Find » Arts & Entertainment » The Top Ten Newspaper Comic Strips ...

The Top Ten Newspaper Comic Strips of All Time

By Timothy Sexton, published Mar 07, 2007
Published Content: 3,125  Total Views: 2,822,590  Favorited By: 257 CPs
Embed:  
Rating: 4.1 of 5
Do you realize it has been over twenty years since the last of the great American comic strips were introduced to the world? Following over 60 years in which it seemed as if a classic comic strip was introduced every ten years or so, the dry run ended with the almost simultaneous rise and resignations of Bloom County, Calvin and Hobbes and The Far Side. Since their demise...nothing. Unquestionably, this dearth has little to do with lack of imagination. Several factors have combined to remove quality from the funnies pages of American newspapers. One of those is the utter lack of respect shown comic strip creators by the newspaper conglomerates. In the golden age of comic strips, these glorious little snatches of Americana received the full treatment of respect awarded to advertising for toilet paper today. Comic strips were actually large enough to read and allow the artists to create wondrous worlds. Today's little one inch square panels are an embarrassment. No wonder that any artist worth his salt has eschewed the limitations of newspaper management for the wide-open vistas of the internet. The internet is the place where you will find the next great comic strip, trust me.

And so, having written a eulogy for the newspaper comic strip, allow me to list one man's opinion of the ten greatest newspaper-based comic strips of all time. I tried to limit this list to those comic strips that are best known in that medium. Many comic books have been translated into strips and many strips have found more success as cartoons, either as short subjects preceding movies or on television. In addition, I've also limited the list to those comic strips that are considered mainstream. While Matt Groening's Life in Hell is certain a fantastic comic strip deserving of a place in the top ten, it remains an alternative strip. The comics on this list all rose to prominence in daily newspapers across the country. May they not rest in peace, but find new life in spectacularly-designed reruns on the internet.

10. B.C.

The Top Ten Newspaper Comic Strips of All Time

Some of the greatest comic strips in history are available in book collections.

Credit: Timothy Sexton

Copyright: Timothy Sexton 2007

Comments
Comments 1 - 13 of 13
 
 
What about Citizen Dog? That has to be on the list. I sure hope Mark returns to cartooning.

Posted on 10/10/2008 at 12:10:30 PM

 
where is pearls before swine?????? come on u have b.c. and doonesbury on there but u dont have pearls before swine? dude replace bc with o i dont know...BABY BLUES??? BOONDOCKS??? GET FUZZY?? and put pearls at least number 5 pearls is the best strip on the newspaper today stephan pastis proves that you dont have to be a good drawer to do what you want to do. and far side should be moved up a place or two but calvin and hobbes definately #1

Posted on 06/23/2008 at 8:06:34 AM

 
Nigga i fuckin love calvina nd hobbes

Posted on 04/17/2008 at 6:04:09 PM

 
Calvina nd Hobbes are cool, but I think that "Peanuts is #1. Good fucking list though.

Posted on 04/09/2008 at 3:04:47 PM

 
Calvin and Hobbs #1??? WTF! Peanuts is the best strip ever made. And where is the Boondocks on this list. This list sucks!!!

Posted on 03/31/2008 at 5:03:11 PM

 
Calvin and Hobbes the greatest strip of all time?!!! There would be no Calvin and Hobbes without Peanuts. Peanuts is the father of the modern comic strip. Don't get me wrong, Calvin and Hobbes was absolutely brilliant, but everything about Calvin can be found in Peanuts first. From his Calvin's character design to the timing and cadence of the writer Watterson is aping Schulz almost 100%. The other huge influence on Bill Watterson's art and writing would be Walt Kelly's Pogo. Even Bill Watterson has acknowledged the huge debt that he owes to Sculz and Walt Kelly. As far as most comic strip fans would tell you Peanuts is number one, Pogo is second than you have Doonesbury, Bloom County and next Calvin and Hobbes. Sorry, but you are just plain wrong.

Posted on 03/23/2008 at 11:03:50 PM

 
I love Calvin and Hobbes diffenitly number one comic of all time!!! I don't like B.C or that crap though cause it dosen't make any sense

Posted on 01/05/2008 at 8:01:28 AM

 
Great list. I agree almost entirely, except for two points: First, B.C. should not be included on this list. Better options, just off the top of my head include "For Better or Worse", "Foxtrot", "Annie" and "The Boondocks." Secondly, I'd switch the order of the top two, with Bloom County at #1 and Calvin & Hobbes at #2. They're both brilliant strips with wonderful art, but Bloom County's devotion to serious and often tragic real-life events, and the ability of the strip to make it all funny... it's simply unparalleled.

Posted on 12/10/2007 at 1:12:41 PM

 
Two of the top 10 newspaper comic strips of all time, Dick Tracy and B.C,. are now being reprinted in graphic novel format by Checker Book Publishing Group. For more information on these books and all the other great graphic novels published by Checker, please visit www.checkerbpg.com.

Posted on 10/03/2007 at 7:10:00 AM

 
First, a point of contention in describing Dick Tracy as being drawn in chiaroscuro. Dick Tracy is drawn in a stark, outlined style, definitely not chiaroscuro, which began with Scorchy Smith in the 1930s, drawn by the great Noel Sickles. Sickles inspired his partner, Milton Caniff, to take up the style and raise it to the next level in Terry and the Pirates, the definitive and first real adventure strip. Chiaroscuro is defined as a rendering of light and shade, drawn in pen and ink and brush in an impressionistic manner to simulate the realism of photography. Caniff became the ultimate master of this technique when he left Terry and started his new strip, Steve Canyon.

Posted on 09/03/2007 at 9:09:00 AM

 
Good article. I would suggest reading "Doonsbury" again because, lately, it's been very funny, relevant, and ironic and - occasionally - very moving with it's story lines of soldiers in Iraq. Trudeau is again in top form. My only quarrel is with putting "B.C." on this list. For the last ten years it's been the lamest comic in the papers, besides maybe Family Circus or Fred Bassett. I have no problem with a comic having a conservative bent but, like "Mallard Filmore", "B.C." is never funny. Never. "Doonsbury", on the other hand, is almost always funny - and well drawn! "B.C." has looked pretty bad the last decade - like a seventh-grader was drawing it. Johnny Hart was obviously phoning or faxing it in during the last years. As for current strips, "Pearls Before Swine" has shown great potential, and "Zits" is well drawn and well written. They're the only two that might make the list next time. Oh, and LONG LIVE BLOOM COUNTY!

Posted on 04/24/2007 at 12:04:00 AM

 
Good list, but perhaps a bit weighted to contemporary strips. I'd include Barney Google (before Snuffy Smith), Terry and the Pirates and Little Orphan Annie (when creator Harold Gray was handling it) on the list, to name a few. Overall, though, it shows great taste!

Posted on 03/13/2007 at 10:03:00 AM

 
I bought my boyfriend The Complete Far Side Collection and it was well worth $80. They are huge! Like 18 pounds. Really pretty books too. Great article!

Posted on 03/08/2007 at 9:03:00 PM

Type in Your Comments Below - (1000 characters left)
Your name:

Submit your own content on this or any topic. Get started »
Comments 1 - 13 of 13
 
Advertisment