Male Circumcision Going Extinct? An AC Experiment on Society's View on Circumcision

Adjust font-size: + 
More:Male CircumcisionSmegmaExtinctFemale Circumcision
Male circumcision is the surgical procedure of removing part or all of the foreskin on the penis. The word circumcision is derived from the Latin word "circum" or around and "caedere" to cut. Research indicates that
 circumcision dates back possibly to the stone age. No one really knows for sure exactly why circumcisions were originally performed but several theories have been made. Perhaps it was used as a form of sacrifice or a rite of passage. Some believe circumcisions were performed to alter the sexuality of the man. For whatever reason, circumcision got it's start, and it is still the most common surgical procedure performed in the United States today.

As a religious requirement, followers of the Islamic and Jewish faiths circumcise their sons. On the eighth day after birth, a special naming ceremony and a "bris" is performed usually by a mohel (a Jewish ritual circumciser). This is a very special time for the family and afterward a party is sometimes thrown. Although many believe that circumcision is fundamental to Judaism, some Jewish families are choosing to have a circumcision free ceremony. Instead, they would have a "Bris Shalom" or the ceremony without the slice.

According to user added content on Wikipedia (Which is currently being flagged for it's question of neutrality on the subject) Routine circumcision practices in South Korea are largely the result of American cultural and military influence following the Korean War. Also noted on Wikipedia are the non-western initiatory traditions that state circumcision can be part of an initiation rite in some African, Pacific Islander and certain isolated Australian aboriginal traditions. Certain Aborigines people are believed to practice the more painful form of circumcision which includes sub-incisions. Basically in a nutshell, a sub-incision is a cut made through to the urethra with the expected outcome of making the penis look almost female "Labia-like". Sub-incisions are almost always self performed.

  • Circumcision has been claimed to be the cure for several ailments.
  • The topic is a very hot button issue, especially in the online world
  • You have the right to refuse your son a circumcision, it's not a requirement
 
Type in Your Comments Below

unnecessary circumcision [most are], male or female, ought to go extinct! oooh religion watch out, god will get you, male is less masculine b/c he has a foreskin, woman is less feminine, biblical/victorian philosophy etc - protect against aids -- bla bla bla... its all nonsense! ...clear as a bell, to me... do no harm, integral mucosal tissue w/a purpose, born w/it, why remove it. Its not like a placenta or anything...
circumcision should go out like the dinosaurs and become extinct. It's stupid and people who do it to their son's are culturally brainwashed into thinking it's a good thing.
I also think it's up to the individual - i.e. NOT the parents, but the individual that's attached to the penis, when he's over 18. We can debate till we're blue in the face about the benefits and detriments of circumcision, but if we all can agree that it's a permanent one-way body modification, we can see that it should join other things like tattoos, body piercings, breast enlargement, female circumcision, etc. that are all generally restricted to the over 18 crowd consenting for themselves.
Uhhhh, did I come in in the middle of anything? Lol, ok here are my two pennies. I am a Mother of a son, married two men, (not at the same time) who weren't circumcised and was a nurse. Not being a man I can't tell you how it feels. I think that if God made 'em that way, they should work just fine without fixing them. I also worked with babies that had just gone through circumcision and they hurt like crazy, poor little things. My good friend though, works for a Doc. that specializes in having to circumcise guys in later life and she says it is a must. I guess it's up to the individual.
Thank you for your comment Summer!
Personally I think circumcision should be stopped.
I found this during an internet search. I wanted to thank the author for their attempts at neutrality. I know that's hard with this sore subject. Other then circumcision, I don't know any other procedure that is non-essential to current health that the AAP leaves up to parents. I'm not quite sure the reason behind that.
--nicer to you since you apologized though. :) And I'm not saying that you can't get defensive, only that I'm not meaning to put you on the defensive. The only way to reach a compromise is to talk about it. :)
Rebecca, I never accused you of attacking my husband, but you did specifically question our relationship--which, yes, is offensive to me, especially being that I constantly have to defend my right to be married (and have a child) due to my age. If you had simply disagreed with me, I wouldn't have become defensive. I would still have given you a mouthful though, because as I'm sure you've noticed by now, I have a lot to say about damn near everything! :D I haven't countered everything you say, only specific details with which I disagree. Discussion can consist of disagreement without being a debate. I've already agreed with you that yes, some men circ'd later in life are fine with that choice. I just don't feel that negates the feelings of those who did lose sensitivity or means that it's okay to take away an infant's choice on the matter. I also agree that we did get off on the wrong foot, and I'm sure I could have been much more graceful at our first encounter. I've been trying to be
You can get defensive and claim I'm attacking your husband by sticking up for circumcised men. I can not get slightly defensive when you attempt to counter everything I say? Sounds like a debate to me. I would love a civil conversation. I already mentioned elsewhere that we got off on the wrong foot and I apologized for that.
Comments 1 - 10 (of 34) Next >>
Share
Tweet
Share on Facebook
Post a comment
34
32
Helpful?
Most Commented