Higher Cigarette Taxes Are Unfair

A Rebuttal to Content Producer Tiffany Riley's Argument

By Dina Hollerbach, published Aug 15, 2007
Published Content: 50  Total Views: 145,145  Favorited By: 9 CPs
Rating: 3.2 of 5
Tiffany Riley, a fellow content producer on Associated Content, has written an article entitled, Higher Cigarette Tax: Good For Society, or Mean For the Addicted in which she stated, after "careful exploration" that she feels, "It is absolutely hilarious to make one pay more for an item that kills them." To me, impending death, and regardless of what causes it, is not something that should be discussed using adjectives like 'hilarious'.

In her article, Riley has also stated that she feels that smokers are of a lower class, smokers are less intelligent, they are partially responsible for the regression of humanity as a whole, and that they're are not as "pretty" of a class of citizens. She also went on to label smokers as stupid, sleazy, downright dumb, disgusting, and as "unneeded resource wasting humans."

First of all, based on the title of Riley's article, I did not know that the attractiveness of smokers was being debated. I was unaware that prettiness is a characteristic that is interrelated with class and is relevant to taxes. Furthermore, Riley, when you say that you carefully considered those people who are directly affected when you wrote this article, I beg to differ.

Not only have you printed a disgraceful, poorly written and clearly not "carefully explored" article that is downright insulting to those who smoke or have ever loved a smoker, but your pseudo-economics are completely flawed and are backed by no research whatsoever.

You stated: "This is simply evolution at work here. The stupid people smoke. Smoking kills them off. In the mean time, because the smokers are down right dumb and will continue smoking even if they have to pay more to do so, it generates more money for the people who are still alive after their death. After the smokers die off, the money generated from their stupidity will then be used for the live people to thus enhance our society into a better one than it was previously."

Higher Cigarette Taxes Are Unfair

Good results never come from sin taxes.

Credit: Public

Copyright: Public

Comments
Showing Comments 1 - 15 of 23
Next >>
 
Way to bring up Hitler. I think if you're dumb enough to damage your lungs like that and get addicted to nicotine you should be taxed, end of story.

Posted on 10/24/2007 at 5:10:00 AM

 
I think all people who smoke should be hung up on crosses and crucified in public. Yeah. That would certainly help with the population problem! But more importantly, it would prevent the government from getting any tax revenues from the sale of tobacco!

Posted on 08/27/2007 at 9:08:00 AM

 
Hitler did indeed make people do things against their will: he made them march into gas chambers and die. He had some help from people who hated Hebrews, and others, who were only too willing to help rid the world of people they felt undesirable. Hence my analogy. A Surgeon General blamed the Tobacco company for his loved ones death, and has led US citizens in a culture of hate against anyone that has the audacity to smoke cigarettes. Some people like to spread love, peace and joy. The Tiffany's of the world like to spread hate. Much like Hitler and others who think only they have the right to exist and make choices.

Posted on 08/21/2007 at 4:08:00 PM

 
If you write for the pure and simple reason of stirring up one's emotions without actually meaning and feeling the things that you write, you must write for money/page views only. I respected you quite a bit more until you tried to say that the things that you wrote were not your opinion and were only portrayed as your opinion. If you actually wrote an article stemming from your own burning passion, that could be respected. The fact that you are saying that you may write an article on how much you love smoking next means that you only do this for the money. At least I write about what I believe, and fight for what I believe is right.

Posted on 08/16/2007 at 8:08:00 PM

 
You are very welcome. I thought that you might need the page views. I am NOT a smoker, actually. I am an ex-smoker who quit due to the fact that smoking has harmed some of my family members, and it was harming me, as well. In my article, I never denied the fact that smoking is TERRIBLE and can kill you. The reason that your article infuriated me was due to the fact that you made so many generalizations about smokers as a whole.

Posted on 08/16/2007 at 8:08:00 PM

 
The reason I write the way I do is to stir up reactions for people like you... This is worth it all. You can not really explain much to people like you either. But regardless, that does not matter to me really. You make my day. You might expect an article about how much I love cigarettes next...

Posted on 08/16/2007 at 7:08:00 PM

 
Do you smoke...?

Posted on 08/16/2007 at 7:08:00 PM

 
Think what you want to think. You are redirecting views to my page. Thanks.

Posted on 08/16/2007 at 7:08:00 PM

 
Again, you are absolutely entitled to your opinion, but do not pretend that the opinion is not yours to make yourself look better now that you are being critiqued. While the purpose of satire is often the shock factor,utilizing more wit in your piece rather than being downright insulting and ignorant-sounding may have been more effective.

Posted on 08/16/2007 at 11:08:00 AM

 
You also said things like, "I might add that I am not the only one who thinks this." The fact that you made this statement is proof that what is written in your article is exactly what YOU believe. You even gave personal examples. "And the way one looks: all leathery, dusty, yellow eyes and fingers, strung out, and most of all stupid are all characteristics of every single smoker I have ever met in my entire life."

Posted on 08/16/2007 at 11:08:00 AM

 
I think that you are only now claiming that you wrote the article as your opinion even though you say it is not your opinion because you are under fire for your beliefs. In the very forefront of your article, you stated that you wrote the piece after "careful exploration" and "careful consideration" and you said, "I have concluded MY OWN SET OF REASONS AND BRING FORTH A LOVELY EXPLANATION IN WHICH DESCRIBES EXACTLY WHERE I STAND ON THIS MAGNIFICENT IDEA."

Posted on 08/16/2007 at 11:08:00 AM

 
Tiffany, you have every right to defend yourself to Carol, and the rest of the world for that matter. I want you to know that I wasn't trying to discredit you as a person or all of your work in general. However, with that said, your piece MAY HAVE been a satirical piece, but you are downright lying when you say that your article is just merely an opinion of some, but not your opinion, even though you wrote it as such.

Posted on 08/16/2007 at 11:08:00 AM

 
And another thing, what I did state in my article would be indeed hurtful to people - if they smoke. However, truth hurts. Life hurts. While some of the things that I did claim, such as smokers being a lower class, may or may not be true for ALL smokers, I am by far not the first person to state such a comment. While I do not neccesarily 'personally' believe that ALL smokers all "lower class", there are quite a few that are still yet.

Posted on 08/16/2007 at 7:08:00 AM

 
By the way, I agree completely with you about pieces like what I wrote need to be publicly critiqued. That would be 'precisely' why I wrote such a thing...

Posted on 08/16/2007 at 7:08:00 AM

 
Carol. Anyone who KNOWS me would know that you are ABSOLUTELY correct. But let the girl who wrote another entire article about me think otherwise. I can't wait for my views to go up just for that... My smoking article is indeed a bit extreme - as is most of my other writings, as you well know by having read some yourself, but my article is merely just an opinion of some - not mine, but indeed an opinion I wrote as mine. But don't let that fool ya if you do know me. Otherwise, it makes no difference...

Posted on 08/16/2007 at 7:08:00 AM

Type in Your Comments Below - (1000 characters left)
Your name:

Submit your own content on this or any topic. Get started »
Showing Comments 1 - 15 of 23
Next >>
Most Commented On