Lethal Injection is Anything but Humane

Griff
Griff
  • Published Content: 405
  • Total Views: 728,089
  • Favorited By: 18 CPs
Full Profile | Subscribe | Add to Favorites

According to New Findings it is Torture

A large debate is entering the public eye, is that the use of lethal injection to execute death row prisoners is comparable to torture.

Initially lethal injection was implemented as it was thought to be a more humane method of execution than the electric chair. However, there is growing concern that lethal injection may be far from humane.


New research carried out by the University of Miami has discovered that it is possible that prisoners being executed by lethal injection could be suffocating to death when they are still conscious. It is also thought that they could be in quite a large amount of pain. The conclusion of the study said that the drug used for lethal injection was not acting in the way it was supposed to. The results of the study have just been released in the journal of the Public Library of Science.

This had brought up important ethical issues, such as is this method of executions violating the Constitution, which bans "cruel and unusual punishment."

Currently of the states that have the death penalty, 37 use the lethal injection method as the first option for execution. In recent times the ethics of this form of execution has been question by at least 12 other states resulting in their stopping or suspending the use of lethal injection for execution.

The lethal injection contains a number of drugs. These are potassium chloride, which makes the heart stop, pancuronium which paralyses the muscles and the lungs and it also includes an anaesthetic, thiopental.

The idea of the lethal injection is that the prisoner would become unconscious and then die from induced "respiratory and cardiac arrest." However, the study found that often times the drug cocktail does not work as it should.

In the study 42 executions that took place in California and North Caroline were investigated. One of the main parts of the study included looking at the doses of each drug given to the death row prisoner. It was found that often times not enough thiopental was given leaving the prisoner conscious.

 
Comments 1 - 7 of 7  
Comments
Type in Your Comments Below
Jacques has an interesting point. Maybe we need to get rid of protective custody. That way many of these criminals will still get the death penalty. But as taxpayers, we won't have to pay for the appeals.

Posted on 10/11/2008 at 11:10:25 PM

Interesting article, but I personally don't care if it is humane or not. I think if you commit a violent crime, it is only fair you suffer as well.

Posted on 06/14/2007 at 9:06:00 AM

Interesting article. I do however feel more for the victims.

Posted on 05/18/2007 at 11:05:00 PM

Great article..

Posted on 05/05/2007 at 1:05:00 PM

Interesting indea Jacques. I am not sure how I feel. I do feel that the death penalty certainly doesn't act as a deterant, and punishment for crimes needs to be looked at.

Posted on 05/03/2007 at 11:05:00 AM

I agree with Jacques in the fact that prisoners are treated to kindly when death is concerned. As for lethal injection, it was to my knowledge developed by the Nazi's- and they weren't kind.

Posted on 04/25/2007 at 11:04:00 AM

Very interesting angle on this. Strangely (to a lot of my friends), in spite of what much of America thinks, I believe there is no place in America for any of the current methods of execution. What may appear strange is that I FAVOR execution for violent crime, but I believe our current methods are too "soft" and no NOTHING to curb crime. My belief is that violent criminals need to be executed in the most painful, extended way possible on LIVE TV, such as drawing and quartering. If criminals know they will die in agonizing ways, they will think twice about committing crimes. Families of the victims should have the option to be the executioners if they so desire.

Posted on 04/24/2007 at 11:04:00 PM

Comments 1 - 7 of 7 

Have more to say?
Become a Content Producer on AC