5

Canadian Forces Banned from Schools - Part I

Coalition of Students, Teachers Believes Canadian Forces Target Underprivileged, Withhold Truth

Military recruiters are no longer welcome in Quebec's schools, says a coalition of teachers' and student's unions. In February of 2009 the Centrale des syndicats du Québec (CSQ,) Quebec's largest teacher's union, received representatives from the anti-recruitment group Operation
 Objection. This fall, as a result of that meeting the union has launched a campaign to keep the military out of the province's schools. Letters from the union have been sent to the Education Ministry, to school boards, to colleges and parents committees informing these recipients that schools are not the appropriate place for military recruitment.

Military Recruiting in High Schools and CEGEPs: Targeting Vulnerable Young People?

After reading some recent news articles I was left with the impression that the issue at hand was whether the military was recruiting in schools where students are underage (i.e. high schools and CEGEPs) and whether military recruiters were telling the whole truth when they set up information kiosks. After listening to a CBC radio interview with the union's special counsel Alain Pelissier, and after looking at through information published by the Campagne d'opposition au recrutement and Operation Objection, it seems that these people will be happy with nothing less than the total elimination of any hint of the military from our schools - right down to not even allowing the local cadet unit to hold its meetings in the school gym after hours.

Although on the surface the issue would seem to be the targeting of a vulnerable segment of our society, this does not appear to be the real motivation behind the campaign. The first argument put forth by the teacher's union is that the new recruitment policies adopted by the military aim to "seduce" sixteen year olds. The coalition accuses recruiters of going out to high schools with contract in hand, proposing to enroll high school students on the spot at an age when they are not yet old enough to vote or to purchase alcohol and tobacco. ("Campagne de la CSQ contre le recrutement militaire dans les écoles")

Kyla Matton
Written by Kyla Matton
I am a homeschooling mother who has recently rediscovered her love of classic children's literature. Education and literacy are causes near to my heart, as is the care of special needs child...  -  Full profile
A young man without school motivation needs time to grow, and joining the military is a viable choice. Parents must be supportive and yet allow the child to make this important life decision. This article is a guide to issues in the military decision.
Some frequently asked questions about the possibility of an imminent military draft.
Obama promises to end the military's "don't ask, don't tell" policy, which will score high on "feel good" politics, but it will, along with his other policies, put recruitment in jeopardy.
The majority of Americans oppose the draft, but will that be enough to keep it from being reinstated?
Driving is thought of as a right rather than a privilege. Consider three regular driving schools in the DFW area, and one school emphasizing real-life driving scenarios for your teen. What skills do you want your teen to learn?
During the past year there have been many news items that involve gay students getting kicked out of school for being gay. Most of these schools that have done this are usually private or religious based.
Public schools in Los Angeles are in a devastating condition.
Related information
 
Comments 1 - 10 of 10  
Comments
Type in Your Comments Below

Very well presented!

Posted on 11/10/2009 at 8:11:46 PM

The military, whether in the US or Canada, is a career that has supported many families. Excellent facts, Kyla!

Posted on 11/10/2009 at 4:11:30 PM

Beautifully put, Joseph. And I know I've said it before, but I'm proud of those 20 years you served too. I thank you for what you went through so I could grow up and raise my own children in freedom. I also agree with you very much, that it is a parent's job to give guidance to a child so he can make good decisions. The point of the career fair should be to present a wide variety of options, and to encourage the necessary dialogue for making informed decisions. As soon as even one group is banned from that fair, we're no longer presenting students an accurate picture & we're taking way the right of the individual to make his own choices within the family unit.

Posted on 11/10/2009 at 10:11:41 AM

The military is an honest and honorable profession. The military teaches dicipline and responsibility, get out of bed and go to work. It will give you a free education, you will learn a trade and various skills. The military does not want to invade other countries, only politicians do to serve their own self centered interest. The purpose of a military is to defend its country against any aggresser and to protect its inhabitants. Students should be aware of what the military has to offer. They can make their own choices. For many young people it prevent them from a living on streets infested with drugs and diseases. I spent 20 years in the Royal Canadian Air Force. I am very proud to have served my Country and would do it again. The military must have the same right as other large companies to visit the schools. It does not hurt anyone. The purpose is to inform. It is up to the parents to provide the necessary direction to their sons and daughters if they wish to join the military. If

Posted on 11/10/2009 at 9:11:26 AM

great info! :)

Posted on 11/09/2009 at 2:11:49 PM

Oh Peter, I'm sure your young people & parents must feel terrible about recruitment right now! I'd probably feel the way you do too, if our military were more like yours. When it comes to issues of patriotism, military service and also where our armed forces get involved in conflicts around the world, Canada and the United States vary greatly. The school visits during a once yearly career fair are usually the only time most people have contact with our military, and even there recruiters are not permitted to do more than inform. They attend with a great number and variety of other educational institutions and potential employers, representing but one of the many options open to a young person getting ready to graduate school.

Posted on 11/09/2009 at 2:11:29 AM

Marilisa, I've heard that US military recruiters were getting personal contact information for students & actually calling them at home. It's important to note that this is definitely not the case in Canada, nor do our youth have to register for selective service. I have never once heard of a Canadian recruiter approaching an individual - you have to seek them out. I agree with you & your kids asking for no contact. It's a very different situation in our two countries.

Posted on 11/09/2009 at 2:11:03 AM

While military recruiters aren't banned in US schools, parents can sign a form which forbids military from soliciting your child. I've fielded many a call from recruiters, many of whom ask directly for your child and do not identify themselves. I'm becoming familiar with their technique. I refuse to allow them to speak to our kids and request that they remove the name from their list. BTW- I've cleared this with our kids and they totally agree.

Posted on 11/08/2009 at 12:11:40 PM

Good for Canada. I wish military recruiters were banned from US schools, as well

Posted on 11/08/2009 at 8:11:46 AM

Excellent article! Thought provoking!

Posted on 11/08/2009 at 5:11:11 AM

Comments 1 - 10 of 10 

Have more to say?
Become a Contributor on AC

Most Comments Today