Find » Health & Wellness » Diseases & Conditions » Andrew Speaker Apologizes to the Wo...

Andrew Speaker Apologizes to the World as His Family Defends Him

For Those Exposed to Tuberculosis, I'm Sorry May Not Be Enough

By Maria Giorgio, published Jun 18, 2007
Published Content: 61  Total Views: 31,606  Favorited By: 30 CPs
Embed:  
Rating: 4.4 of 5
Andrew Speaker said he's sorry. The lawyer, who has a rare strain of tuberculosis, risked the lives of people around the world after the CDC told him not to fly. His family appeared on Good Morning America hoping to prove that he is a victim. With all of the twists to this story, will the public ever see Speaker as anything other than negligent?

Speaker's new father-in-law is a researcher at the Center for Disease Control (researching tuberculosis, no less). Mr. Cooksey insists that his position had nothing to do with the delay in Speaker's flight ban or his decision to fly at all. Some aren't buying it. Postings at various internet sites are critical of the family's lack of social responsibility.

People can believe Andrew Speaker's claim that the CDC was not clear about his leaving the country. They even believe that the news that he has XDR, a drug-resistant strain of tuberculosis, didn't reach him until after he departed for Greece. The public stops believing Speaker at the point where he flew to Canada to sneak across the U. S. border, despite a warning that he could infect others.

The CDC told Speaker to turn himself into Italian authorities while he was in Rome. He claims that he was fearful of Italy's health care, so he ignored the order. Surely, his father-in-law, as a tuberculosis researcher, knew that the head of the World Health Organization Stop Tuberculosis Program is an Italian doctor - Mario Raviglione. That doesn't seem like substandard care, does it? If Speaker doubted foreign health, then why did he leave the United States in the first place?

The family of Speaker blames the CDC for not bringing them home. At the same time, government officials say that they were preparing to bring him back when Speaker hopped a flight from Prague to Canada. Is the government responsible for a personal injury attorney vacationing in Europe on a trip he voluntarily took?

It is hard to feel sorry for Andrew Speaker after knowing his actions, despite his reasons. This personal injury attorney may have the tables turned and find himself as a defendant in civil suits. No amount of money will give a victim back their health, though.

Andrew Speaker Apologizes to the World as His Family Defends Him

How many people will be affected by Andrew Speaker's decision to ignore CDC warnings?

Credit: Microsoft

Copyright: Microsoft

Takeaways
  • According to the CDC, Andrew Speaker flew seven times after his initial diagnosis.
Comments
Showing Comments 1 - 5 of 5
 
 
Great reporting!

Posted on 06/18/2007 at 10:06:00 PM

 
I still think it's interesting that his father in law was a TB specialist. As a lawyer, Speaker would know all the law loopholes. I think this was a case of mismanagement within the CDC, and a guy with TB that was a tad selfish. Everyone knows that TB is contagious. Don't they???

Posted on 06/18/2007 at 1:06:00 PM

 
There is also the point that while the CDC could have put Speaker on a no-fly list preventing him from LEAVING the U.S., they did not. The question in part is what happened in those three or so days that made him suddenly extremely dangerous (though no one has ever said he was "infectious") and also, why is there no similar urgency to seek out the people who flew TO Europe with him only a handful of days before the CDC abruptly changed Speaker's classification. I'd like to know what happened at the CDC to prompt the sudden change; what about the people on the Greece-bound flight; and what is being done to hold the CDC (including the dad-in-law) and the Fulton County, Georgia Health and Wellness Dept., and Kaiser-Permanente Hospital accountable. That is what I'd like to know. In my book, THEY misbehaved and caused a world of trouble for a man, a family, innocent by-standers, and...a world. THIS is unforgivable: Overseers of public safety who neglect to oversee. Inexcusable, unforgivable

Posted on 06/18/2007 at 1:06:00 PM

 
Very nice article. He really put everyone in a position that they didnt deserve to face. I think Aly Adair is right, selfish and stupid on his part.

Posted on 06/18/2007 at 12:06:00 PM

 
Good report on this. Of course, everyone is going to blame everyone, but with a father who works for the CDC - does common sense not kick in when you are told you have TB - UUMM, maybe you shouldn't travel no matter WHAT anyone says? No forgiveness from me! That was selfish and stupid.

Posted on 06/18/2007 at 10:06:00 AM

Type in Your Comments Below - (1000 characters left)
Your name:

Submit your own content on this or any topic. Get started »
Showing Comments 1 - 5 of 5
 
Most Commented On