Transsexuals Please Explain Why Sex Surgery is Necessary?

How Can a Person Feel like They Are the Opposite Sex?

Before Thomas Beatie decided to "become" a man, "he" was in a beauty pageant; so I supposed maybe Thomas Beatie is closer to 5-7. However, according to "Inside Edition," Thomas Beatie's height comes in at 5-10. So ironically, here is this girl who's always wanted to be a man, and Thomas
 Beatie just happens to be as tall as a man; an enviable trait among other female transsexuals who got cheated out of a man's height.

A transsexual is a person who, from an early age, always felt they belonged in the opposite-sex body. Transsexuals report feeling out of place, feeling awkward, and to get others to understand their inner struggle, transsexuals will ask typical people: "If you're a woman, imagine that every morning when you awaken and look in the mirror, you see a man. And if you're a man, imagine that when you awaken, you see a woman in the mirror. That's how a transsexual feels."

Well, I still don't understand.

Transsexuals commonly report that they (prior to sex reassignment surgery) always longed to "live the life" of the opposite gender. My question is: What IS the life of the opposite gender? Now, if I myself went through a sex-change procedure, I would not be living a different life afterwards (except for superficial changes like dressing differently and shaving my face). I would still be doing the same things. So what is the point of having sex reassignment surgery and hormone treatments? Take Thomas Beatie. Why did he tamper with nature by getting hormone injections? And undergo risks of major surgery to have breasts removed? What is Thomas Beatie doing now, that he couldn't do as a woman?

He can shave his face. Well, I doubt that's why Thomas Beatie did what he did. He can bench press 255 pounds, says "Inside Edition." Well, if a woman wants to achieve this, she doesn't have to undergo sex reassignment procedures and have her breasts cut off. Further, I highly doubt the desire to bench press 255 pounds is why Thomas Beatie began taking hormone injections, had breasts removed, and started dressing like a man.

Related information
 
Comments 1 - 7 of 7  
Comments
Type in Your Comments Below

You'll never completely get it because you aren't trans. I'll never get it completely because I'm not trans. I felt much like how you did before I met a friend who was trans. I met him while they were biologically male and they were miserable. It has nothing to do with society or gender roles. Basically, he would look at his body in disgust. He would look at his chest, his penis, his body hair, his adam's apple, and would hate himself because there weren't breasts, silky skin, or a vagina. He had felt this way his entire life and puberty was terrifying because he knew how he felt inside but his body was rebelling. His puberty was ten times as terrifying as what we go through. She has now gone through some of her first surgeries and hormone therapies and will continue with them. She is happier than she has been in her entire life. What makes it harder is that she is bisexual and is now dating a woman. So, she is seen as female, but also trans and dating a woman. You c

Posted on 04/24/2009 at 10:04:56 PM

Entirely agree with the previous Anonymous. Please research more. Stereotypical hobbies are not the basis of transgender/transsexualism.

Posted on 01/27/2009 at 7:01:36 PM

Final sentence: SRS and hormone therapy, however, have proven themselves to be extremely valuable tools to improving the psychological health of a trans person who experiences body dysphoria.

Posted on 01/27/2009 at 1:01:26 PM

There are female-to-male transsexuals who like fashion and the color pink and male-to-female transsexuals who like football and having short-cropped hair. As with non-transsexual people, most trans people are just a mix of whatever activities they happen to enjoy, masculine or feminine. Also, some people don't change their bodies, and still live as the opposite sex. Some don't feel that bodily dysphoria, but still understand themselves to -be- the gender opposite the one they were assigned at birth, and live that way. What does "live that way" mean? It means being called the right pronouns, using the right bathroom, and generally being perceived as the correct gender. It doesn't mean acting in a stereotypical way. Really, you should have done your research before publishing an article. Transsexuals cannot "live as they are." Do you know what that results in? Suicide. SRS and hormone therapy, however, have proven themselves to be extremely valuable tools to improving the psycholog

Posted on 01/27/2009 at 1:01:09 PM

You don't get it because you refuse to get it. You've taken one offhand comment about "living like" and taken it to be the entire transsexual experience. You're right that activities are not gender specific, and that a woman can work on cars; that a man can like flowers and dolls. That is not what makes a transsexual. What makes a transsexual is that they feel that they ARE the opposite sex, and often this comes with an inherent, unalterable discomfort with some parts of their bodies. Thomas Beatie did not transition because he wanted to do stereotypically masculine things. He transitioned because deep down inside, male is who he was and always has been. And I can't speak for his experience, but since he got sex reassignment surgery, likely he has always been severely uncomfortable with the presence of his breasts. Your discussion of stereotypical activities is pointless because plenty of transsexuals don't fall into the stereotypes of the gender they feel themselves to be. Th

Posted on 01/27/2009 at 1:01:11 PM

I JUST DON'T GET THIS ARTICLE.

Posted on 01/27/2009 at 12:01:25 PM

:)

Posted on 11/20/2008 at 12:11:38 PM

Comments 1 - 7 of 7