Differences Between a Normal Public School and a Charter School

By Jackie Walker, published Dec 31, 2006
Published Content: 9  Total Views: 1,570  Favorited By: 2 CPs
Rating: 2.0 of 5
As a parent, I have seen many things in the public school system that drastically need improvement. Too often, the cures suggested are financial... throw enough money at the problem and it will go away. Yes, a good education costs a certain amount of money, but money is not the cure-all. More important than money is qualified, dedicated teachers, involved parents supporting the school's activities, and students who are eager to learn. The school district my son was in has different standards at each school. The children must then learn the ropes as they move from school to school as they progress toward graduation.

My son Jaxom is in 2nd grade. I removed him from the school he was supposed to attend because the principal there would not make any provisions for a gifted and talented student. Her gifted and talented program consisted of giving G&T students extra work. They were required to do the same classwork everyone else was expected to do, plus extra work too. Naturally, the gifted children regard this as punishment, though it is not intended to be.

I saw the biggest danger for Jaxom as a 2nd grader to be boredom. In kindergarten and 1st grade, he was well on the way to becoming a G&T underachiever. But Mrs. J, the principal, would not consider allowing Jaxom to be tested (credit by examination) to skip 2nd grade. She would allow no special concessions even as far as curriculum before November. Well, by then Jaxom would have been so bored he would have been in trouble and possibly even had an "in school suspension" or two under his belt. This was not acceptable to me, so I started making phone calls, looking for other options.

The first phone call I made was to a neighboring school district with an exemplary G&T program. I was told that they could not accept out of district students, but had I heard of Rapaport Academy, a local charter school? No, I had not. They gave me the phone number for this charter school. I called immediately and got the information I needed to start the pre-admision testing process.

Differences Between a Normal Public School and a Charter School

Jackie Walker

Credit: Jackie Walker

Copyright: Jackie Walker

Comments
Showing Comments 1 - 11 of 11
 
 
Richelle, Ah! Now I see what you mean. Well, so I messed up! I'll try to do better next time. But the school my son attends must be doing SOMETHING right, since all the kids are passing the TAKS every time they take it, from 3rd grade on up. I suspect it is because they are a "Core Knowledge" school rather than a school that spends 7 months of their year merely teaching the children how to pass the TAKS test. The textbooks the local school districts use as BORING - but that's how they teach the kids to pass the TAKS. Anyway, thanks for your comments.

Posted on 03/27/2007 at 5:03:00 PM

 
Jackie--We've been going to charter schools for 8 years now--I agree that they are beneficial, wasn't arguing. The very title of your article promises to compare charter schools to 'normal' schools (a better term might be 'traditional'--charter schools aren't exactly bohemian casbahs as some would like to assert) but there aren't many, if any comparisons.

Posted on 03/26/2007 at 12:03:00 AM

 
Richelle, in the first paragraph I told everyone to fix the educational woes of the public school system we need to do more than "throw money at it. More important than money is qualified, dedicated teachers, involved parents supporting the school's activities, and students who are eager to learn." That short list right there is the biggest difference between your standard public school and charter schools or private schools. The teachers and the parents are more involved with the children! There is also a lower turn-over rate of teachers. The atmosphere is less one of "us against them" and more one of "lets see what we can learn today, and it makes the whole day more fun. I cannot even begin to describe the difference to you. But I will tell you this. My 2nd grader used to HATE going to school Now, he gets mad at me for not taking him to school when he's sick!

Posted on 03/10/2007 at 1:03:00 AM

 
I didn't really find any information here about how charter schools differ from "normal" public schools.

Posted on 02/22/2007 at 8:02:00 PM

 
I used my jacket and the zipper!! The zipped up zipper was the DNA strand before replication. When a section had to be transcribed, it would unzip and be duplicated, and then zip up again. Or, if just duplicating for cell division, the entire strand would reproduce itself as soon as it unzipped. I showed the class how DNA does NOT like to be single strand, but always double. If you force it to unzip, it will automatically duplicate. It was cool when I could see them start to understand!!

Posted on 01/17/2007 at 12:01:00 AM

 
The choices were so much more limited back then. That is one advantage we have now over then. But many teachers now seem to be less flexible in teaching strategies. As a substitute teacher, I use any method my fertile imagination can come up with to try to get a concept across to the students. I remember trying to get DNA replication across to my Biology class. Do you know how I did it?

Posted on 01/17/2007 at 12:01:00 AM

 
I'm not really sure why the State boards of Education won't learn from the Charter school "experiements." I certainly wish they would. Back in my own public school days, I can remember how sad it made me to watch classmates "fall through the cracks" of the public school system. And since I graduated from high school in 1978, there were no choices like charter schools or magnet schools back then.

Posted on 01/17/2007 at 12:01:00 AM

 
As a grandmother of two grandsons (ages 7 and 8)who are in the gifted and talented category it has been my observation that they present a unique problem for public school. One boy lives in Colorado while the other lives in Texas. So you see it is not simply a matter of a particular locale. Each boy is in a Charter school. The classes are smaller, they learn according to their ability. They are challenged in areas where needed.All the children, regardless of their abilities, are learning at an astounding rate. Why can't or maybe it should be stated as "won't" the school boards learn a lesson from the Charter School?

Posted on 01/16/2007 at 11:01:00 PM

 
As a grandmother of two grandsons (ages 7 and 8)who are in the gifted and talented category it has been my observation that they present a unique problem for public school. One boy lives in Colorado while the other lives in Texas. So you see it is not simply a matter of a particular locale. Each boy is in a Charter school. The classes are smaller, they learn according to their ability. They are challenged in areas where needed.All the children, regardless of their abilities, are learning at an astounding rate. Why can't or maybe it should be stated as "won't" the school boards learn a lesson from the Charter School?

Posted on 01/16/2007 at 11:01:00 PM

 
Trouble is, so many people are busy just trying to survive that they don't take the time to get involved. I'll admit that I was just as guilty before I had my two sons. I put my now 25 year old son into a private school for preschool through 1st grade because I knew he needed more than the El Paso, TX public schools could give him. Then, I learned that his school didn't have enough 2nd and 3rd graders to have separate classes, and couldn't give him all the individual attention he needed while still giving all the other students the attention THEY needed. So he left that school after 1st grade. That was when I starting home schooling. Now, professional educators will tell you that you need special training to be able to teach. I would disagree. What you do need is discipline and the ability to read something and then turn around and explain it to someone else. There were times in our home schooling days when I was just a half-step ahead of my son - like when we studied French in

Posted on 01/05/2007 at 8:01:00 PM

 
Well written, mom, and I couldn't agree with you more. I saw first hand the troubles that plague public schools during the latter part of my high school (yes, boot camp counts!), and it was sadly lacking in many ways. If only more people would learn to think the way you do, then our nation's children might just have a better life ahead of them.

Posted on 01/02/2007 at 10:01:00 PM

Type in Your Comments Below - (1000 characters left)
Your name:

Submit your own content on this or any topic. Get started »
Showing Comments 1 - 11 of 11
 
Most Commented On