Does Pitcher Mike Mussina Belong in the Baseball Hall of Fame?

The 39-year Old Veteran Pitched for the Baltimore Orioles and New York Yankees Over 18 Seasons, Amassing 270 Career Wins

Former New York Yankees pitcher Mike Mussina has announced that he is retiring from baseball. The decision was probably a hard one for the 18-year veteran, but without clear knowledge of what the Yankees planned to do with him, it
 may have been time. The question now comes into play as to whether or not he deserves to be voted into the baseball Hall of Fame. Breaking down whether Mike Mussina should have his day in Cooperstown isn't as easy as one might think, but he does have some qualifications that could make him noticeable to voters when he becomes eligible in 5 years.

Usually, a pitcher is defined by statistics when it comes to making it into the Hall of Fame, but there are also times where a player has performed extraordinarily well in the post season, and has received additional recognition for being great over a short period of time. One such pitcher to have a really short career was Sandy Koufax, but because he was so good over those few years, he still made it into the Hall of Fame. Some voters also argue that a player needs to be one of the best players at their position for X number of years, meaning that longevity of the career is good enough to get in if they were one of the best players.

Here are the stats in question for Mike Mussina for his career:

Mike Mussina Career Statistics:

Statistics: 270 wins, 536 games started, a .638 winning percentage as a starter, a career ERA of 3.68, a career WHIP of 1.192, and 2813 career strike-outs.

Awards: 5-time all-star; 7-time Gold-Glove winner (5th most ever for a pitcher).

Career Statistical Ranks: Wins 270 (33rd); Innings 3562.7 (66th); Winning Percentage .638 (38th); Strike-Outs 2813 (19th).

Post-Season Statistics: 16 Post-Season Series -- 23-21 Record; 3.42 ERA; 145 k's in 139.2 innings; No World Series Titles.

Related information
 
Comments 1 - 9 of 9  
Comments
Type in Your Comments Below

Great profile :) Sheri

Posted on 11/25/2008 at 7:11:05 PM

:)

Posted on 11/21/2008 at 6:11:37 PM

Actually don't give him a break. If a SP cannot hit 300 wins or 3000 strikeouts then he has to be dominant some other way - Mussina simply was not. His ERA was extremely mediocre at 3.68. I don't want "good" pitchers in the Hall - I want ELITE pitchers in the hall. So to compare: The automatics: Maddox, Clemens 300 wins and/or 3000ks: R. Johnson; Glavine; Pedro; Shilling; Smoltz Burt Blyleven is NOT in and his numbers exceed mussina in every way. 3701 Ks, 3.31 ERA, 287 wins. Red Ruffing is the only guy in the hall with a worse ERA than Mussina has (3.80) and frankly he does not deserve to be in although he did have 4 20 game winning seasons. His K numbers (2212) and wins (273) however are off the mark. Mussina would be another Red Ruffing. Baseball has been around for 13 decades. There are only 59 pitchers - INCLUDING RELIEVERS - in the HOF. That's roughly 4.5 per decade with 1 per likely dedicated to relief. Is Mussina one of 9 SP you'd pick from the 90s or 00s to be

Posted on 11/21/2008 at 2:11:29 PM

Good article. Couple things that I think hurt his chances: Steroids (Do I think he took them? NO. Do I think the era hurts his chances? Yes. Do I expect a lot of flak for this comment? Yes.). No World Series rings. Those not in the Hall at are in front of him in career categories. 3.68 ERA. Also, its hard to count gold gloves for a pitcher as a reason to why he should be in the Hall of Fame. Especially when Greg Maddox has taken every one but one since 1990 in the NL - you're telling me there isn't a better glove over the last 20 years? Plus the Gold Glove has only been around since the late 1950's which makes it hard to compare to players already in who played prior to that stat. Also, hard to compare pitchers of today (average 4-6 innings every 5 games), to pitchers in earlier era's who pitched much more. Just in general - across all sports - its hard to compare old players to today's. Do I think he get's in? Yes. On his 1st year of eligibility? No. Good read.

Posted on 11/21/2008 at 1:11:44 PM

:o)

Posted on 11/21/2008 at 9:11:11 AM

He does belong in the Hall! You mean to tell me that a pitcher can throw his way into 16 post seasons out of an 18 year career and not get in? He had to be doing something right. Any let me tell you about this 300 win crap. He's 30 short! Give the guy a break! RBI Magazine

Posted on 11/21/2008 at 6:11:15 AM

:)

Posted on 11/20/2008 at 5:11:16 PM

Good report.

Posted on 11/20/2008 at 5:11:02 PM

:)

Posted on 11/20/2008 at 5:11:59 PM

Comments 1 - 9 of 9