Izimi: Obsolete File Sharing Program at Launch

A Solution Looking for a Problem

I first learned about Izimi from digg.com. I was reading articles about Scientology, and found that one user in particular had submitted mostly pro-Scientology articles, and articles raving about Izimi. I checked out Izimi.com, and found what may be one of the least useful services to
 debut since the DotCom era.

On it's web site, Izimi describes itself as "the fastest and simplest way for you to share photos, music, videos...anything, straight from your PC" while many of the digg.com articles described it as a "youtube killer." The web site also advertises, "No limits - share any file type, size and any quality". So far so good. It was sounding like youtube.com or imageshack.us with the ability to share any file type.

The next claim however, is what started setting of warning bells. "Faster - just click and instantly share straight from your PC, no upload needed."

How, exactly can you make files available without uploading them?

The next warning bell cam when I realized it was Windows only. You need to download, and run, a Windows application to make all this magic happen.

Here's how it works. You download their application, run it, and from then on, whenever anyone requests the file it gets uploaded from your PC. They brag about you retaining control of your files, and while it isn't explicitly stated on the web site, if your computer isn't on and their application running, the links to your files won't work. No one will be able to download them.

Izimi describes this as "P2P" technology. While technically accurate, it's misleading. Bittorrent, Kazaa, Limewire and other P2P services work by distributing the load. A single file enters the network, and is served up by multiple users. The more popular a file is, the more people will be serving it up.

 
Comments 1 - 4 of 4  
Comments
Type in Your Comments Below

Wait, let me get this straight, your target market are people who are too dumb to figure out how to use an FTP client and too cheap to sign up with a web hosting provider? I need to hit your site. I can't wait to see how much stuff people have made available without knowing about it. By the way, doesn't "Caching" the filed defeat the whole "stop sharing whenever you want" advantage?

Posted on 09/25/2007 at 2:09:00 PM

(TIP - read my BOTTOM comment first, comments get truncated, so they are in reverse order) ...om, plus there are a host of other enhancements in both the app (aimed at making it easier and faster to organise the files you are sharing) and the web (aimed at making it more engaging for viewers). I should sign off by saying I'm not intending to try to negate your opinions because as I believe they are valid for some people, just to balance the arguement a little, keep it less emotive, offer a little of the rationale behind the product, and provide some news of soon-to-be-release enhancements. Thanks for taking the time to write, and thats for the opp to respond. David www.dpingram.com www.izimi.com

Posted on 06/07/2007 at 10:06:00 AM

...caching, why use izimi instead of a file upload website? Well, it really is instant as there is no processing of files at our end and the URL you get is immediately useable. Your audience get to see your native file format and for some thats very important. There are no restrictions on file type, size, and quantity, so you really can share what you like without having to maintain accounts with several services. I have another admission, and that is we consider the current app to be rather too clunky. To that end we have been busy redeveloping the whole UI (app and website), the sharing process itself, and adding new features to speed up and simplify sharing. For example, in the new version (planned release end of June) you can share multiple files at once (currently just one at a time), we have reduced the number of clicks required to share files to just one (current around 6 clicks in a wizard), we've added private sharing so if you wish your stuff is NOT indexed on izimi.c

Posted on 06/07/2007 at 10:06:00 AM

Hi Matthew, I work at izimi so I can shed some more light and alternative opinions on this. The points you make about your PC needing to be on to serve are valid, as are the bandwidth and speed issues. We too recognise this and in a few months we'll be implementing a means of caching content as its served the first time which aims to provide solutions to these obstacles. I def hear your opinions re the arguement between uploading or not, but izimi was not conceived in a vacuum, in fact we developed izimi in response to a problem we had experienced, and our users are testament to the fact that its not a unique set of problems. Of course I respect its not for everyone - no software or service is - and your opinion is valid for you and most likely for others too. Though it may not be for you there's a danger in expecting that one persons views hold universally true. I have heard this called the straw-poll of one. Given we're addressing the online/offline and speed issue with

Posted on 06/07/2007 at 10:06:00 AM

Comments 1 - 4 of 4