ABC vs. Food Lion: Ethical Questions Raised by Sweeps Week

When Journalists Have to Decide Between Ratings and the Truth

By Laurie Maisano, published Dec 07, 2005
Published Content: 5  Total Views: 4,338  Favorited By: 0 CPs
Rating: 3.0 of 5
Lately, it seems that it's impossible to turn on the television without hearing a blaring teaser that announces who will be the next guest-star on a bevy of different sit-coms. Even newsmagazines such as Dateline NBC and PrimeTime Live bring out the big guns during this time of year. Why are the networks are going to such lengths to attract viewers now? One word-"sweeps".

According to NielsenMedia.com, "sweeps" are different periods of time throughout the year when extensive, viewer demographic information is collected to determine advertising rates.
For PrimeTime Live, airing shocking, investigative pieces during "sweeps" is nothing new. In fact, almost exactly 12 years ago, they aired a particular hidden camera report on the unsanitary meat handling practices of a grocery chain called Food Lion. It not only landed them in the courtroom, but it also raised several ethical questions on how far a journalist should be able to go in the name of informing the public. There were three parties involved, the Food Lion grocery chain, The United Food and Commercial Workers Union, and ABC's PrimeTime Live newsmagazine. All three claimed that they took the measures they did because it was in the best interest of the public. Sadly, when the motivational factors behind each interest is reviewed, it is easy to see that public safety was the last force behind any of their actions.

Takeaways
  • Food Lion sued ABC not on the grounds of libel, but rather the way in which the reporters gathered t
  • In 1997, a federal Jury awarded Food Lion $5.5 million dollars in punitive damages and $1.402 in act
  • Because the damages awarded were based on this claim, the appellate court threw out all but $2 in d
Did You Know?
According to NielsenMedia.com, �sweeps� ratings occur at several different times throughout the year, but the only months that hit all 210 markets in the United States are February, May, and November
Comments
Type in Your Comments Below - (1000 characters left)
Your name:

Submit your own content on this or any topic. Get started »
Most Commented On