Atheism, Theism and Open-mindedness

Whether Atheist or Believer, it All Comes Down to Faith

By Jay Christopher, published Aug 14, 2007
Published Content: 1  Total Views: 31  Favorited By: 0 CPs
Rating: 2.3 of 5
While I agree that the nature of atheism, as it is modernly observed, is more conducive to "open-mindedness" than the most prevalent forms of religion in the United States (specifically evangelical Christianity, and varying forms of Islam of which information is most widely obtained through the media's reporting on foreign events and the current emphasis on global terrorism), it has nothing to do with the atheist's thirst for facts, or the theist's seeming denial of them.

The differences between the two lay in the social, political, religious, philosophical and psychological cues we use to define our ideas about reality and ourselves. Because Christians, for instance, emphasize the teachings of the bible as their foremost guide to life, and this same guide is used by all Christians, and because this emphasis is, in fact, what defines them as Christians, logic requires that they tune their moral compass to consistently guide them to the bible when confronted with a question about reality, ethics or morality.

Atheists, on the other hand, have no such unanimously used compass. "Atheism" does not bind us to any particular dogma, precept or maxim. While religion most often requires the belief in a being, beings, or a force outside the physical world, atheism requires a lack of belief, a distinction that defines the latter term.

It is because of the required philosophical, religious and moral compass of many religions that makes followers less "open-minded." Technically, it is the purpose of religion to do just that. (Again, as an example, I turn to the bible, the religious document with which I have the most intimate experience): The bible, through stories, commandments, and self-proclamations of authority aims to narrow its adherents' beliefs to correspond only with the bible, or to choose the path laid out in the bible over any other option. Indeed, this simplification of the world through the narrowing of acceptable life-choices provides exactly the satisfaction religious stalwarts seek.

Takeaways
  • Atheism
  • Religion
  • Open-Mindedness
Comments
Showing Comments 1 - 2 of 2
 
 
......."A belief that no God exists is not a lack of belief, but rather a belief in the nonexistence of a deity."...wow you are really twisting words here. I don't believe in fairies or father christmas does this mean that i have a belief in the non- existence of father christmas or fairies or unicorns or whatever. I merely have the absence of belief in god/fairies/father christmas/Zeus etc etc. I am assuming that you don't believe in Zeus and the 1,000,000 or so other gods that man has believed in at some time or another in in the last 40,000 years. As you can't disprove the existence or non existence of all these gods does this mean that you believe in them all? By the way why don't you believe in Zeus???

Posted on 06/30/2008 at 7:06:05 PM

 
You raise some interesting points in this article. I think, though, that your statement that atheism is "the lack of belief in something rather than the belief in something" is a little misleading. A belief that no God exists is not a lack of belief, but rather a belief in the nonexistence of a deity. As you yourself noted, neither side of this debate can disprove the other side's position; further, any scientist will admit that it is impossible to prove a negative (e.g., "There is no God"). In both cases, it seems to come down to faith. Agnostics can lay claim to lacking a belief on this question, but neither theists nor atheists can make the same claim.

Posted on 06/07/2008 at 5:06:58 PM

Type in Your Comments Below - (1000 characters left)
Your name:

Submit your own content on this or any topic. Get started »
Showing Comments 1 - 2 of 2
 
Most Commented On