Find » Society » Should Prisoners Have Access to the...

Should Prisoners Have Access to the Internet?

An AC Experiment

By Kristina Jones, published Feb 08, 2007
Published Content: 111  Total Views: 284,736  Favorited By: 81 CPs
Embed:  
Rating: 3.4 of 5
Prisoners are afforded their basic rights, as laid out in the constitution. They are given three meals a day, shelter, legal advice (which may not be very good), and visitation with family members and friends. Some of the prisons are even made comfortable by allowing inmates to have televisions and other forms of home comforts while incarcerated. You may think having these things would be enough comforts for prisoners; after all, they are being punished. Unfortunately, many think prisoners should be able to have internet access as a way to communicate with the outside world.

Granting inmates access to the internet can be a good and bad thing. It may be a good thing for the inmates to have access to the internet for gaining legal advice. If a prisoner has a need for additional legal advice, why not allow them to only access a few select law websites and block everything else? Well, some prisoner advocates believe that prisoners' first amendment rights would be violated by denying the right to the internet.

It may be a good idea to grant inmates internet access for those who would like to pursue educational opportunities. In today's world, it is virtually impossible for a person to obtain a degree or write a research paper without having access to the internet. It is not likely the inmate will find all the materials needed to complete a program in the prison library, so why not let them research some academic resources on the internet?

Some activists believe prisoners should have full access to the internet and not just for legal or educational purposes. I have a major problem with letting prisoners have full reign on the internet. There are too many things that can go wrong with websites like Myspace.com becoming breeding grounds for predators. It just would not be comforting knowing a fourteen year old boy or girl could be communicating with someone behind bars and nobody ever knows it.

Should Prisoners Have Access to the Internet?

Gavel, Mouse, and Keyboard

Credit: Comstock

Copyright: Comstock

Takeaways
  • Access to the internet can help inmates gain legal knowledge and may provide educational benefits.
  • Limiting or allowing no access to the internet is argued as unconstitutional by advocates.
  • Several inmates have posted to social networking sites as a means to communicate with the outside world.
Did You Know?
After Arizona's internet restriction law in prisons was overturned, several states abolished laws limiting or allowing no access to the internet to prisoners.
Comments
Comments 1 - 15 of 20
Next >>
 
no!!!!!! if they want rights and access stay outta trouble.

Posted on 11/17/2008 at 8:11:37 AM

 
Internet access creates a huge problem that is difficult to monitor, especially from a security standpoint. E-mail communication and access to sites even such as GoogleEarth allow communication and co-ordination that facilitates escape attempts, co-ordinated disruptions or riots and a lot more. Currently for security reasons, prisoners are not even informed of the date and time of outside medical consults or appointments to avoid escape attempts. Simply to allow blocking or monitoring does not solve the problem, and merely creates a lot more work for someone who has to go through all of that e-mail and logging. Committing a crime that gets you incarcerated comes with certain consequences, and justifiably one of those is no internet access.

Posted on 07/25/2008 at 3:07:53 PM

 
Absolutely not!!! How absurd. If you have done something to cause you to go to prison, you do not deserve to have access to the internet. Prison is a place for people who have broken the law whatever it might have been, they do not deserve entertainment.

Posted on 10/20/2007 at 3:10:00 AM

 
give me a break too soft isjust a beginning. I as a ew christian don't believe in the death penality. however I have no problem w/ work camps like those in Lousiana or any one that even pretends to be like Cool Hand Luke. Work hard and earn your damn keep and spend less time on gang related activities or any other mischief. Ask anyone in the prision system and theywould agree. And all the bleeding heart liberals out there, pay for their care on your own... not w/ my tax dollars

Posted on 09/04/2007 at 12:09:00 AM

 
i have been in prison fed and state systems.im a non violent non sex offender that let drugs temporarily cloud my morals and ethics.i know what people in prison a capable of.despite the fact that there very well may be those in prison whom could use the privilage w/o incident or problem. there is always that one idiot that will take advantage and exploit any inch given,in turn this gives prison officials evidence needed to show the public & law makers why not to have something.for 4 years i heard plenty of idiots go on and on about the past idiotic things they did,and the future idiotic things they plan on doing.because of this alot of people in prison that could really benefit from something like having the internet available for legal,educational,correspondence,etc won't be able to,and have to just understand that prison officials will use these 1 in 10000 cases to fight anything potentially beneficial to a prisoner, allowing prisoners any ADDITIONAL tools,access to up to date lega

Posted on 04/23/2007 at 2:04:00 PM

 
I do not believe inmates should have the right to access the internet. As a former Correctional Officer I have seen what they can do and how they can manipulate anyone, they also can get your information and find out where you live, so no I do not think they should have the right to access the internet while they are in prison. They are in there for punishment not lesiure time.

Posted on 02/22/2007 at 8:02:00 AM

 
I think that as long as there are network restrictions on what a prisoner can access like they have at certain work places that it would be a good idea to let them have the access. It would be like providing more books for them to read. I think that they should also be allowed to used the internet to communicate with people authorized by the prison administration. Giving them access on a limited basis would help keep them busy. There is too much time on their hands now and as the saying goes idle hands are tools for the devil. Limited social networking could include a church orgainzation and family members. It would help with the morale and face it in those places it is needed as much as possible. I would prefer to have an imate busy on the internet writing a letter to their children at home than preying on each other or the prison staff. I think that myspace is a bad idea anyway. I see too much bad stuff on there from people who are not in prison.

Posted on 02/17/2007 at 6:02:00 PM

 
There are a lot of people in prison who have not yet been convicted of a crime but don't have the funds to post bail. These people should have better access to the outside world than they do. Supervised internet access is one way to do this. Prison mail already has to be read, this is only slightly different so I don't see a huge bump in cost for this. If need be a fee could be assessed for internet use in the same manner its assessed for phone calls. Public libraries already have software that limits the amount of time a patron can use a machine.

Posted on 02/11/2007 at 11:02:00 AM

 
p.s. I think a lot of online courses just involve individual work. :)

Posted on 02/11/2007 at 12:02:00 AM

 
I definitely agree that there are so many resources online that they should have access to, such as information, banking, legal, keeping touch with loved ones, earning money--but I do agree that they need to be restricted. I also think that the restrictions should be based on their crimes and histories. If a man is in jail for molesting a child, obviously he doesn't need to be anywhere near MySpace or Neopets. But for someone who committed a nonviolent crime, there may not be a reason to deny him access to that. Evaluating people on an individual basis would be best. You can create different accounts on a computer with different restrictions on each, and that would make regulating them individually quite easy. I don't agree that it's wrong for the tax payers to pay for it. These men can't exactly work to make a decent living. Providing the resources of the internet is no different than paying unemployment to someone. Internet access isn't even that costly.

Posted on 02/11/2007 at 12:02:00 AM

 
Rhonda, I agree our prison system has gotten too soft on prisoners. I remember going to a prison for a school trip in high school and they had televisions right in their cells. Letting them have internet to only access legal information and education seems the logical stance here. Thanks for the comments.

Posted on 02/09/2007 at 8:02:00 AM

 
Susan, I understand not everyone in prison is a child molester, but regardless of their crimes they are treated equal within the system. I loved your comment on them having access to Associated Content so they can buy better legal advice. Allowing them to have email to communicate with families and lawyers is a good thing, unless they are incarcerated because of a violent crime or are part of a prison gang. If there were to have email, the prison would have to have a system where they can read all outgoing and incoming email for security reasons. This could take up extensive manpower and the department of corrections could lose money. Thanks for the comments.

Posted on 02/09/2007 at 8:02:00 AM

 
Sharon, I agree it should depend on the level of security in the prison. There sould be absolutely no accss to chatrooms and social networking websites. I agree it is the departmet of corrections duty to monitor the activities of the inmates while using the internet.

Posted on 02/09/2007 at 8:02:00 AM

 
Heather B., I think you hit it on the nose. Internet privileges should be very restrictive and it should be used only for two things: legal advice and educational purposes. I am strongly against the idea of letting them take online courses with individuals in the free world though,depending on their crime. Thanks for the comment.

Posted on 02/09/2007 at 8:02:00 AM

 
Great article. Something to think about.

Posted on 02/09/2007 at 2:02:00 AM

Type in Your Comments Below - (1000 characters left)

Submit your own content on this or any topic. Get started »
Comments 1 - 15 of 20
Next >>
Advertisment