Gentle Discipline: Alternatives to Spanking in the First Few Years

How to Discipline Your Baby and Toddler (0-3 Years)

By Heather B., published May 07, 2007
Published Content: 195  Total Views: 385,677  Favorited By: 97 CPs
Rating: 2.9 of 5
To spank or not to spank? It seems everyone is caught up in the debate and has their own opinion. Non-spankers know that there are alternatives to spanking and that you can discipline your child without striking them. Even those who do spank their children often say they do it as a last resort. How is it that some people avoid spanking even as a last resort, while others do not? Do they simply have more disciplinary tools under their belt? Obviously, the more methods you have on your list, the farther down it spanking will be. The best way to eliminate spanking is not to convince people that it is wrong but to teach them how to avoid situations in which they may the other ways of handling behavioral problems. There are so many methods of gentle discipline that one should never reach the bottom of the list, whether spanking is on it or not.

You should never punish a baby. They do not understand that their behavior is inappropriate or wrong, and they cannot be made to. They may be made to associate a behavior with an action, such as throwing food with being slapped; however, they learn nothing from this about appropriateness or morality. Do not expect a baby to behave as you want when you want. There is no way to teach a baby right from wrong. Punishing a baby is very cruel. Slapping a baby just makes her think you are angry with her, and she will not understand why. It will only hurt her heart and sting her skin. Withholding affection because she isn't obeying is certainly not acceptable. A baby needs to feel secure in her relationship with her parents, and building that relationship is the most important thing in the first year of life. Don't damage your bond by trying to start disciplining your child too early.

Gentle Discipline: Alternatives to Spanking in the First Few Years

A happy little boy!

Credit: Josee Holland

Copyright: Josee Holland @ sxc.hu

Takeaways
  • Baby-proof your home.
  • Redirect your child.
  • Teach with consequences.
Did You Know?
Tantrums are not always caused by a child not getting their way. Many times temper tantrums are caused by a need that is not being met or by frustration. Showing compassion and meeting your child's needs are great ways to combat tantrums.
Comments
Showing Comments 1 - 15 of 18
Next >>
 
To banish is to send away. I don't feel placing my toddler in the playpin until he calms down is banishing him, as it doesn't drive him away. It merely confines him for a few moments. And yes, I do know what positive parenting is and that it's not rewarding.

Posted on 05/14/2007 at 9:05:00 PM

 
I dislike the time outs...I only use Positive Parenting, which is not rewarding either. But banishing?

Posted on 05/14/2007 at 8:05:00 PM

 
This is super advice. I never spank, I have twins so the one time I tapped a hiney the other one was right there letting me know I was wrong. I also can not raise my voice without the other twin mocking me. Makes for long days and fun times!

Posted on 05/10/2007 at 10:05:00 PM

 
I totally agree. There's a girl on another site I use that is ALWAYS complaining about her daughter touching her DVDs. She yells at her, says no meanly, smacks her, and complains it doesn't work. I'm like, well maybe you should try something new! She refuses all our suggestions. She says she CANNOT put the DVDs up higher because the shelf is built-in. I'm like, they are not fucking GLUED to the shelf. Take them down; put some toys on the shelf. Then go put the DVDs in a box in a closet or buy a $10 shelf at Walmart to put them on. Problem solved. She keeps complaining and hitting her daughter because she doesn't want to solve the problem. She can move the DVDs but doesn't want to. She could hang a shelf but doesn't want to. It's ridiculous.

Posted on 05/10/2007 at 2:05:00 PM

 
I just had to comment again, I really think more parents need to read this article and understand that they are the ones who need to child proof their home, keep the things away from a curious toddler instead of getting mad at them for touching things they don't want them too. I've seen so many parents get mad and yell at their toddlers for touching glass statues on coffee tables and such, I ask them why not just put the statue up where he can't reach it..problem solved. They look at me and actually say things like, no he needs to learn not to touch it. Crazy.

Posted on 05/10/2007 at 11:05:00 AM

 
I never spanked my daughter, not once. My husband and I were beat as children and we vowed never to hit our kids. She is now almost 16 and is well behaved, healthy and respectful.

Posted on 05/10/2007 at 11:05:00 AM

 
Length of punishments can be increased as the child ages and her memory improves, but it should never be excessive. Grounding a teenager for two weeks may be a good idea, but punishing a child younger than that for that long is just ridiculous. The child will forget what was done wrong and not understand the punishment. The point of discipline is to teach, and if the child isn't learning, there's no point.

Posted on 05/08/2007 at 10:05:00 PM

 
definitely agree with this; ESPECIALLY the fact that discipline times need to be kept short... a friend's mom has younger children and they'll stay in trouble for days or weeks, eventually not knowing what they did wrong (nor why it was wrong, which I think is very important). If you were to ask them what they did, they'd say "we made mommy mad". It really doesn't fix things at all...

Posted on 05/08/2007 at 8:05:00 PM

 
Nice article. Sometimes being a parent is frustrating but spanking is only a release of our anger and frustration. It sure doesn't teach the kids anything except big people hurt when they hit.

Posted on 05/08/2007 at 5:05:00 PM

 
Really great advice.

Posted on 05/08/2007 at 3:05:00 PM

 
Yep, don't give in. But that doesn't mean you can't or shouldn't be willing to compromise. You can do this even with a two year old. Like if my son is tantrumming because he wants an expensive toy, but I don't want to buy it for him because I can't afford it I might go get like something cheap that I know he'll like that I don't mind buying. And what that teaches him is he can't always have what he wants, he can't always have anything at all, but that mommy is willing to compromise. SOme people will think that's a reward for bad behavior, but nope. It's a compromise. I didn't give in on the expensive toy and spend my money, so I'm good. And the kid isn't crying and throwing a fit anymore, but didn't get his way. So it's good!

Posted on 05/07/2007 at 7:05:00 PM

 
Great article. I think one of the most important lines you mentioned is "follow through"!! Parents need to understand that they have to mean what they say, or what is the child going to learn? "When I yell long enough, I get what I want!" And that won't be good.

Posted on 05/07/2007 at 7:05:00 PM

 
Another 5 stars for you. :-)

Posted on 05/07/2007 at 1:05:00 PM

 
my parents never spanked me. boy am i a brat :)

Posted on 05/07/2007 at 1:05:00 PM

 
Great advice, I so needed to read this today. lol :)

Posted on 05/07/2007 at 12:05:00 PM

Type in Your Comments Below - (1000 characters left)
Your name:

Submit your own content on this or any topic. Get started »
Showing Comments 1 - 15 of 18
Next >>
Most Commented On