Find » Opinion/Editorial » Presidential Debate #2: Who Won, Jo...

Presidential Debate #2: Who Won, John McCain or Barack Obama?

Town Hall Meeting Format Favored by McCain Fails to Change Race

By Roger Gowens (AKA RazorsEdge), published Oct 07, 2008
Published Content: 259  Total Views: 167,273  Favorited By: 13 CPs
Embed:  
Rating: 2.0 of 5
If Sen. John McCain had had his way on the debates, all of the Presidential debates would have been of the "Town Hall" format like the one America just witnessed, or slept through, as the case may be. As David Gergen of CNN, a veteran of both Republican and Democratic presidential politics said, this presidential debate was a rather nondescript affair.

In my view, neither John McCain or Barack Obama made any "game-changing" gaffes to hurt their campaigns. The closet thing to a gaffe was when Barack Obama made a remark about McCain suggesting Obama was "green behind the ears". Senator, one is either "green" as in inexperienced, or "wet behind the ears" which inplies the same. However, I don't see voters letting a little Bushism deciding their vote. In the post-debate anaysis, most of the pundits panned John McCain for his "that one" referral to Obama.

Alas, neither man scored any "zingers" which could define this increasingly nasty presidential election either. Like a football coach "sitting on a lead" to run out the clock , Barack Obama played it safe and stuck to his gameplan.

For his part, John McCain, who is clearly playing "catch-up", threw a few "Hail Mary" passes, most nowhere near the target, and ran the draw play on third and long. A Lot. With such a tepid response to trailing in all the polls with less than 30 days to go before election day, John McCain might as well punt, or have his "enforcer" Sarah Palin punt.

That's somewhat of a mixed metaphor, I suppose, as Sarah Palin constantly refers to herself as a "hockey Mom" and played basketball in school, but John McCain's seeming strategy of hiding behind Palin's skirt is a sure way to lose the election of Nov. 4.

So, with both John McCain and Barack Obama "playing it safe", who won the latest Presidential debate? America didn't win for sure, but by staying calm Barack Obama seemed "Presidential" while John McCain seemed erratic and scattershot in his attempts to undermine Obama's lead in the polls. McCain's attempts at humor went over like a turd in a punch bowl. The one thing many viewers may take away from McCain's performance is the comment about needing "hairplugs".

Comments
Comments 1 - 2 of 2
 
 
I think the Dow will determine the election, not the debate. It will end up being all about the economy and people will vote based on their feelings about that and the candidates.

Posted on 10/08/2008 at 7:10:10 AM

 
I agree that McCain didn't change the momentum of this election. I think the home owner bail out is an absolute necessity. Spending the money of all the people will not resolve the current crisis. In order to resolve the current crisis, we must focus on the problems that contributed to this economic crisis. We must resolve the credit crunch so that store will be able to obtain loans to restock their shelves, so that people will be able to get loans and so that manufacturers can resolve cash flow problems. The first indicator of this deep recession was foreclosures. If we don't resolve the main issues that are causing this deep recession, then we may very well end up with a depression. People don't comprehend or don't want to comprehend any problem that requries Federa intervention. The typical conservative response won't work. Federal intevention is a necessity and I applaud McCain for supporting the bail out.

Posted on 10/08/2008 at 12:10:49 AM

Type in Your Comments Below - (1000 characters left)

Submit your own content on this or any topic. Get started »
Comments 1 - 2 of 2
 
Advertisment