Why is Christian Music Inferior?

By Steve Hicks, published Jan 02, 2007
Published Content: 31  Total Views: 15,798  Favorited By: 7 CPs
Embed:  
Rating: 4.4 of 5
As a working musician for going on 20+ years now and a Christian for going on 5 years now a question has plagued me recently. Why is the musicianship, songwriting and overall quality of the music released under the "Christian" label so often inferior to that in the secular world?

In my youth, I grew up listening to a very eclectic blend of music. My dad, being a locally popular country performer introduced me to George Jones, Waylon Jennings and Merle Haggard. Additionally, because of his penchant for crossing genres in his music, I was introduced to country acts with a little rock flavor and also the inverse. I learned to love Lynyrd Skynyrd, Bob Seger, ZZ Top and the grandfathers of all three chord bar bands Creedence Clearwater Revival, with their genius singer/songwriter/guitarist John C. Fogerty.

Later, as I developed my own subjective tastes I began to delve into Hendrix, Clapton, Led Zeppelin and the like. As you might figure, I came to realize that all these great performers were rooted in the blues, which lead me to my greatest "discovery" at age 13, Stevie Ray Vaughan. My eyes were opened and I was onto something that hit me in the souls like a ton of bricks...The Blues. I was hooked and it has infected my listening habits and playing style on several instruments since then. I fell in love with Freddie King, Johnny Winter, Robert Cray, Muddy, The Wolf...all of 'em.

As a high school student in the mid 80's I began to hear some other styles. My classmates were into Ozzy, Metallica, AC/DC plus all the "hair bands" from the era. Poison, Cinderella, Winger. That's when I realized I was able to discern good music from bad. The hair bands were invariably bad in my book. To each his own I guess. I vaguely remember a couple of "Christian" bands from that time. Literally a couple. Petra and Stryper. That's it. And I remember not knowing much about either of them as the Christian marketing machine was not yet in motion. I remember seeing a Stryper video abnd thinking "wow, Christian hair bands are just as bad as the others."

Why is Christian Music Inferior?

I know there are those out there who do have the gift and the desire to make Christian music valid, relevant, and radical.

Credit: Wild About Music

Copyright: Wild About Music

Comments
Showing Comments 1 - 15 of 58
Next >>
 
What about Johnny Lang or Michael Montgomery? You can't have songs on MTV that have the word Jesus in them. Stifling Christians is what Satan wants. There are some most excellent Christian players out there that don't need drugs or alcohol to entice their creative juices. They get their music from God and it is the best music in the world if you would just open your ears and listen!!! The world system is going to crash soon and I hope that by the time it does you are on the right side!!!! God Bless you... It sounds like you need it.

Posted on 07/08/2008 at 10:07:06 PM

 
Because religious people are generally of lower intelligence, and connected that that is a lessened sense of creativity. The peak of christian music (Bach) occured during an era when people didn't know any better. This trend will no doubt continue, as religion more and more becomes a bastion of the irrational and intellectually weak. Most of the best 20th century rock music was made by atheists.

Posted on 07/08/2008 at 9:07:44 AM

 
Bro good artical, but i feel You've been decieved to turn away from Christ. Worship music is ment to be simple, easy to remember and perform. Allowing those of all ages and walks of life a way to take part in worship of God through music and singing praise. For ages people did'nt have their own personal Bible, paper wasnt cheap, and the printing press was hundreds to thousands of years away. They would sing simple psalms to pass the time as they worked, and worshiped at temple. Complex is not always better bro, its a message God has been sending us for Years, "Slow down, stop and listen for me" Forget about worldly trappings, and seek the father" If Your making music from Your heart to please God, great that all He wants from You is Your heart. If Your making music to please man, and seek mans stamp of approval as great music, then your setting yourself up for dissapointment. Man will let you down most of the time. Find a quiet place and pray to God to show You a path to

Posted on 03/26/2008 at 11:03:50 PM

 
Steve, those certainly were very helpful and constructive comments. Thank you. Now it was all worth it.

Posted on 06/06/2007 at 9:06:00 AM

 
Are you in a position to define what is valid, relevant and radical in any kind of music? First of all, where do you think a super talneted musician is going to seek fame and fortune? Secondly, why do you think that any person listens to or plays Christian music? Music is a personal medium, religion is a spiritual and personal choice. I think you've got your priorities mixed up. So you stepped away from doing praise music to think about how it should be done? That makes no sense to me at all, like your article.

Posted on 06/06/2007 at 8:06:00 AM

 
I've read you'll know them by how they live. I was raised on the music of the Jesuits, fine fer the time and the nostalgia. Music in all venues is appreciated by the listener or it dies. Music is like prayin' twice so do your best and leave the rest up to God.

Posted on 05/19/2007 at 6:05:00 PM

 
Wow, I can't believe you put Switchfoot with Creed. Sounds like you need to buy the last few Switchfoot albums and sit down to have a listen. They are really unique, fun, thoughtful, deep, hard, soft, and real.

Posted on 05/02/2007 at 7:05:00 AM

 
I wonder if this has to do with our definitions of quality vs. God's definition of quality. We typically define quality music as melodious with a definable rhythm...can you remember it? etc. According to that definition, yes perhaps Christian music is a little lacking. On the other hand, I believe God values honesty, brokenness, sincerity, and seeking after Him (all matters of the heart). In that respect, yes Christian music is fairly high quality.

Posted on 01/16/2007 at 11:01:00 AM

 
Stain I actually do intend to write an article about your previous comment on art... the earlier churches abuse of it, and hampering of it. I love the movie Dogma. As a Christian I believe God has a sense of humor. In fact i know he does, because he created me and I laugh every time I look in the mirror. But for a tidbit... I would encourage you to watch the movie "The Agony and The Ecstacy" and watch carefully for exactly which fights Michaelangelo fought with the Pope about. It was not that he was expected to pain a religious theme. It was that the religious theme the Pope originally wanted was not what was in Michaelangelo's heart to paint. Had he not fought, we would not have the Cistine Chapel.

Posted on 01/09/2007 at 5:01:00 PM

 
Compare Hark the Herald Angels to any contemporary praise music for Christmas. Which is the more powerful, musically and lyrically? Which one causes that chill to go down your spine? It ain't Christmas with Carmen. We've certainly lost that wonderful music and poetic talent in this genre. Sorry, folks, but Michael W. Smith is weak. His music and that of his contemporaries make me want to vomit. The FBI would be better served using their music for psychological intimidation in stand offs than Nancy Sinatra's "These Boots Were Made for Walking." That's actually a great tune.

Posted on 01/08/2007 at 5:01:00 PM

 
Stain, I appreciate the opinions, but you aren't really offering anything but "Christians are stupid." And maybe a Kevin Smith commercial.

Posted on 01/08/2007 at 5:01:00 PM

 
I couldn't have said it better. Us Christians, myself included, tend to be dogmatic and love our extra-biblical rules. The generation before us said drums and rock music were of the devil. Now that we have drums and bonafide Christian rock, we box it in by refusing certain styles and say that progressive experimentation is bad, therefore less holy, therefore unholy, yada yada yada. Some other bizarre things as well. I gave up on Christian radio stations years ago. They're pathetic. Christians have more musicians percentage-wise than non-Christians (Everyone's encouraged to be on a worship team, practically) yet 90 percent of our music is simple fodder. Yes, the message is important, but that doesn't mean you should write lazy music. We've turned a blind eye to our Grammy winning sophomoric artists because they love Jesus. We have several groups that literally rip off bigger name acts, and I'm not talking about the Apologetix alone. Those guys are horrible. Then we criticize true talent

Posted on 01/08/2007 at 5:01:00 PM

 
Steve, I'm not a musician, so maybe I look at this with a different view, but I do believe it is the message that is most important, not the esthetics, which are in the ears of the beholder anyway. The nature of most christians is that of practicality and often puritanical, kind of opposite most musicians or artistic types. Also, I don't think Switchfoot deserves to be lumped with Creed. Meant to Live and Dare you to move are much deeper than anything Creed ever did and could be considered Christian Anthems. I do agree too much of Christian music is derivative, but you could say that of most music. The good doesn't have to be the enemy of the perfect.

Posted on 01/07/2007 at 8:01:00 PM

 
i had a second comment that was deleted! notice how everyone posting is cristian, REAL nice discussion. i really think you guys are getting somewhere. see the movie, "dogma". funny how the more religious the person, the more narrow minded they tend to be. enjoy each other, please leave me behind, we'll make better music/art/theater/public policy/society. sorry for being so bitter, but i'm providing balance.

Posted on 01/06/2007 at 6:01:00 PM

 
"you shall know them by their fruits".

Posted on 01/05/2007 at 11:01:00 AM

Type in Your Comments Below - (1000 characters left)
Your name:

Submit your own content on this or any topic. Get started »
Showing Comments 1 - 15 of 58
Next >>
Most Commented On