Isolation in the Big Apple

Big City Blues

By Richard Carriero, published Apr 08, 2007
Published Content: 153  Total Views: 61,864  Favorited By: 24 CPs
Rating: 4.0 of 5
Despite its immensity and the throngs of people that crowd the canyon-like streets, New York is a lonely city. You can always spot a New Yorker in the Deep South because they walk around with a look of deep suspicion. This wariness is triggered by the warmth, solicitude and hospitality of southerners. In New York City we do not speak to one another unless we have to. Riding the subway, packed in like cattle, elbows mashed into ribcages, we New Yorkers manage a remarkable paucity of verbal communication. The advent of ever increasing personal audio technology in the form of iPods, CD players or cellular phones has only served to deepen the isolation. New York is a city in which myriad tongues are spoken but there is one universal form of communication among us all-the quick glare of the eyes that signifies "leave me alone!" or "get out of my way!"

What could have triggered such iciness and lack of feeling between people? There are many reasons New Yorkers are so unfriendly. Firstly, while everyone in the city understands that crowding is a fact of life, no one likes it and we all bristle at the slightest imposition by strangers. For example, there is a way to walk down the sidewalk that facilitates pedestrian traffic. Walk briskly down the right side of the sidewalk and stay in your "lane." If you are walking in a group, walk close together or single file. To New Yorkers these are simple tenets of getting where you are going efficiently. Nothing angers a New Yorker like finding in their path a family of tourists waddling five-wide slowly down the left side of the sidewalk and staring at the tops of buildings while they take up the whole walkway.

Isolation in the Big Apple

Yours truly. A typical antisocial New Yorker working on the computer at Starbucks.

Credit: Rich Carriero

Copyright: Rich Carriero

Comments
Showing Comments 1 - 15 of 47
Next >>
 
This article is not true. I just move from the suburbs and I have met som many great people in New York. But I can see that this city also attracts many people with anti-social behavior from many parts of the country. It is a big city after all.

Posted on 06/28/2007 at 11:06:00 AM

 
My comment was cut off. But as I was saying is that kind of behavior is like asking for trouble. So, your article confirms what I have long suspected. Thanks for opening the window to this and letting other see.

Posted on 05/30/2007 at 9:05:00 AM

 
Yes, I agree with you. I grew up in Manhattan and left when I was sixteen. Yet, despite that I have lived away from New York for 24 years, I'm still considered "unfriendly". To me I'm being normal and minding my own business, but to those who meet me or who observe me from afar, they come to the conclusion that I'm a bitch or anti-social. I recently had a friend from New York move in to our home, and I noticed that he relatively spends his days alone and doesn't do much socializing. I mean he can socialize but it is not primary in his life. So, it hit me that what I was considering a personal problem may just have to do with the environment that I grew up in. Although, it has been 24 years, New York has left a lasting mark on me, and obviosly on other New Yorkers too. I've probably made progress since I left NY, but to those around me who don't know that, they see this aloof girl who doesn't have a smile plastered on her face. In New York that would be ridiculous, and who knows

Posted on 05/30/2007 at 9:05:00 AM

 
That's more like it. You have a point and you make it using evidence and examples. That I can respect. Perhaps you are right, I might just generalize. I don't find the first person perspective to be effective writing, however. If I am talking about something inherently subjective, then what I say must be inherently an opinion so the "I" is necessarily contained within that opinion. I'm also a big believer in not being offended by other people's opinions. Just because someone says something you don't like doesn't mean you have to respect their judgment. What I really prefer is CIVIL disagreement-like your comment Khara House. Insults are pointless and only reveal that the insulter is not up to the challenge of formulating an intelligent argument. All of this is contained in an article I have coming up.

Posted on 04/16/2007 at 7:04:00 PM

 
I think one problem a lot of people are having with this article is that, yes, it is the opinion of the author, but it's stated in such sweeping generalizations. If I was from NY, I might be a bit insulted myself. I.e., from the very first paragraph, "You can always spot a New Yorker in the Deep South because they walk around with a look of deep suspicion. This wariness is triggered by the warmth, solicitude and hospitality of southerners. In New York City we do not speak to one another unless we have to." If this is an opinion, perhaps it's better stated with "I" phrasing (vs. the extensive "we" here), or clearly stating that "In my opinion many New Yorkers [note, not the generalized "New Yorkers" itself] . . ." That's my OWN humble opinion.

Posted on 04/16/2007 at 2:04:00 PM

 
To New York City Guy - Yet another person who does not know how to comment on someone's written work (that takes effort, believe it or not) without being insulting. Don't tell me you're one of those "love it or leave it" morons. I can criticize anything I please. I pay city taxes and two grand a month in rent to live in New York City, I don't have to love it. Also, did I not say that I work an antisocial job and am of same nature? Its called a qualified opinion. The point is that having travelled some little bit, I find this city to be less friendly. It still has great museums, pizza and baseball-rest assured.

Posted on 04/15/2007 at 5:04:00 PM

 
I think a person's experience in regards to living in NYC varies on the type of person they are. If you are someone who likes people, a plethora of cultural scenes, as well as tons of action NYC is a great place to live. Now say you like to keep to yourself and are relatively shy then I can see how this article relates. Nevertheless, I like most major cities because they are great ways to garner ideas for articles.

Posted on 04/15/2007 at 12:04:00 AM

 
I live in NYC -- I disagree Totally with this article. I have many friends. Anti-social seem more fitting. You live in the best city in the world. Why don't you go outside instead of crying in an article. Also, you seem to have a lot of complaints about NYC -- you know you could always move to hmmm IRAQ...

Posted on 04/14/2007 at 11:04:00 PM

 
This is the very best piece I've read here at AC. And as a former New Yorker I can attest that every word is true.

Posted on 04/14/2007 at 11:04:00 AM

 
What a great article. Thanks for sharing.

Posted on 04/13/2007 at 3:04:00 PM

 
Excellent article!

Posted on 04/13/2007 at 2:04:00 PM

 
I went to NYC last weekend after having not been there for many years, and we were actually offered directions by someone without even having to ask, not that we would have asked anyway, which was great because the A train was running on the C track, and we probably wouldn't have known where to go. Then 3 stops from where we needed to get to, the subway broke, which was bad enough because it was the longest subway ride ever. It's a great city, but it takes forever to get anywhere, which was annoying for us because it's relatively easy to get around Phila. I witnessed several people obliging panhandlers which surprised me, and I'm pretty sure they weren't tourists.

Posted on 04/11/2007 at 7:04:00 PM

 
Very good article.

Posted on 04/11/2007 at 6:04:00 PM

 
Really good article, Richard. I loved visiting your New York, but cannot imagine living there or being a New Yorker. I prefer being a laid back, yacker from Texas. Internet cafes, coffee houses, and deli areas of organic grocery stores are popular here for socializing. Keep trying to break out - you deserve it.

Posted on 04/11/2007 at 5:04:00 PM

 
Superb piece of writing. Boston is pretty unfriendly. I lived there 2.5 years and experienced some of what you describe. It was over 20 years ago and I've never been lonelier in my life. Although Boston is so much smaller. I think it's more of a New England thing. I love living in the Southwest, at the foot of the Rockies, where it's frankly considered rude if you fail to wave at the other oncoming pickup truck on a rural road. We talk to each other a lot here. At the grocery store. The Theater. The feed store. Sporting events. Rodeos. The national parks. Anywhere we southwesterners are gathered together it seems. Life is too short to live in isolation. Have you considered a move?

Posted on 04/11/2007 at 3:04:00 PM

Type in Your Comments Below - (1000 characters left)
Your name:

Submit your own content on this or any topic. Get started »
Showing Comments 1 - 15 of 47
Next >>
Most Commented On