The Root Cause of Rape - A Male Dominated Society

By em j, published Mar 26, 2007
Published Content: 9  Total Views: 2,640  Favorited By: 0 CPs
Rating: 3.0 of 5
"Successfully reducing the occurrence of rape [requires]... the identification of its causes" (Hodgson, J. & Kelly, D., 2004, p. 44) and "somehow, over the past 30 years we've managed to create an entire social movement dedicated to treating and ending violence against women that rarely addresses the root cause" (Anderson, 2004). The cause that will be discussed in this paper is our patriarchal society that does not value the autonomy and unique voice of women. If, for instance, society placed value and interest in the well being of women, beyond their ability to reproduce, then the rape of a woman would be such an outrage that to do so would cause a man not only legal but social strife. However, men who rape do not experience such strife. For example, it is presently very difficult to prove acquaintance rape, and during a trial, our society's interests in protecting men over women are obvious by how the victim, not the perpetrator, is scrutinized (Taslitz, 1999). "The [criminal justice] system's response tends to focus less on the injury of and sensitive treatment of the victim, and more on evaluating the victim's credibility" (Hodgson, J. & Kelly, D., 2004, p. 3). A victim must fight against, not only her attacker, but her society, which, incidentally, is the root cause of her violation.

"For most men, aggression, whether physical or verbal, is instrumental, a way of controlling others, attaining social or material benefits, dominance, and self esteem" (Taslitz, 1999, p. 25). In other words, aggression is central to a man's behavior. And men are central to society's institutions. Therefore, male aggression creates the atmosphere for rape because society grants men the role of control over women in all institutions. "What I see all too often are stories about military bases, big business, universities, professional sports organizations where women were humiliated and abused by men who thought they had a license to do whatever they wanted to them" (Lefkowitz, 1999).

Comments
Showing Comments 1 - 7 of 7
 
 
what are the main causes of rape?

Posted on 09/04/2007 at 6:09:00 AM

 
Jamie-Thank you for the compliment! I too have enjoyed our conversations! WOW, how exciting that you are writing a story involving the Salem Witch Trials. I look forward to reading it!!! Very intriguing about the Iroquois Indians. I did not know that about them. Yes, I agree it would be very interesting to research the incidences (or lack thereof) of rape in non (or less) patriarchal cultures. Sad part about that is that there are very few if any cultures to study. Thanks for the posts:-) ~BB

Posted on 04/30/2007 at 12:04:00 AM

 
LOL! You do write a lot, I'll grant! but at least it's intelligent, which seems rare these days. I have heard, but not seen any real verifiable statistics on, that the Iroquois Indians couldn't even believe rape existed when the Puritans moved in. In every captivity narrative, the women who were kidnapped could not believe that the Indians committed horrible atrocities while killing etc (including doing nasty things to the bodies), yet it never occurred to them to rape their female captives, and indeed when asked seemed to find the idea repugnant. The Iroquois were not matriarchal, but certainly had female sachems, so there may be some support right there for your ideas. Of course, the Puritans were extremely patriarchal in the classical sense, yet they had a low incidence of rape as well. (er, sorry -- this period's one of my areas of strong interest, as I'm writing a book about the witchcraft trials) Perhaps there was another variable involved?

Posted on 04/27/2007 at 12:04:00 AM

 
which places value on dominance, allows for the continued rape of its subjugated without much consequence. (dang it, I write too much!!!)

Posted on 04/26/2007 at 3:04:00 AM

 
Thanks for reading, Jamie!!! :-)

Posted on 04/26/2007 at 3:04:00 AM

 
There actually has been much research regarding male rape. In that instance, again, the driving force is aggression, power, and authority. Modern day prisons for male offenders have been studied and the research has shown that rape is used as a tactic for creating control and hierarchies. Like female rape, male rape is about dominance. Rape period has nothing to do with sex and everything to do with superiority--which of course, a patriarchal culture teaches, develops, and encourages. I dare say that in other cultures the incidence of rape would be similar, as America is hardly the only patriarchal culture. The serious difference is the social stigma placed on the victim, and therefore, the less reporting of rape that is done. Rape happens whenever a culture places one section of the population dominant over the other. American society is at its root, patriarchal, and therefore, the paper could not be approached another way as it was a reflection on how a culture, which places value on

Posted on 04/26/2007 at 3:04:00 AM

 
Though this is well-written, I think it's flawed at the root by treating all American (?) society as one lump: Patriarchy. We have a hundred different ethnicities, and none of them behave violently in the same way; I suspect rape is much rarer in a Jewish or East Indian enclave than in most, for instance, provided the original culture is adhered to. I'd love to see this study done, but with the different groups torn apart in the same way that Thomas Sowell did in Race and Culture. I bet the results would be fascinating. I'd also like to see the study done that way with a focus on male-male rape, to see if there is a difference when the gender is swapped.

Posted on 04/26/2007 at 2:04:00 AM

Type in Your Comments Below - (1000 characters left)
Your name:

Submit your own content on this or any topic. Get started »
Showing Comments 1 - 7 of 7
 
Most Commented On