Garnier Nutrisse Hair Color Versus Loreal Superior Preference

A Comparison of Two Red Hair Color Products

Coloring your own hair can be fun. It can be quite enjoyable to experiment with different colors and shades. It can also be a total disaster. I have used two different brands of color. I have used both of these products several times and used different colors within each brand. Here is my
 experience with these two brands of hair color.

The two colors I have used the most are Garnier Nutrisse 66 True Red and Loreal Superior Preference RR07 Intense Red Copper. Both hair color products give approximately the same shadeof red to dark brown hair, which is my natural hair color. You can find both of these brands at your local drug store or department store, such as Wal Mart. But, that is where the similarity stops.

The Garnier product is a bit trickier to use. The color agent is in a tube that has to be squeezed to get the gel into the reactor bottle. It is a bit difficult to use when the tube is slippery and you are wearing latex gloves to protect your hands. It is also troublesome to be sure the entire amount of color agent is squeezed out of the tube. The Garnier product also burns your skin much more after application.

The Loreal product is much easier to use. The color agent is in a bottle with a screw on top. It is very easy to open and much easier to get into the bottle with the reactant agent. The Loreal product still stings a bit when it has been on your skin a while, but not nearly as much as the Garnier. Loreal also does not discolor the skin as much as the Garnier product. It is almost impossible to color your hair and not get a bit of the product on your forehead or ear.

After using any hair color that causes your hair to be lighter than the original color, keeping it conditioned and hydrated is a major issue. The Garnier hair color comes with one application of conditioner. To get more Garnier conditioner, you are required to purchase it separately. The Loreal product comes with six applications of a once a week super hydrating conditioner. This is enough to last until the next time you color your hair. If you buy Loreal again, you will have another six weeks of conditioner, as well. So, you only have to buy additional conditioner if your hair is very dry.

Related information
  • Finding a product that stays an attractive shade of red can be difficult.
  • Conditioning is important to keep colored hair healthy.
 
Comments 1 - 10 of 19 Next >>
Comments
Type in Your Comments Below

I cannot use L'Oreal hair products - it's as though they are made with the cheapest ingredients. Garnier left my hair gummy (bad sign) and L'Oreal has always burned my scalp and falls right out. Their shampoos aren't any better. For silver/grey/white hair coverage, the best thing to do is apply it first to those areas and leave it on for 15 more minutes and then apply the color to the rest of your hair. Highlights seem to be the best way to cover grey/white/silver hair(s). If you can get a friend to help you you won't have to turn into a contortionist! As for shampoos, the ingredients label should not have sulfates, alcohol, listed first. The John Frieda shampoos and conditioners work well, and really do help keep your hair healthy. You can try a beauty school as well - I had a color weave done for $45. It came out well, and I didn't have to fiddle around with it. Oh, and never use those haircolors in the 99c stores - they are made in Korea and will wreck your hair. Good luck.

Posted on 05/10/2009 at 1:05:32 PM

I used Garnier Nutrisse Luscious Mango for years as well, and have yet to find a replacement for it since it's been discontinued. None of the other reds I've tried have come close to it. That was the best out of all the Nutrisse shades I have tried, the rest seem to fade very quickly (but not as quickly as Colorsilk or anything by Clairol).

Posted on 02/05/2009 at 9:02:55 PM

I love garnier, but had to stop using it because the company discontinued the color I use which was luscious mango, brillent copper number 68, it was a beautiful shade of red. They have other shades of reds, some darker, some lighter, but none that can replace number 68. I don't know why they discontinued that color, out of all the other colors they have, probable because I liked it. Is there anyone else that was using that shade, and now is lost to find a replacement?

Posted on 01/05/2009 at 6:01:33 PM

Hi. i used garnier nutrisse and i liked that out come... of colour, for about a week that is. my hair is brittle and i feel like a sheep dog! i shed so darn much and it's kind of embaressing not gonna lie... anyway, i guess it varies from person to person. i liked the colour of red, but not the effect is had on my hair.

Posted on 01/03/2009 at 10:01:32 PM

Same here! I used garnier and my hair came out in clumps.. It took two years to get back to normal.

Posted on 12/17/2008 at 3:12:42 PM

The burning feeling you describe is a skin allergy, so it varies from person to person. Garnier doesn't bother me at all, Loreal stings a little, and Clairol Nice 'n Easy leaves my scalp itchy for weeks. I also don't agree with you on which brand dyes skin more. I just used Garnier and didn't notice a large smudge of dye on my shoulder until it was time to rinse the dye out. Thankfully, all I had to do was wipe my skin with some damp TP and the color was gone. Loreal, however, always left my scalp colored, no matter how careful I was with the application.

Posted on 11/30/2008 at 12:11:16 PM

I just dyed my hair with the Garnier after a few times of dying with Loreal, and I have to say that garnier is AMAZING. I will never go back, the color is so gorgeous, and my hair feels amazing.

Posted on 10/04/2008 at 9:10:20 AM

I ruined your hair? I don't recall holding you down and putting the color on your hair. YOU put the color on it. YOU ruined it. Stop being a such a baby and take responsibility for your own actions.

Posted on 08/22/2008 at 8:08:58 AM

made my hair really dry and the grey showed as I washed it did not leave it shiny like the box says, Just dull

Posted on 08/22/2008 at 7:08:04 AM

so thanks so much for ruining my hair. i have never dyed my hair before and it killed my hair, leaving it damaged and weak. if you give it a slight tug and a whole handful comes out. you guys suck. never again.

Posted on 08/18/2008 at 11:08:13 PM

Comments 1 - 10 of 19 Next >>