Should Oprah's Town Hall Show on Don Imus Outrage White Americans?

Were White Americans Purposely Discriminiated Against?

By Psychic, published Apr 17, 2007
Published Content: 253  Total Views: 187,232  Favorited By: 10 CPs
Rating: 3.9 of 5
On Monday April 16, 2007, the Oprah show aired a show about Don Imus called, "Town Hall. Now What?" As you may already know, Don Imus made a comment on his radio show about the Rutgers African American basketball players calling them, "nappy headed ho's." This comment outraged many Americans of all races and caused much debate over the issue of racism in the United States.

On this particular show, the Oprah show put together a panel of guest speakers. About 95% of the guest speakers were African American. The Oprah show included guests such as Rev. Al Sharpton to speak on the issue of Imus and the way that White Americans often portray African Americans. This show did not give voice to the opinions of white Americans. The show instead gave the opinions of African Americans only and the way that they are perceived by white people. Was this show just another form of racism? The shows title did not say, "African American Town Hall. Now What?" The title of the show was, "Town Hall. Now What?" However, the guest speakers were nearly all African American and the opinions that were given came from African Americans. Her panel did not include anyone of the white race except for one woman that was on her panel and she hardly even get the chance to speak. Was this Oprah's way of targeting all white Americans? She even stated that many white people think that it's ok to use the "n" word or other words that are considered to be racist against African Americans.

The show also targeted the way that most African American rappers use the "n" word and also use the word "ho." However, Oprah did not interview any white Americans on their views of Imus or about the use of derogatory words in rap music. She even had African American record label producers on the show that gave their opinions about how rap music often portrays African Americans with the use of the "n" word and other racist slurs.

Takeaways
  • Racism comes in many formes.
  • It's wrong to exclude any race when you're doing a show about racism.
  • Advertisers should hold shows accountable when they do something racist.
Resources
  • Psychic - Psychic
  • Psychics - Psychics
  • Psychic Reading - Psychic Reading
Comments
Showing Comments 1 - 15 of 17
Next >>
 
What is so wrong with having a black panel speaking about something that is of primary importance to the black commuinty. Why should we care that Oprah did not have whites on the panel? It is the equivilant of saying that because I hold a family meeting about something that is effecting my immediate family, that I am wrong because I did not involve all the neighbors on my block. This is something that we need to deal with in our community. White people can't offer me anything of any interest on a topic so personal because there is no way they can know how it effects me as a person of color.

Posted on 01/10/2008 at 5:01:51 PM

 
Yadda, Yadda, Yadda. So this was a majority African American Panel and you take issue w/ it?! GET OVER IT! When Heavy Metal was a HUGE issue (Backmasking, Suicide, Satanism) in the 90's were Black people asked to give THEIR opinion on its dilemma; How many African Americans were ask how they felt about Kirk Cobain?! Speaking of whick, I suggest BobP and TH Pankey be careful who they point their fingers at. Any interesting article on Heavy Metal: "In other words, the content can be discounted because it is not meant to be taken literally. On stage, groups of death metal sing about [Satan], societal ills, cannibalism and sex with rotting corpses (LOL!). But to fans [its entertainment]. "It's good violent fun," says Ron Holt, 26, a death metal fan. "Its like seeing Jason slash someone's head off; it helps me release my aggressions, but it doesn't mean i'm going to go out and do it." http://www.cyberessays.com/Arts/36.htm Violent fun? Sex w/ dead bodies? TOO FUNNY!

Posted on 12/21/2007 at 10:12:04 PM

 
Rosetta 6/29/07 I am old enough to have been through the race riots in Chicago thirty years ago.I see both sides of this issue. Things have changed. Why can't we look at the postive changes that have been achieved while still working to make sure the postive changes move forward. Oprah's show was a step forward. Yes, the African American community needs to police itself. For years the African America community blame whites for their failures. Now that there are many successful role models for African Americans yet white people are still being blamed. This will take time to change. I have been called many names by African Americans over the years. I find them offensive. I was abused as a child, my son was attacked by three African Americans when he was young. I have faced many things including losing a job because I was white. There are many white people that have faced diverisity. Racism does not belong to one race. I admire Oprahs attempt to help her community. I trust t

Posted on 06/29/2007 at 7:06:00 AM

 
That said, it would have been beneficial to hold a Town Hall meeting represntative of all citizens. Rap/Music and lyrics does affect the white community. When Snoop Dogg tells the public that everyone knows when they rap about "Ho's" they do not mean fine ladies like the Rutger's team, they are talking about the reality of girls in the hood who only want to get with for their money, he effectively degraded a whole bunch of females living in poor neighborhoods. He also told "white" some minority females are whores.

Posted on 06/28/2007 at 8:06:00 PM

 
I do not know much about Oprah but I believe she is neither a racist or a bigot. Ditto Imus. I understand why Sharpton is, growing up in an era when "blacks" could not legally drink out of a public water fountain. As long as "white" America allows the KKK to exist, I do not see any reason for "white" America to be outraged by what a bi-racial female does on her own TV show, when "black" citizens are continuously excluded from the media.

Posted on 06/28/2007 at 8:06:00 PM

 
Racism means that one believes one race to be superior to another. There used to be one race the human one, until 1800 something when a German scientist started classifying people due to thinks such as skull size. Bigotry is a bias against persons due to ignorance or stereotypical views.

Posted on 06/28/2007 at 8:06:00 PM

 
What's ridiculous about getting upset that this show apparently did not reflect "white American opinions" is that the majority of the time American media ignores African American opinions. There's no denying that each and every person in America is racist. I'm not talking about radical racism, but we all hold racist prejudices consciously or subconsciously. I feel this rant to be an example of someone angry that white privilege was not overtly evident for an hour long television talk show. Settle down.

Posted on 04/26/2007 at 6:04:00 AM

 
I agree with Meridith and Tired. You can count on one hand the number of Blacks that are on Sunday morning talk shows, who host news television programs between 3pm and 11pm M-F (oh by the way, ZERO!), or serve as commentators on the cable news shows - unless the issue is about race. If the media does not get it togehter and begin to have reporters that reflect the reality of America, we are going to have another Civil War (a.k.a. race war) on our hands. Have you seen some of the ugly posts written by some whites (not all whites mind you)? There is some venum brewing. If the newsrooms were more diverse, again reflect the reality of America's demographics, we would have never had an Imus situation. There are many white people that have to get real about sharing. They cannot control everything and they are not the only ones on this earth. The reaction of fear and jealousy by some white people of the very little people of color - especially Blacks - do have is deafening. Many may

Posted on 04/22/2007 at 7:04:00 PM

 
How many white talk show hosts have had 95% black town halls? Is it not true that on a white talk show the panel would likely be 95% white? Is that a problem for you? Or are you just upset whenever there is a black majority?? Ask yourself why you are not offended when the major of the panel is white...

Posted on 04/22/2007 at 7:04:00 PM

 
I agree with the previous posters who said that she rarely has an all-black panel on her show. 364 days out of the year she has all-white panels on her show on a wide range of topics, and no one in the black community complains about it. And since SOME, BUT NOT ALL white people don't feel it's an important issue but the black community does, then why wouldn't she have her panel set up this way? If you had watched the panel or maybe actually talked to some black people, you'd see that this issue really is dividing a lot of people. Some of the posters like Bob P. and TH Pankey stereotype black people, put us in a box and say 'this is how ALL blacks think' and then wonder why we still feel there is racism in America. Why didn't she have white people on her panel? Maybe it's because a lot of people like Rosie O'Donnell don't feel that this issue is newsworthy.

Posted on 04/22/2007 at 10:04:00 AM

 
I was very disturbed and disappointed that Stanley Crouch and Russell Simmons basically kept pushing their point that the main reason rap music and rap videos are bad is because whitey likes the performance and buys the music. Ok...so it's the white man's fault. It doesn't matter that rap music degrades women and constantly uses vulgar images and obscene language. It's only morally wrong because white people like it - "likes to watch minstrel shows". How twisted! It would be a great and acceptable genre of music if whitey didn't like it so much. Sick, sick, sick...that sort of twisted reasoning is why the black culture can't get ahead.

Posted on 04/21/2007 at 1:04:00 PM

 
The Oprah Show is one the most influential unbiased shows on television...she has chosen to rise above color and focus primarily on compassion and healthly living mind body and soul on her show. Many African Americans want her to be more "Black" and whites want her to cater to them. She has chosen a more spiritual walk, because we fight in the spirit not in flesh and blood. She has many African Americans on her show but not to discuss "African American Issues". This particular Town Hall specifically dealt with how the Rap Music/Lyrics affect the African American Community. Rev Al Sharpton has consistently been against demeaning speech from the Rappers so it was valid that he was included in this discussion. Bill Cosby has consitently been for more education and taking responsibility in the AA community. The discussion centered around how African Americans portray themselves, really having nothing to do with Whites, or what whites think of African Americans. So there was no need fo

Posted on 04/19/2007 at 7:04:00 AM

 
Please get a LIFE.

Posted on 04/18/2007 at 9:04:00 PM

 
Oprah RARELY, VERY RARELY has majority Black panels on ANYTHING on her show. Which, by the way, is why a lot of Black Americans do not watch her show. This episode in particular was majority Black because she was discussing an issue within the Black community that needs to be addressed within the Black community. Before there can be any discussion with the larger American family, Black people must come to some understanding about the issue within ourselves. That is why the panel was majority Black. Calling the panel 'Hood' is uncalled for and biased. There was nothing 'Hood' about any of the panelist. If you have issue with Al Sharpton, that's your choice, but to say "why not Bill Cosby?" is ignorant. Bill Cosby knows NOTHING about hip-hop culture which is what much of the discussion was about. Personally I had more issue with the other panelists. At least Al is familiar with the hip-hop community. There were a lot of voices missing from that panel, but it was not discrimina

Posted on 04/18/2007 at 7:04:00 PM

 
This rant against Oprah is absurd!! Oprah is a journalist...she has gays..lesbians...poor..rich...white...black and all of the above on her show. She even has folks from all over the world on her show etc... let her do her job and stop judging her on one program....please don't be that imature... She has a body of work that extends 20-30 years... she is also a black woman....is there anything wrong with that? Look up the definition of racism and you'll clearly see hosting a program and dedicating 2 shows to the open discussion of a specific area.... DOES NOT CONSTITUTE RACISIM.....

Posted on 04/18/2007 at 3:04:00 PM

Type in Your Comments Below
Your name:

Submit your own content on this or any topic. Get started »
Showing Comments 1 - 15 of 17
Next >>
Most Commented On