Some Question Mitt Romney's Refusal to Grant Pardons

Mitt Romney had a policy when he was governor, one that made modern Massachusetts history among governors. During his term, he never once granted a pardon, a power bestowed among state governors and of the President of the United States.

During his term, 100 requests for communications came to his attention along with 172 requests for pardons. He turned down each and every one, no exception. And the reason why? He never wanted to overturn a jury, as reported by
Some Question Mitt Romney's Refusal to Grant Pardons
the Associated Press.

Said an aide of Romney's, Eric Fehrnstrom, "Governor Romney's view is that it would take a compelling set of circumstances to set aside the punishment and guilt resulting from a criminal trial... the power to pardon should only be used in extraordinary circumstances."

It was reported in an Associated Press article that Eric Ferrnstrom, when commenting about Romney's policy, was not aware of the case of Anthony Circosta, a man that many think has more than proven his worthiness of a pardon.

Circosta, at 13, shot another boy in the arm with a BB gun. He didn't even break skin. For that, Circosta was convicted of assault. Since the conviction, Circosta has worked his way through college, then joined the Army National Guard and has become a decorated Iraq war veteran, leading a platoon of 20 through the Sunni triangle. Romney refused the request for Circosta's pardon twice, even against the suggestion of the state's Board of Pardons.

Circosta, now 29, dreams of becoming a police officer, a dream that cannot be realized without the pardon. Circosta says, "I've done everything I can to give back to my state and my community and my country and to get brushed aside is very frustrating...I'm not some shlub off the street."

Former Massachusetts Governor, Republican William Weld, commuted the sentence of Joseph Yandle, a man who had spent 23 years in prison for murder. Two years later, Yandle was returned to prison. Weld had commuted his sentence because he had claimed that during the Vietnam War, he had become addicted to heroin, which led him to commit his crimes. Yandle was returned to prison when it became known that he had never served in the Vietnam War.

 
Comments 1 - 4 of 4  
Comments
Type in Your Comments Below

I agree with Deborah Dera. Just because the kid got lucky and didn't shoot the other kid's eye out is not reason for a pardon. Also, so if someone lives a good life after committing a crime he/she deserves a clear slate, NO. He did deserve a second chance which he made the most of. I believe pardons should be more of a legal matter not a political one.

Posted on 02/01/2008 at 7:02:10 AM

I see what you're trying to say, but don't at the same time. For example, your description of what Circosta did is limited. He shot a kid in the arm and didn't even break skin. My question would be whether or not he did it on purpose. If so, the intention was worse than the final result, yes...but the intention was still there - he was just unlucky. We all live with consequences. If no one's going to erase my debt, I sure as hell hope convicted criminals wouln't have their wrongs erased. Besides, if the guy was 13 at the time, why isn't that conviction sealed?

Posted on 06/18/2007 at 1:06:00 PM

This is a shame!

Posted on 06/12/2007 at 8:06:00 PM

Positions of power require some tough decisions; I don't aspire to one.

Posted on 06/12/2007 at 6:06:00 PM

Comments 1 - 4 of 4