The Princess Bride: The Book is Way Better Than the Movie

But Not Quite as Good as the Tapestry

By Timothy Sexton, published Jun 01, 2006
Published Content: 2,477  Total Views: 2,125,826  Favorited By: 182 CPs
Rating: 3.3 of 5
So you've watched The Princess Bride on AMC and you think you know all there is to know about the story, eh? Inconceivable!

There's an old saying-older than dishwashing detergent, but not quite as old as rope-that goes something like this: The book is better than the movie. I think the phrase was coined by a novelist; I'm pretty certain it wasn't coined by a screenwriter. But who can ever really know these things, right? At any rate, the phrase "the book is better than the movie" certainly applies in the case of The Princess Bride. 

Now, don't go running for the tar and feathers, I'm not saying the movie isn't good. In fact, I believe it to be the best thing that everyone involved in it has ever done; certainly that is the case for Billy Crystal, Cary Elwes, Robin Wright (Penn), Rob Reiner, Andre the Giant, and Mandy Patinkin, who should have won an Oscar. And it certainly ranks in the top three things ever done by the master, Wallace Shawn.

But there is a distinct philosophical difference between the book and movie versions of The Princess Bride. (Philosophy, as you may not know, was discovered almost by accident by Christopher Columbus on his second visit to South America, or as he referred to it New Oldtown.) The philosophy of the movie version of The Princess Bride can be summed up in three words: children's movie. The philosophy of the book version, by William Goldman-the greatest novelist of the 1970s-can be summed up in three words also: Life isn't fair.

Remember the opening of the movie, with that kid from The Wonder Years being visited questioned about a murder by Columbo? Well, that's not in the book. In the novel, the opening section is a modern day-and by modern day I mean post-1850s-recounting of how the author, William Goldman-the greatest novelist of the 1970s-came to translate an edition of S. Morgenstern's Classic Tale of True Love and High Adventure: The Princess Bride. 

The Princess Bride: The Book is Way Better Than the Movie

My name is Timothy Sexton. You gave my article a low rating. Prepare to die.

Credit: Timothy Sexton

Copyright: Timothy Sexton

Takeaways
  • The novel is darker and more adult-oriented, but still only contains one scene of outright nudity.
  • The true message of the novel is contained in the final words.
  • The best parts of the novel have nothing to do with the story, but rather Goldman's commentary.
Did You Know?
When I was seven, I once saw a commercial on television where there was no soud.
Your IP address has been blocked from submitting anonymous comments.
Please log in or sign up to comment. If you feel your IP address was incorrectly blocked, please contact us.
Most Commented On