The Ultimate Guide to Freezing Peanut Butter Sandwiches

Freeze Ahead Sandwiches for On-the-Go Folks

This is valuable information if you or your family like peanut butter sandwiches and eat them at least once a month. I recently found out my children are willing to eat peanut butter and honey or peanut butter and jam sandwiches every day or even twice a day. This is good news for me!

1 loaf of whole wheat bread (You could use white, but why sacrifice all those good nutrients?)
Peanut butter
Honey or Jelly or Jam

On a clean countertop, lay out the bread in sets of two pieces. On one slice spread a very, very thin layer of peanut butter. This will be the slice that the honey, jelly, or jam goes on. You don't want to put the honey, jelly, or jam directly on the bread if it's going into the freezer-it would crystallize all gross-like. So, this very, very thin layer of peanut butter protects the bread. Then you can spread the honey, jelly, or jam on top of it. When we do honey, we like to mix it in with the peanut butter. On the second slice of bread spread the peanut butter as thick as you like. Place two pieces together and voila! Place sandwich in a sandwich baggie and into the freezer. When all the sandwiches are frozen, I like to line them all back up in the bread bag.

Prepare all the peanut butter slices first then do all the honey, jelly, or jam slices next. That way you don't get gooey stuff back in the peanut butter jar.

To thaw: Remove from freezer and thaw at room temperature for an hour.

There will be no sogginess. It's like you just made it.

How is this valuable to you? Well, if your child likes to eat peanut butter for lunch every single day (and you're okay with it), make a whole bunch at the start of the week or month. If you like to have emergency sandwiches for unexpected doctor or ER trips or long car rides (which we do if we're going to the temple 2 hours away), grab your bag of sandwiches and go!

I haven't tried it yet, but I heard you can also freeze lunchmeat and cheese sandwiches. I wouldn't recommend putting mayonnaise on it though, because mayo does NOT freeze well. You could keep the extra packets from fast food places and throw it in your lunch so you could add the mayo or mustard later to your sandwich.