Find » Society » Affirmative Action as a Staple of S...

Affirmative Action as a Staple of Society

Is Affirmative Action Fair?

By Jacob Malewitz, published Mar 16, 2007
Published Content: 329  Total Views: 86,492  Favorited By: 19 CPs
Embed:  
Rating: 3.0 of 5
It's hard to move around in American society without running into affirmative action. It affects both school and work life. It is apparent that many politicians in America believe society isn't colorblind. Basically, what affirmative action does is by trying to rectify the wrongs done to minorities in the past by giving them advantages over the white class in America. It can be seen in school admission policies, where at one time minorities weren't allowed into the same schools as whites, to now where minorities are sought about by schools to improve diversity. The same can be said of minorities in the workplace: where once minorities were discouraged to apply to certain schools or jobs now they are encouraged to apply. Things like quota systems have become common knowledge in a society where it is no longer right to let minorities fall behind. In Michigan and California there have been laws passed stating affirmative action shouldn't be used. The question then becomes, is it wrong to give minorities a better chance than white Americans?

Takeaways
  • Affirmative action affects both schools and jobs.
  • Is affirmative action fair to those who had no part in past discrimination?
Did You Know?
Affirmative action was recently rules illegal in California and Michigan.
Comments
Comments 1 - 2 of 2
 
 
"In the end, the reasons for affirmative action are much stronger than those that are against it." Pray tell, what are the reasons for affirmative action? You do realize that a good deal of the upper class is minority and a good deal of the lower class is majority, yes? You also realize that, as an Asian, I am less likely to get into a good college than a black or Hispanic who has fewer qualifications than me? What about the fact that I was born in the 1980's and have absolutely nothing to do with the Jim Crow laws, which have nothing to do with that badly qualified Hispanic that I mentioned and very little to do with that badly qualified black? How about the way that affirmative action is as racist as the Jim Crow laws, being as it makes decisions based solely on race, not achievements? Finally, how do you think minorities feel, with the possibility that the only reason they succeeded was because of their race? Isn't it possible that it cheapens them?

Posted on 03/21/2008 at 2:03:35 PM

 
If slavery and Jim Crow laws are the justification for affirmative action, then we should limit eligibility for affirmative action programs and college admission preferences to descendants of African Americans who endured them. As Hispanic Americans replace African Americans as the ntion's largest minority, demographic change is making a mockery of affirmative action. The nation's largest states, such as California and Texas, have become or soon will become predominately minority. In my hometown, a border city of about 750,000, 80 percent of the population is Hispanic. Intermarriage between Anglos and Hispanics is common, and the offspring of these unions (think Cameron Diaz) are also eligible for affirmative action. Once the city's African Americans, Native Americans, Asians and non-Hispanic white females are counted, about 95 percent of the population is eligible for affirmative action. While African Americans and Hispanic Americans tend to be "disporportionately poor," there are sil

Posted on 03/17/2007 at 9:03:00 AM

Type in Your Comments Below - (1000 characters left)
Your name:

Submit your own content on this or any topic. Get started »
Comments 1 - 2 of 2
 
Advertisment