Find » Opinion/Editorial » James Cameron Documentaries Point t...

James Cameron Documentaries Point to Hypocrisy

By Jeff Musall, published Mar 12, 2007
Published Content: 337  Total Views: 209,194  Favorited By: 93 CPs
Embed:  
Rating: 4.2 of 5
When the History Channel aired the documentary "The Exodus Decoded," the majority of Christians hailed it as evidence of the hand of God in the affairs of the ancient Israelites. After the film first aired in 2006, the accolades coming in from the religious right were high on praise and short on criticism. Many scholars did find much to be critical of in the documentary. Still, most lay people seemed happy to take it at face value since to them, it supports their view of God. Whether that view is grasping at straws or finding real value in the information given, it isn't the purpose of this article to decide. In a voice-over at the end of the film you hear these words: "Was the Exodus just a natural event, or was it the hand of God? We'll leave that for the viewer to decide."

In truth, the film makes quite a few assumptions. But it does make them with an eye toward science, which is to the credit of those who made it. I think it points to several natural events that an ancient tribe wove into mythical lore. As we have learned before, many myths have their roots in some truth. Quite a few people were surprised when the ancient city of Troy was discovered, having given it up as myth. However, just because the city existed-and probably was sacked in warfare-doesn't mean that Paris killed Achilles by hitting him in the ankle. Stories get embellished as they are passed along. The documentary explored the possibilities when myth and science cross in real events.

Now the same production team-James Cameron and Simcha Jacobovici-have offered up 'The Lost Tomb of Jesus." And the furor it has stirred among Christians is almost off the scale. Why? Because it challenges the very foundation of Christianity, claiming to have found the burial tomb of Christ. And just as sacrilegious to most Christians, claiming that he was apparently married and had at least one child. Them's fightin' words, there! 'The Lost Tomb of Jesus" is similar in approach to "Exodus Decoded." There are based on sound scientific ideals, but taken to an assumptive level. They present provocative information that some will discard no matter, and some will feel compelled to explore.

James Cameron Documentaries Point to Hypocrisy

The ossuary of Christ?

Credit: getty images

Copyright: getty images

Takeaways
  • It is amazing how fast some can change their stripes..
  • Ancient peoples tried to explain the world around them as best they could.
  • Why are Christians so afraid of those who question?
Comments
Comments 1 - 6 of 6
 
 
Huh...? Your point is -since everybody who wrote anything you do not understand before you were born of-course was so much less capable of respecting the "truth" than the scientist minded people of today consider to be truth that they were liars...it is a broad sweeping statement and in accordance with the elite of today those are themselves to be suspect on those grounds alone... so, why were all of those who wrote what some don't understand, liars?

Posted on 03/14/2007 at 10:03:00 AM

 
oops, it cut me off . . . to continue : It's like saying, "Well, my friend and I both believe in the immortality of the soul, therefore we must believe all the same things." Life is more complicated than that.

Posted on 03/14/2007 at 9:03:00 AM

 
oops, it cut me off . . . to continue : It's like saying, "Well, my friend and I both believe in the immortality of the soul, therefore we must believe all the same things." Life is more complicated than that.

Posted on 03/14/2007 at 9:03:00 AM

 
Well, I think you need to check out a definition of hypocrisy. "I don't think it means what you think it means" to quote Inego of The Princess Bride (80's movie). It's a nice $5 word, but repeating it over and over doesn't make it mean something else. People have the freedom to agree with someone one minute about one thing and disagree with them on another point without it being "hypocrisy." We all have the freedom to change our minds on things we once believed as well, this isn't hypocrisy either. Hypocrisy, as I understand it, is to believe one thing and then DO something else. If you've demonstrated anything about the fundamentalists (no, I'm not one), it's that they are anything but hypocritical, sticking to what they believe. You might accuse them of being blind, but not hypocritical. I'm unfamiliar with either documentary, so I really can't say anything about them, but the logic here is a little shoddy. It's like saying, "Well, my friend and I both believe in the immortality of t

Posted on 03/14/2007 at 9:03:00 AM

 
Hear hear!

Posted on 03/13/2007 at 2:03:00 AM

 
Great article! And people say accountants can make the facts say whatever they want them to say...

Posted on 03/12/2007 at 5:03:00 PM

Type in Your Comments Below - (1000 characters left)

Submit your own content on this or any topic. Get started »
Comments 1 - 6 of 6
 
Advertisment