Find » Society » Religion & Spirituality » Why Do Intelligent Human Beings Bel...

Why Do Intelligent Human Beings Believe Literally in Myths?

By Uncle Rico, published May 03, 2007
Published Content: 4  Total Views: 0  Favorited By: 0 CPs
Embed:  
Rating: 4.0 of 5
I have many questions. Many others have the same questions. I have heard the questions many times... on talk radio, in books, and on the internet of course. What always seems to amaze me is the way they are answered. The purpose of this article is to provoke somebody to attempt to answer some or all of these questions... but there is a catch... you cannot use canonized scripture for your answers. Too often I hear the so called answers coming in the form of quoted scripture, but how can the answer come from the very source that's in question? The questions will focus mainly on Christianity and Judaism - the two mythologies that I suspect most readers will be familiar with. When I turn on the TV and I see a preacher yelling to an audience, "this is what God said", and "this is what Jesus meant when he said this", and I see the people nodding their heads and saying "Amen!" I am in awe. I know that these are smart people. They are doctors, lawyers, teachers, engineers, etc. But as intelligent as they are I just cannot understand how they convince themselves to believe literally in obviously ridiculous stories, and I don't think they can answer my simple questions. So who can? Actually, I can. I know all the answers to the following questions, I'm just curious to hear how others answer them.

Did You Know?
All cultures and tribes of the earth, with no connection to one another, have amazingly similar stories passed down through the ages including flood stories, the death and resurrection of a hero, and creation/extinction myths.
Comments
Comments 1 - 13 of 13
 
 
I can't help that people need to know. What makes someone got to the edge and look over a cliff? He wants to know what is at the bottom. It's nothing more than a natural urge to know. And the one's that didn't look over the edge? They'll guess. And pass on their guess. Until it becomes fact. People also need to belong and to create order. Start adding up these needs and urges, and you end up with a bible, of one denomination or another. Steve Hicks - why must good come from religious thought? What makes you think that 'good' is a universally held standard? What is 'loud'? Does that come from religious thought also? The concept of Objective Moral Values as proof of a god is possibly the most bizarre fallacious argument currently being propogated. I find those who think they 'know' far more alarmingy than those who 'believe'.

Posted on 08/10/2007 at 10:08:00 AM

 
I appreciate everyone's comments and respect everyone's viewpoints. The purpose of the article was for someone to answer my questions - either nobody that claims to know the truth read it or simply couldn't answer... oh well.

Posted on 05/17/2007 at 8:05:00 AM

 
I think some events in religious texts surely could have happened but it doesn't really matter to me. Being raised as a Christian didn't affect me in any spiritual way, I remember thinking about it as a history lesson. And you can learn a lot from the past but none of it has ever caused me to wonder if my thoughts and actions contribute to being a "good" person or if I'm leading a "good" life. My conscience is what I rely on to be good. I think we already have within us what we need to be good and lead meaningful lives. Some just decide to ignore theirs I suppose.

Posted on 05/16/2007 at 2:05:00 PM

 
I loved this article! Awesome!

Posted on 05/12/2007 at 12:05:00 AM

 
Thank you Steve, I appreciate your comments. I happen to believe that humans had a natural sense(instinct if you will) of right vs wrong (good vs evil) before the Mosaic Law was inscribed on stone tablets by the hand of God. Having said that, even right and wrong are obviously subject to interpretation - a good Christian/Jew might stomp on a spider on his bathroom floor while a Buddhist might pick it up gently and place it in the back yard (I've seen that). I know atheists and agnostics who have higher moral standards than a lot of religious people. I'm just saying we don't need the Bible to tell us how to behave.

Posted on 05/07/2007 at 3:05:00 PM

 
Good article Rico. I happen to be one of the simpletons who subscribes to an organized religion, but it was a very engaging and interesting article despite our differences in belief and the reasons for them. I did have one question/comment for you. In the last sentence of your article you said, and I'm paraphrasing, "Read the bible for what it's worth and be a good person on your own." What determines "good? Where does the concept of "good" come from if not from religious thought?

Posted on 05/07/2007 at 1:05:00 PM

 
I am in complete agreement with you ShzWhz. The article has nothing to do with God or faith. It simply poses questions to those who claim to know what is beyond knowing. It is directed toward the religious intolerants... literalists... those who believe they know the truth because they were told by man... those who take as infallible ancient texts that have been translated, transliterated, and interpreted by man for thousands of years.

Posted on 05/07/2007 at 9:05:00 AM

 
Faith is something that is not related to intelligence. We think with our minds, we feel with our hearts and we need to 'believe' to fulfill our spiritual needs. Faith is very personal and does not need to be supported with factual information. Religion created by man has been taken too seriously, made into something to fight about. Religion, in my opinion, was never meant to be what it is today. We all need 'something to believe in' because we are human. We all ask 'why are we here?' because we are intelligent and able to reason. Religion is our way of answering that question...How could we ever really find the RIGHT answer to that question? There is NO RIGHT ANSWER, so we all need to find our own personal answer and live our lives' in the way that most fulfills us. Man has made spirituality into a religious war. We, the intelligent people, need to SEE this and stir clear of the getting entangled. We need to focus on our own spiritual needs and just by doing that we will be

Posted on 05/07/2007 at 7:05:00 AM

 
Intelligence does not apply only if you do not assert your religion as factual. Again, it depends on where you fall on the "religious continuum". If you say that your beliefs are facts, meaning they are things that are known to have happened or exist, then they become subject to scientific methods. On the other hand if you say that your beliefs are not necessarily factual, then that begs the question: do you really believe your beliefs?

Posted on 05/04/2007 at 11:05:00 AM

 
I disagree with Nordberg's comments. There are plenty of things in life that give it meaning; it is the afterlife that drives people's beliefs. Religion is a system of beliefs not a science. The questions posed in this article can not be answered with and concrete facts or mathematical formula, therefore, intelligence does not apply.

Posted on 05/04/2007 at 10:05:00 AM

 
Nordberg, you sound like a "better safe than sorry" christian. If you were born in Nepal and raised a Buddhist would you accept Jesus Christ as your personal savior? I don't think my life is meaningless or chaotic, but I believe if I tried to follow the (ever changing) rules of a particular religion I would be constantly confused and afraid. Another problem is how do you define Christianity?... You don't... you can't - maybe for yourself but not for all so-called christians, they're all different in their beliefs. Making up stories is fun and entertaining and certainly has its place in society, I just happen to think that for humanity to assert knowledge of the unknowable is absurd.

Posted on 05/04/2007 at 9:05:00 AM

 
Very interesting, Uncle Rico. The answer to all of your questions are "I don't know for sure, I just believe". That is what every christian person will tell you. It's not whether it is true or false, it's what they believe. And people need something to cling to or life is meaningless. Or should I say life what be chaos...

Posted on 05/03/2007 at 1:05:00 PM

 
Uncle Rico, you seem like a nice person. I'm sure God will strike you down with a lightning bolt in the next week for writing such blasphemy.

Posted on 05/03/2007 at 12:05:00 PM

Type in Your Comments Below - (1000 characters left)

Submit your own content on this or any topic. Get started »
Comments 1 - 13 of 13
 
Advertisment