New Medical Study Shows Epidurals Inhibit Nursing Instincts

A new study published in the International Breastfeeding Journal, a peer-reviewed medical journal, confirms what many have been saying for years; that epidurals can have a negative effect on infants, specifically impacting their ability to nurse properly.

Spearheaded by Siranda Torvaldsen the study followed 1,280 women, the largest sample of any study of this type. The results were surprising and have led some to call for action. In fact, Dr. Sue Jordan, senior lecturer in applied therapeutics at Swansea University called for more
 long-term research into the effects of epidural opioid medication on newborn babies. She also said the evidence from this research warrants breastfeeding difficulties being added to the list of "adverse drug reactions" even though it isn't a reaction by the mother, but rather an adverse reaction to the baby.

The Study: 1,280 women who had given birth were studied. Of those 416 received epidural pain relief during their labor. This was a cohort, observational study meaning that the women were not assigned to specific medication vs non-medication groups, but rather were allowed to act on their own and the results followed to determine the effects. (Authors note: British women have a 40% epidural rate; in America the percentage of laboring mothers receiving epidurals is much higher, giving this even a higher impact on children in the States)

The Results: While 93 percent of women attempted breast feeding in the first week, those who had received epidural medications during labor has more difficulty establishing a good breast feeding routine in the critical first few days.

At the 24-week mark 72% of the women who did not receive epidurals were still breast feeding but only 53% of the women who received epidurals were still breast feeding at all. The number one reason given for no longer breast feeding was that the baby simply "refused to nurse". Over a third of the mothers no longer breast feeding gave up within the first week and 55% quit nursing their infants within the first month and a half.

Related information
  • More Childbirth Articles
 
Comments 1 - 6 of 6  
Comments
Type in Your Comments Below

This is a great article. Now I see why it was hard for my daughter when she was nursing. I wouldn't get an epidural with my boys, thank God. I want to encourage all mothers to try your hardest to nurse!! I did all 3 of mine. It is rewarding for years to come!! My children hardly ever get sick.

Posted on 12/23/2006 at 9:12:00 AM

Very interesting article!

Posted on 12/22/2006 at 11:12:00 AM

Obviously epidural vs. non-epidural is not the only factor in regards to whether a mom breast feeds or not, or ever whether it is easy for her to breast feed or not; but I do find the full study interesting. I agree that ALL breastfeeding mothers need more support; more help, more protection from cultural inhibitions, etc.

Posted on 12/21/2006 at 2:12:00 PM

Angela... my second delivery was assisted by vacuum because of the eipidural completely cut off my ability to feel anything and I lost control over those muscles... even with the nurse (and she was panicky) pushing down with me and tell me when to do so, I still couldn't force my muscles to listen to my commands. Needless to say, my third child was born natural. I noticed a major difference in my third child's first day - the one born naturally.

Posted on 12/21/2006 at 8:12:00 AM

I had two natural births also and my daughter, Brianna, was able to roll over front to back the day she was born. She rolled over back to front within the week. Very strong muscular control, head control, etc.

Posted on 12/21/2006 at 6:12:00 AM

This type of research needs to be out there for moms. Epidurals are SO common in our culture that we've gotten politically correct about them...even if there is a question about them, God forbid someone mention that to the public. My daughter was SO alert, and acted like a 1month old right after birth and I 100% believe that it because of no meds in her system. Family and Drs both noticed how awake and alert she was. She nursed beautifully and nursed until 10 months (would have continued if I had not started substituting formula!) I never udnerstood my firends who just "couldn't breastfeed"....they all had epidurals. Actually, out of all the mothers who delivered without meds (probably know a couple dozen)I don't know a single one who had difficulty breastfeeding. Hmmm....

Posted on 12/21/2006 at 6:12:00 AM

Comments 1 - 6 of 6