Michael Moore and Politics: Is He Relevant?

Chris Radtke
Chris Radtke
  • Published Content: 54
  • Total Views: 35,753
  • Favorited By: 11 CPs
Full Profile | Subscribe | Add to Favorites
Michael Moore is stirring up controversy again. Moore remarked on Friday that the timing of Hurricane Gustav's landfall on the Gulf Coast to coincide with the first day of the Republican National Convention in Minneapolis is "proof that there is a God in heaven". This quote is one of a long line o
f statements and films by Michael Moore that show he is no friend to the Republican Party.

There is absolutely no doubt that Michael Moore has the right to hold the opinions that he holds and has the right to express them. In my opinion, the issue with Michael Moore is that he takes his preconceived notions into his films and tries to pass them off as documentaries, which are typically considered objective and factual. According to Wikipedia, a documentary is "a broad category of visual expression that is based on the attempt, in one fashion or another, to 'document' reality". The process used to "document reality" is best when it is objective and when you haven't decided on a pre-determined outcome, which Michael Moore often has.

Michael Moore has a long (and profitable) history of anti-Republican statements and films. Moore has made several films masquerading as documentaries. Among his most popular films are the following:

Roger & Me - This film that launched Michael Moore's career in 1989 follows Moore's attempts to secure an interview with GM Chief Executive Officer Roger Smith to discuss GM's closure of a Flint, Michigan plant that resulted in 30,000 lost jobs.

Bowling for Columbine - An anti-firearm "documentary" from 2002 in the wake of the Columbine tragedy.

Fahrenheit 911 - A 2004 Michael Moore film that investigated the Administration's reaction to 9/11 and the subsequent War on Terror.

Sicko - Michael Moore's 2007 film that attacked the North American healthcare system.

 
Comments 1 - 4 of 4  
Comments
Type in Your Comments Below
Give me Ben Stein any day!!

Posted on 10/26/2008 at 10:10:54 PM

I'll admit that the man has some relevant points to make. However, the way he goes about making them turns me completely off. I find myself going in the opposite direction simply because he is too obnoxious for words. I prefer to listen to people who can present their case openly, honestly, and politely. None of those words describes this man.

Posted on 10/03/2008 at 6:10:24 AM

I see your points of view. From my vantage point, Moore tries to use the term documentary to create an illusion of objectivity to suck in the independent-minded folks. Let's face it, he wants the viewers and the money, and if he only marketed his films to his die-hard fans, they'd be failures. Yes, there must be people who ask the hard questions. However, if you ask a question, and already have the answer in mind, you'll never be open to other possibilities. As far as Fox News, while they do lean right, they have a large number of left-leaning hosts and contributors. Even O'Reilly (who claims to be independent, but clearly isn't), will criticize the administration on many issues even if he does agree with them on others. Now Olbermann on MSNBC is another story. I have never heard him say one positive thing about the administration (such as record contributions to AIDS research in Africa).

Posted on 09/26/2008 at 6:09:56 AM

But he doesn't pretend to be an objective documentary maker. He's making his case -- I think it's a good case, as far as Sicko goes, at least. He's no more objective than Fox News; the only difference is that he doesn't pretend not to have a point of view, and they sometimes do pretend to be "fair and balanced." By the way, when "documentaries" began, they were things like CBS's White Paper, "Harvest of Shame," about migrant workers. They didn't pretend to be objective either. Sometimes you need someone who's not objective to be willing to ask the hard questions that the mainstream newspeople never ask.

Posted on 09/25/2008 at 7:09:58 AM

Comments 1 - 4 of 4 

Have more to say?
Become a Content Producer on AC