Find » Sports » Is it Time to Build an Alternative ...

Is it Time to Build an Alternative Baseball Cheaters Hall of Fame?

Mark McGwire's Failure to Get into Baseball Hall of Fame on First Ballot Points to the Need for a Special Hall for Today's Players

By Timothy Sexton, published Jan 19, 2007
Published Content: 3,004  Total Views: 2,630,829  Favorited By: 241 CPs
Embed:  
Rating: 4.3 of 5
Hey, did you hear the big news? Mark McGwire failed to get into the Baseball Hall of Fame on the first ballot. Loud outcries were heard across the country; so were cheers. Despite the fact Mark McGwire briefly held the record for most home runs in a single season and despite the fact that he hit almost 600 career dingers-as sure a path to entry into the Baseball Hall of Fame as there is, typically-the baseball writers of America didn't seen fit to include Mark McGwire among that select few who make it on the first ballot. Why?

Two words and an ampersand: Steroids & lying. Mark McGwire has much in common with Barry Bonds and I'm not talking about single season home run records. I'm talking about two rookies who were almost ridiculously skinny turning into two veterans who look like Popeye. If there is any doubt remaining in anyone's mind that Mark McGwire MAY have taken steroids to juice his power numbers, I really cannot suggest vociferously enough that you look at McGwire's rookie card and then look at his card from his record breaking season. A physical transformation like that 300 years ago would have gotten McGwire stoned to death as witch in Salem, Mass. It just ain't normal. Like Barry Bonds, there is simply no way Mark McGwire could have changed his physical appearance merely through strength training. I guess. I mean, hey, I'm not physical fitness expert. But this is what my physical fitness expert acquaintances tell me.

The argument, of course, is that since Barry Bonds and who knows how many others are doing exactly the same thing, why not let Mark McGwire into the Hall of Fame? It's a level playing field; McGwire MAY have taken advantage of steroids, but so MAY have Bonds and everyone else. So it's not like Mark McGwire really had any advantage over anyone else, right?

Well.........

Is it Time to Build an Alternative Baseball Cheaters Hall of Fame?

A call goes out to build a Baseball Cheaters Hall of Fame.

Credit: Timothy Sexton

Copyright: Timothy Sexton 2007

Takeaways
  • Despite the fact Mark McGwire hit almost 600 career homers, he was not voted into the Hall of Fame on the first ballot.
  • There are two words for this: steroids & lying.
  • The argument that steroid use is rampant so no one has an advantage belittles the accomplishment of players from the pre-steroid era.
Did You Know?
In his first foru years in the bigs, Barry Bonds hit 84 home runs. From 2000 through 2003, hit 213. Surely, there must be some other reason than performance-enhancing drugs to account for that phenomenal rise in production.
Comments
Showing Comments 1 - 11 of 11
 
 
If there WAS a cheater's HOF, Hal Chase would be the President. He invented cheating in baseball.

Posted on 07/04/2008 at 12:07:41 PM

 
Wow Rick... I'm impressed by your comment. (Timothy-- well written article) I'm not even a big major league baseball fan (I'm liking the futbol), but just reading what you have to say, I agree. It's the Hall of Fame... those guys are famous... mostly from being good players. They wanted to be better and used what they believed would help them at the time, and back then, it was legal. ~Heather James -- AC Content Producer (page is messed up where we were all listed as Gretchen B. and I cannot log in)

Posted on 01/21/2007 at 1:01:00 PM

 
What everyone seems to forget is that A) doing steroids wasn't illegal during the time they were allegedly doing steroids, and B) nobody has proven anything to anyone about whether they actually did them. It has not been proven. Do I think McGwire belongs? Yeah, but not on the first ballot. Bonds? Yup. Rose? Absolutely. Everyone talks about the sanctity of the game, but that argument is absurd in the face of facts. Baseball is a DIRTY GAME. Ty Cobb is in the Hall and he cheated for a living. What about the dozen or so spitball pitchers in the Hall? Cooperstown is a baseball MUSEUM. It's a place to go learn about the history of baseball. McGwire and Bonds, Sosa and Rose, all of them are a part of baseball's history, and in all of their cases, baseball profited much from having them in the game. Now baseball writers - who cheered louder than anyone when McGwire and Sosa were duking it out in '98 - are going to keep them out? Does that make sense?

Posted on 01/21/2007 at 12:01:00 PM

 
Well put Rashawn, but as of yet it still has to be proven if McGwire was only using legal substances. His performance in front of Congress did nothing to boost that case.

Posted on 01/20/2007 at 2:01:00 PM

 
So is going to be the President of this new Cheaters Hall of Fame? I vote Jose Canseco.

Posted on 01/20/2007 at 2:01:00 PM

 
I'm a young fan of baseball and I wouldn't mind seeing Mark in the hall of fame. Pete Rose wouldn't do much harm to me either. It could be cause of my youth or it could simply be how I feel about it. But Mark did what every athlete does, try to seperate himself from the field which he did legally--the substance he used was not illegal at the time. Hindsight is always 20-20, but if we're going to include lying as one of the reasons he's left out, why don't we go back and exorcise all of the racists and bigots in cooperstown?

Posted on 01/20/2007 at 9:01:00 AM

 
One thing no one mentions about MCgwire not getting in on the first ballot....he shoudlnt have! He was a one tool player, granted he was very good at that one tool, power, but he wasn't a great average hitter, couldn't play a lick of defense and couldnt really run. 2nd ballot ...yes becasue of the homers, first....absolutely not. I dont think he should ever get in, but there is no question he shouldn't be a first ballot guy. Same goes for Sosa, he cost many games for the Cubs becasue of his terrible D. Bonds on the other hand, is, or was one of the most complete players ever, before the juice. He would be a first-ballot guy if he wasn't a juice monster. Nice article though.

Posted on 01/20/2007 at 9:01:00 AM

 
Hey, at least Pete Rose didn't do steroids! Great article.

Posted on 01/20/2007 at 12:01:00 AM

 
P.S. I hear you're a Sports Writer for AC. hehe.

Posted on 01/19/2007 at 6:01:00 PM

 
Preach on Brother Tim! If someone did a time-lapse comparison of the cards over the years it would look like an episode of The Incredible Hulk, only with out the green skin. Some winners are losers.

Posted on 01/19/2007 at 6:01:00 PM

 
Ouch. Nice article. I guess Bonds has now said that both McGwire and Rose belong in the hall. Surprise, surprise.

Posted on 01/19/2007 at 5:01:00 PM

Type in Your Comments Below - (1000 characters left)
Your name:

Submit your own content on this or any topic. Get started »
Showing Comments 1 - 11 of 11
 
Most Commented On