Is Urban Fiction Appropriate for African American Teenagers?

By LaQuisha Hall, published Jul 30, 2007
Published Content: 19  Total Views: 6,371  Favorited By: 10 CPs
Rating: 4.8 of 5
African American teenagers, who are commonly reluctant readers and who do not read on their grade level in school, are found more frequently reading urban fiction or "ghetto" books. Urban fiction writings are complete with urban settings and lifestyles of African American characters. These books also include explicit violence, sex scenes and profanity. The target audience for these books is generally African American adults. The authors of urban fiction books are commonly young African Americans themselves.

People can relate to book characters that seem to be in similar situations. Teens' attraction to these books could be based primarily on the fact that they have similar experiences or they simply understand urban fiction characters. In addition, these books are more contemporary and different from the literature books they are frequently required to read in school.

My High School Experience with Zane

During my first year of teaching English, I received my induction into the world of teenagers reading urban fiction. One of my most hard working students in the class was also a special education student, labeled as reading on the second grade level. I was impressed by this student because anytime she completed an assignment; she would begin reading a book. What eventually occurred is that she would be so entertained by the book that she would almost refuse to put it away when it was time to begin a class assignment. There were even times when she would put the book inside of the classroom textbook in order to continue her leisurely reading. After one week of the student's repetitious habits, I finally asked her if I could see the book.

I was almost appalled to find that the cover of the book displayed a woman taking off her shirt. The title, Addicted, did not seem appropriate for my student. After asking a series of questions to the student about how many books she read and how often, I thumbed through the pages of the book. What I found was explicit profanity, several pages of graphic sex scenes and typos.

Takeaways
  • How Urban Fiction Helps Teens
  • How Urban Fiction Harms Teens
  • How Parents and Teachers Can Help
Did You Know?
"By age 17, only about 1 in 17 seventeen year olds can read and gain information from specialized text... This includes: 1 in 100 African American 17 year olds."
Source: The National Institute for Literacy
Comments
Showing Comments 1 - 7 of 7
 
 
This is a tough issue... "dime novels" for the 21st century. I'm sure you will think of some creative ways to deal with it in the classroom. A class project to re-write a chapter (that isn't toooo graphic) and make it more meaningful and less trashy?

Posted on 10/02/2007 at 9:10:00 PM

 
Great article. I spent my first year teaching at a 97% African-American school and probably 1 in 10 of my students were reading this 'urban fiction' and Zane popped up a lot. I realized there was some trashy sex stuff in there, but I didn't realize that people could publish these books without going through an editor like everyone else. Now it makes sense why even some of my avid reading students had horrible writing skills.

Posted on 09/12/2007 at 7:09:00 PM

 
I agree that teens and children shouldn't be reading books that depict profanity and sex. I feel the same way about music. Children should not be exposed to that garbage. Reading is very good for children, however, it's important that they don't get hooked on garbage. It's hard because this kind of thing is all over the TV and Video channels. We can stop them from reading certain books and listening to certain music at home; But they just do it at their frirnds house or where ever. Very good write.

Posted on 09/06/2007 at 5:09:00 PM

 
Great article. Sounds like an opportunity for a really good writer to step in and raise the bar with some excellent fiction in the same genre for this audience.

Posted on 08/19/2007 at 4:08:00 AM

 
This was a great piece! I can see why teens are attracted to these books. I don't think they're appropriate though.

Posted on 08/01/2007 at 2:08:00 PM

 
Thanks for this great article. I also agree that teenagers should not be reading books that depict profanity and sex scenes. Sophie

Posted on 07/30/2007 at 10:07:00 PM

 
Wow... We're experiencing a similar thing in the opera world, I think. The stage directors either dumbing things down to the audience or the PR machines over-promoting pretty faces who can't really do the music justice yet (or in some cases...ever). Lots of us wish they wouldn't underestimate the audience so much and incite us to learn to be able to distinguish good singing from mediocre or worse, but we're also afraid of turning potential new audience away from the genre if we don't enthusiastically endorse the pretty faces... Thanks for writing this up! :)

Posted on 07/30/2007 at 5:07:00 PM

Type in Your Comments Below - (1000 characters left)
Your name:

Submit your own content on this or any topic. Get started »
Showing Comments 1 - 7 of 7
 
Most Commented On