Thinking of Dyeing Your Hair at Home with Garnier® Nutrisse?

You Might Want to Reconsider

The packaging on the Garnier® Nutrisse Nourishing Color Creme was lovely, capitalizing on the color one might call "Garnier® Green" - as it is the same used on the line of shampoos and conditioners Garnier® also produces. The price appeared reasonable, at less than 8 bucks
 from my local drugstore. The hair color, 76 Rich Auburn Blonde aka "Hot Tamale", appeared to be exactly what I'd had in mind. Once I saw the word "nourishing" on the box and realized there was (in addition to the standard developer, colorant and conditioner) a fruit oil concentrate included, I was sold.

When the time came to dye my hair, all seemed to be in order. All the components were present and accounted for, including form-fitting latex gloves, which I was (I am now ashamed to admit) pleased to see. I learned that the fruit oil concentrate actually went in at the developer stage, and after dutifully reading the directions, my assistant and I prepared to turn me into a "Hot Tamale" redhead.

The first problem I noticed was the gloves. I had been pleased, as I said, because they were form-fitting and not the over-sized paper-thin kind one normally sees. As I quickly discovered, however, latex plus hair dye equals lots of pulled hair. I also noticed issue number 2 which was the far-stronger-than-average chemical odor. When she began applying it, my assistant's eyes began to water. We were in a living room with a ceiling fan at the time, so close quarters/poor ventilation were not to blame.

The third issue came when my assistant showed me the first section of my hair to which she had just applied the colorant-developer-fruit oil solution. The hair appeared to be completely dry. I knew the package said "no-drip", but this was rather an extreme definition, I felt. She added a little more and we achieved a sort of oiled look.

Related information
 
Comments 1 - 8 of 8  
Comments
Type in Your Comments Below

Jayde, as I have explained, I have been dyeing my hair (and the hair of others) for over 20 years - and most of the time it was some variation of red. I know how hair dye works. I know what it smells like. I know that the color on the box will not exactly match the result. NONE of what I experienced was in any way common to at home coloring with quality hair dye. If what I describe has been your typical experience (and that of anonymous), I suggest you buy better quality dyes.

Posted on 07/07/2009 at 4:07:47 PM

It's pretty common for red dye to "bleed" for several washes after coloring. Last time I dyed my hair red, it bled for weeks (keep in mind that my hair is very long; almost hits my tailbone). I could stand under the shower head for an hour rinsing my hair and the water would still not run clear. I know how annoying it is. The color is almost always misrepresented on box dyes. If you have dark hair you will probably not be able to achieve the color it indicates you will on the side. It's annoying, but after the color fades a bit, it'll look more like the color you were aiming for. As far as the odor, the chemical smell of a fresh-dye job usually lingers for quite a while. Everything you experienced is pretty common when it comes to at-home coloring. If it bothers you that much, a salon is your best bet.

Posted on 07/07/2009 at 4:07:42 PM

Hmmm, lemme see here... Anonymous says dying hair red leaves residue on towels. Well, my wife dyes her hair red and it never leaves dye on the towel, even the white one. I never smell the dye in her hair, just the hairspray... Now who's the chickenshit moron?

Posted on 06/16/2009 at 7:06:14 AM

So, anonymous, how long have you worked for Garnier? I am neither a moron nor a liar. In those 20 years of dyeing my hair myself, I have used red dyes nearly every single time. I have never left stains on a towel before unless I failed to rinse it long enough, which was NOT the case here. I also know what freshly dyed hair smells like and how long that smell lingers, and this was NOT the normal after-odor of dye. It smelled like I was freshly dipped in perm solution. And as you can see, other people have agreed with me. Of course, anonymously hurling insults doesn't exactly support any claim to expertise or intelligence on your part, does it? So feel free to go out and buy as many boxes of this stuff as you like and enjoy the results. Or does your employer give it to you for free?

Posted on 06/14/2009 at 12:06:10 PM

You're a moron. RED hair dye will ALWAYS fade when washing. Meaning, you will NEVER be able to dry your hair on a towel without it leaving stains. And its dye. It'll always smell like chemicals for the first 2-3 washes. You'd think after 20 years of dyeing your hair yourself, you'd know better.

Posted on 06/14/2009 at 11:06:24 AM

i wish i would have read this before i bought the product. it makes you feel sick. eww, and the odor....

Posted on 04/19/2009 at 1:04:27 AM

Thanks for writing this. I'll remember never to uses that brand.

Posted on 10/23/2008 at 9:10:22 AM

Ooh you are so right about this product, you hit it right on the nail, hate this stuff!!! Great read

Posted on 10/17/2008 at 4:10:43 PM

Comments 1 - 8 of 8