Traditional Theory: Thucydidesin, Hobbes in Today's World

There is Still Much that Can Be Learned from Thucydides

By Jean Marquit, published Nov 22, 2005
Published Content: 302  Total Views: 528,901  Favorited By: 15 CPs
Rating: 3.0 of 5
While neither Hobbes nor Thucydides had much to say about international relations directly, their commentaries on human nature and war (and peace) have been applied to international relations for quite some time. Hobbes himself "expressly licenses the translation of his analysis of the state of war among individuals to the level of international rivalry" (Hanson, 331). Thucydides doesn't often comment on events (possibly why there is not much directly said about relations between city-states), but Larry Pratt asserts that "His [Thucydides'] narrative and the carefully crafted speeches…draw the reader into a deeper understanding of the war…." (Pratt, 442). Hobbes, himself a student of Thucydides (also the first to translate him into English) agrees with this point and states that the reader is instructed subtly, and this is more effective.

It does not necessarily follow that just because there isn't much overtly said about international relations that the writings of Hobbes and Thucydides are not applicable in today's modern world. Hobbes' and Thucydides' (who Hobbes actually takes many of his ideas from) observations and assertions, especially on international dealings through the medium of war, can still be applied to current international relations. Both contend that the driving forces behind relations on an international level, especially war, are the forces of human nature.

Comments
Showing Comment 1 of 1
 
 
very good article, though you might want to comment on real international relations (IR) theory. the realist theory is completely based on hobbes. realist say that there are three principles, one of them is international anarchy, the second is that the ultimate goal of the state is survival (this principle varies from theory to theory)... basically all the questions you ask are answered by introducing some IR theory to your essay

Posted on 05/15/2008 at 5:05:53 PM

Type in Your Comments Below - (1000 characters left)
Your name:

Submit your own content on this or any topic. Get started »
Showing Comment 1 of 1
 
Most Commented On