Starvation for Sanjaya - Possibly the Dumbest Hunger Strike Ever

American Idol Fan Starves Herself Over Sanjaya's Success

Some people go on hunger strike for political reasons. Some people go on hunger strike for animal rights. Jevonda, a 23-year-old woman from New York, is on hunger strike for a much different reason- because Sanjaya Malakar is still on American Idol.

"J," as she refers to herself on her website, is writing a blog about her hunger strike. Apparently, it has created quite the stir. The Myspace page has almost 2,000 friends! Strangely enough, many "friends" of this cause have left comments such as "I'll be
Starvation for Sanjaya - Possibly the Dumbest Hunger Strike Ever
 having a nice steak tonight while I vote for Sanjaya."

Personally, I am not a fan of Sanjaya Malakar. I could not handle the numerous shots of a crying pre-teen girl at last week's Idol show. I mean, at first it was amusing, but then it was just lame. Part of me wants to think that they kept showing her because nobody else in the audience looked like they were enjoying Sanjaya's performance. How could they be?

But to decide not to eat because he is still on the show... that is just plain stupid. For starters, Sanjaya has an unfortunate appeal to a large demographic of the American Idol audience- teenage girls. I believe that Sanjaya might just be to 2007 what Taylor Hanson was to 1997. No one of any merit really believed that Taylor, Zach, or Isaac Hanson were talented singers, but the Hanson brothers sold millions of records because teenage girls thought they were cute. Sanjaya seems to have that appeal, and it will likely carry him far.

Sanjaya is also one of the few teenagers on the show this season. Previous seasons have had more teenagers as finalists, but this time through there is only Sanjaya for the boys and Jordin Sparks for the girls. Teenagers like to vote for teenagers. I think they feel some cosmic connection to them, solely because of their age.

 
Comments 1 - 10 of 14 Next >>
Comments
Type in Your Comments Below

Hanson are great musicians now... Their music is great! This comment is so unfair! Hanson improved their sound comparing it to 1997 times!

Posted on 10/02/2007 at 3:10:00 AM

"No one of any merit really believed that [Hanson] were talented singers..." ? If I recall, "Middle of Nowhere" received raves from critics (not just teenage girls). Their harmonies, particularly nowadays, are unbelievably beautiful. Someone should send you Hanson's a capella cover of "Change in My Life" -- it will blow you away. So full of soul and passion. It's unfortunate that Hanson's talent gets derided simply because they were shoved into the spotlight by a mass marketing machine. They sold millions of records partly because of their youthful appeal and appearance, yes, but they're still going strong on their own because of their musical prowess and drive. And as far as Sanjaya goes... it's a TV show. Period. Not the end of the world. This is only a big deal because people on both sides of the debate are making it a big deal. And besides, he looks like he's having fun, so more power to him.

Posted on 04/14/2007 at 7:04:00 PM

If you have ever heard Hanson NOW they DO sound great. better than before. MUCH better than before. and they ARE a very talented band. #1 on the independent Billboard

Posted on 04/05/2007 at 9:04:00 PM

needless to say, this journalist has opened quite the can of worms. Maybe check the facts before making a whole lot of people mad...

Posted on 04/05/2007 at 5:04:00 PM

Oh gosh, I also hate Sanjaya. What a fluke. The hair is just unacceptable. I'm also sorry that you compared him to Hanson, since it was bound to bring out the angry Hanson fans. Yet, as someone who does listen to Hanson, I have to say that they are very, very different from when they first came out and are actually quite critically acclaimed in music circles. Thus, to say that they aren't talented just isn't true.

Posted on 04/05/2007 at 1:04:00 PM

I agree with you Jane, i don't find sanjaya attactive either. I also agree with you Charlotte, the comment you made was very true, lets face it Hanson have become even better since 1997. There are people out there who like bands because they are talented its not all about the looks.

Posted on 04/05/2007 at 10:04:00 AM

Maybe you should read up a little before you make uneducated assertions towards one of the highest selling independent artists making music now. i'd like to know what you think 11, 14, and 16 year olds should be accomplishing if not performing over 900 live shows, writing and playing their own music, and keeping a very huge fan baase for the next TEN years. And i don't find that sanjaya kid even remotley attractive.

Posted on 04/05/2007 at 10:04:00 AM

The hunger strike really is a stupid idea, and its not Sanjaya fault hes still in the show. The comment about Hanson was unfair, they are great singers and they have improved even more since 1997 ( 10 years ago you stupid jackass ) even Hanson themselves will say the same. This person seems to forget that they were teenagers, lets face it what male teenager sounds great with their voices breaking? Also i have seen Hanson live and they can sing..

Posted on 04/03/2007 at 8:04:00 AM

http://www.myspace.com/hansonmusic go here, scroll down a bit and see how many people of no merit think Hanson is for real. note the very FIST one mentioned. check out the other sites. you may be pleasantly surprised and not so quick to make harsh analogies like you did.

Posted on 04/02/2007 at 3:04:00 PM

you analogy is lame. Hanson is a VERY talented band and they are doing alot for indie music everywhere. if you had done your homework, listen to their more current music, seen their documentary, you would know that they are grown men now and very passionate about their art.

Posted on 04/02/2007 at 3:04:00 PM

Comments 1 - 10 of 14 Next >>