NBC Finally Scores with The Black Donnellys: A TV Review

NBC Finally Has a Decent Show to Follow-up Heroes

By Bryan Alaspa, published Mar 07, 2007
Published Content: 298  Total Views: 113,691  Favorited By: 5 CPs
Rating: 4.0 of 5
NBC has been struggling since the start of the season to pair the hit show "Heroes" with a decent show that people would wan to stick around for. They made an attempt with "Studio 60" but it was certainly not effective. Whatever it is Aaron Sorkin may have had during his heyday with "The West Wing" he apparently lost this time around. How is it he could spend so much time creating crackling and sparkling dialogue but forget to create characters or stories that would make us care about any of it? I didn't like a single character on the show. I could care less about the actors because if the character that actor is playing I can't care about it could be the best actors in the world.

Well, the executives at NBC made a decent decision and got rid of Sorkin's latest let's-all-move-an-talk-really-quickly-and-show-how-smart-we-are-but-let's-not-make-characters-the-viewers-can-invest-in attempt. The show is called "The Black Donnellys" and it debuted February 26. It's worth checking out and that's a good thing. I like to keep the same channel on when I watch television instead of having to flip around and it's nice to move from one of the best written shows on television (Heroes) with a show that manages to be smart and compelling and create three dimensional characters that you can sympathize with.

The show is potentially very complex. The plot of the series debut was complex and introduced characters so fast you had to be paying attention to keep up with them. A few times I admit I got a little lost. These characters speak very quickly and considering the series appears to be narrated by some fast-talking shyster who happens to be in jail it can be a challenge. There are also a large number of characters. The Donnelly family is a large one with a large number of brothers and the casting people managed to find actors who actually do sort of resemble each other and look like brothers so there's another challenge.

Takeaways
  • The show is well written
  • The plot is complex so pay attention
  • Can this show sustain this kind of quality is the question.
Comments
Showing Comments 1 - 2 of 2
 
 
You have got to be kiding me. Viewers are tuning out for a reason! The show got killed by a CSI Miami RERUN. The acting is below average and but for the killing the show is totally boring. Sad to think that this was the best NBC could do.

Posted on 03/07/2007 at 6:03:00 PM

 
You did your best to summarize a really complicated and fast paced program into two pages, and you did great. I am warming slowly to The Black Donnellys, but I think they may need to scale back each episode to less plot lines to keep viewers watching. But a great review on your part, you have a knack for this!

Posted on 03/07/2007 at 4:03:00 PM

Type in Your Comments Below - (1000 characters left)
Your name:

Submit your own content on this or any topic. Get started »
Showing Comments 1 - 2 of 2
 
Most Commented On