Find » Society » History » Anti-Protest Protesting and the Pol...

Anti-Protest Protesting and the Politics Located Therein

By J Gorman, published Jan 09, 2007
Published Content: 124  Total Views: 102,729  Favorited By: 4 CPs
Embed:  
Rating: 4.0 of 5
This past weekend, a funeral cemetery service was held in honor of a local fallen soldier [from Pennsylvania]. Ordinarily, this seemingly normal event might bring one or two headlines detailing the soldier being laid to rest and his or her accomplishments. In this particular case (and far too many of late to count) however, there is much more buzz surrounding the occasion.

While visiting my grandfather shortly before Christmas, I learned that he, along with several other members of a group to which he belongs, would be partaking in an anti-protest protest. Now, before you begin to think negatively about the politics of protesting a protest and its apparent contradictory nature (my immediate thought was one in the same), please continue reading.

You may remember hearing the name Westboro Baptist Church (WBC), based in Topeka, Kansas, which was formed in 1955 by Pastor Fred Phelps. Its websites include: godhatesfags.com, godhatesamerica.com, hatemongers.com, and thesignsofthetimes.net, among others. The church received national attention for its picketing of gay rights (beginning with the funeral of Matthew Shepard) and the funerals of fallen soldiers as well as its planned picket of the funeral for those children killed during this past summer's Amish School shooting. The last item was cancelled to comply with the terms and conditions of a deal made for Phelps to be allowed an hour's time on the Mike Gallagher Show. To me, the message is clear cut -- it is readily apparent that the church cares more about publicity than they do about upholding their values.

Anti-Protest Protesting and the Politics Located Therein
Anti-Protest Protesting and the Politics Located Therein

What does the U.S. flag represent?

Credit: tome213

Copyright: Copyright-Free

Takeaways
  • The bill bans unapproved demonstrations at federal cemeteries, including Arlington National Cemetery, and also restricts protesting within 500 feet of any military cemetery one hour before, during, and until one hour after the ceremony.
  • The issue remains to be the constitutionality of these provisions in law.
  • Maybe the best solution follows in the path of the group to which my grandfather belongs and the Patriot Guard Riders, who demonstrate their freedoms in counteracting those with which they disagree.
Did You Know?
The actions of Westboro Baptist Church prompted the formation of the Patriot Guard Riders, whose objective is to show sincere respect for fallen heroes, their families, and their communities in shielding them from interruptions created by any protestors.
Comments
Comment 1 of 1
 
 
I'm as big of Constitution and Bill of Rights advocate as anyone. There is a clause in the law regarding freedom of speech and right to assemble. Using hate words and hateful actions meant to spark violence is not covered by the Constitution or Bill of Rights. It's called The Fighting Words Doctrine and was written by Justice Frank Murphy in 1942 and has been repeatedly upheld as good law ever since. Ironically, it was first decided in a case that involved a Jehovas Witness spreading hate talk. (Chaplinsky v. New Hampshire, 315 U.S. 568 (1942))

Posted on 02/20/2007 at 8:02:00 PM

Type in Your Comments Below - (1000 characters left)

Submit your own content on this or any topic. Get started »
Comment 1 of 1
 
Advertisment