What I Learned from Terri Schiavo

Reading Between the Headlines

By Mary Shaw, published Apr 18, 2005
Published Content: 31  Total Views: 16,690  Favorited By: 3 CPs
Rating: 3.0 of 5
The Terri Schiavo saga has come to an end, but it's still being talked about (and argued about) around water coolers, bars, and family dinner tables everywhere. I think it's time to stop arguing and reflect on the lessons learned.

This is what I learned from Terri:

I learned that I was wise to have drawn up a living will two years ago, but that I was unwise for not having done so much earlier. Terri was only in her twenties when tragedy struck.

I learned that to face the impending death of a child is probably the hardest thing for a parent to do. Despite the fact that Terri's condition could hardly be called "living", her parents refused to accept that she could not connect with them. I do not fault them for that. Reality is not always easy to take.

I learned that Michael Schiavo loved Terri very much, and that he just wanted to honor the wishes that she had expressed to him repeatedly. I would hope that any life partner of mine would do the same, even if my parents were unable to accept the fact that I would not want to live as a vegetable.

I learned that I would not want Tom DeLay or any other elected official to interfere with my medical treatment. My medical decisions are between me, my doctor, and my loved ones. Let Congress find something better to do with my hard-earned tax dollars.

I learned that George W. Bush, as governor of Texas, signed cost-saving legislation giving hospitals the power to disconnect feeding tubes, breathing devices, and other means of life support without the consent of the patient's family. But, since Terri wasn't living in Texas, he jumped on the "save Terri" bandwagon to score some additional points with the religious right.

I learned that some Republican officials who have complained in the past about "activist judges" wasted no time in pushing for a little judicial activism to save Terri.

I learned that a majority of the American public, both Democrats and Republicans, reported to pollsters that they approved of removing Terri's feeding tube, so this really wasn't a partisan issue at all.

Comments
Showing Comments 1 - 2 of 2
 
 
I agree with your observations. I actually live about five miles from the hospice where Terri died. It's quite scary to be face to face with some of these fanatical so-called "right to lifer's". They appear to be fueled by anger and speak illogically, almost as if in a trance. You have written with a voice of reason and compassion.

Posted on 06/06/2005 at 3:06:00 PM

 
What I learned from the Terri Shiavo case is that a lot of Americans think it's OK to starve a person to death. We show more compassion and humane treatment to convicted rapists and murderes. Further, to say it's OK to starve someone to death because they don't know it's happening to them is to use the same line of reasoning that thieves, murderers, and embezzlers use: you don't know what's going on, so I'm going to take advantage of you. I also learned that it's OK to have an adulterous affair, have children with your lover, and legally kill your wife when there's a large insurance policy at stake. I suppose it's all perspective, eh?

Posted on 04/23/2005 at 1:04:00 AM

Type in Your Comments Below - (1000 characters left)
Your name:

Submit your own content on this or any topic. Get started »
Showing Comments 1 - 2 of 2
 
Most Commented On