Tragic Commuter Train Crash in California Damages Denver Transit System

Apparent Attempted Suicide Resulting in Eleven Deaths, Over 100 Lawsuits Spooks Railroads into Requiring New Concessions from Commuter Rail

By Dave Maddox, published Apr 18, 2007
Published Content: 236  Total Views: 89,824  Favorited By: 16 CPs
Rating: 3.0 of 5
When Juan Ignacio Alvarez parked his SUV on Glendale, California commuter rail tracks and started to set it ablaze in an apparent suicide attempt, reports the Rocky Mountain News, he didn't just kill eleven people and injure 180, he also set in motion consequences that now block commuter rail expansion in the north of Denver.

Denver's existing light rail system was cleverly designed to take advantage of existing railway right-of-ways, and thus to involve very little land-taking or other difficult governmental maneuvers to gain access to the locations needed to lay the tracks. The system has been developed in phases, and so the time from funding votes to "all aboard" has been fairly reasonable, resulting in fairly enthusiastic ridership, and housing development planned to take advantage of soon-to-be-available transit options, termed "light rail condos."

In the next phase of development, called "FasTracks," mounting concerns over accidents such as Alvarez's have caused a change in the degree of cooperation that the railroads have provided to the RTD, the agency which oversees the public transportation system in the Denver area. The light rail system planned for the northern part of Denver, the next phase, has been redrafted as a "heavy rail" system, more like the commuter rail systems in some communities, because of railroads' demands that the rolling stock used be less vulnerable in case of a collision with railroad stock, reducing the personal injury liability exposure for the railroad companies.

Tragic Commuter Train Crash in California Damages Denver Transit System

Light rail is becoming a big part of Denver transit.

Credit: David Maddox

Copyright: David Maddox

Takeaways
  • Commuter rail lines sharing on freight lines' property has raised new liability questions
  • Desperate act in California shows that anything can happen, and lawsuits follow
Resources
Comments
Showing Comment 1 of 1
 
 
I truly do not like the trend of holding public utilities, cities, etc, for accidents that were not caused by them, but by other people. Paying out lawsuits casuses one thing to happen: fares or taxes to be raised. Individuals whose greed to make a quick buck by blaming companies that had no control of the accidents, hurt more people.

Posted on 04/21/2007 at 10:04:00 AM

Type in Your Comments Below - (1000 characters left)
Your name:

Submit your own content on this or any topic. Get started »
Showing Comment 1 of 1
 
Most Commented On