The Case Against Home Schooling

When Home Schooling is Chosen with the Wrong Motivations

By Jan Castagnaro, published Sep 10, 2007
Published Content: 74  Total Views: 54,945  Favorited By: 12 CPs
Rating: 3.5 of 5
Home schooling, when chosen for the right reasons and implemented in a correct way, can be an effective means of educating children. However, not everyone choosing to home school their children should embark on this route. Let's face it, just like there are some parents that should never have had kids, well, there are some parents that should not home school their children. These types of parents do not have the skills or understanding in order to give their children a full and effective educational experience.

Not every parent is qualified to be an educational teacher, and this is when the choice for home schooling is an often selfish one, and the child's best interest is not first and foremost. There are numerous tools available for parents that choose to home school, but if the parent themselves are void in some or all the curriculum realms, they will be fast tracking their child to a lack of knowledge. Should we not want our children to excel and surpass our own skills and experiences, is that not what we are supposed to strive for, giving our children access to the best education possible? So, if you yourself of void educationally, how can you expect to guide the best education possible for your children?

Some choosing to home school are doing so for religious convictions and want to only expose their children to a religious sensitive curriculum, while some others are paranoid and protective. They fear the big evil world out there will expose their child to common sense reasoning that they want to stifle and protect them from. Its plain paranoia and it can cause a child's development to be delayed on many levels. Again, it all goes back to some parents not being qualified to take on the role of educational teacher. Some parents can be an effective teacher, while some are selfishly choosing to home school when they cannot fulfill the requirements of ensuring that their child will excel academically, and only care that they excel religiously and are sheltered away from all bad in society.

Takeaways
  • Do not home school if you plan to dilute important educational content to fit in with your religion.
  • Home Schooling can be done beneficially with the proper motivation steering the course.
  • Not every parent is qualified to be an academic educator.
Comments
Showing Comments 1 - 5 of 5
 
 
I haven't seen this "Jesus Camp" either. I can't say I agree with or disagree with what's in it. But if you believe something to be the "Truth" and "worth dying for", integrity would demand that you do whatever it takes to teach that "Truth" to your children. I think that the people you are talking about place their children's spirituality above everything else. The key to keeping a balance is to remember that as Christians, we are called to "be in the world but not be OF it". That requires a well rounded education.

Posted on 09/13/2007 at 1:09:00 PM

 
I haven't seen "Jesus Camp", but I have heard awful things about it. The way it sounds, I don't think those parents should be homeschooling, either. I do teach my children Biuble stories and songs, but it is a seperate subject from their other subjects. Howver, that's really no different than what I did when they were in public school, either. I feel that children should be taught their religion, but that they should also be taught core subjects and electives. I would hope that when people do read this article, they read the entire thing and understand you are saying that not everyone is cut out to be a homeschooling family. I didn't take offense and if someone is homeschooling the correct way (providing a solid education) they shouldn't be offended either, I think you did a great job. :-)

Posted on 09/13/2007 at 8:09:00 AM

 
Continued from 1st comment: Thanks for stopping in (Mommy2Lots). I figured by now I'd have some parent condemn me and miss the point that I am not against homeschooling, and realize the benefits it does hold when carried out in a way that promotes factual content and not some diluted version, because then they are no better than some school districts.

Posted on 09/11/2007 at 10:09:00 PM

 
I've never been against Homeschooling myself, as I have supplemental homeschooled my children in the past due to the failures of the school system and district they were in. But, I didn't infuse my religious beliefs in the education, and what motivated my article was watching the movie "Jesus Camp". Some of these parents are homeschooling their children and brainwashing them with misinformation because for some reason they believe it states to do so in the Bible. They are not raising children to question, to reason, and to use common sense---they are doing more harm through homeschooling. I've seen this in my own community and have met homeschooling parents that have no clue what they are doing, while others have the best intentions and are doing it exceptionally. Which is why I know homeschooling when done properly thru "expanding educational possibilities", it can be effective. Thanks for stopping in. I figured by now I'd have some parent condemn me and miss the point that I am not a

Posted on 09/11/2007 at 9:09:00 PM

 
Excellent article. I homeschool my children, but I do it because of the expanded educational possibilities (being able to take extra classes, hands-on learning, etc). I agree that not every person can handle it. It's a difficult task - one that some parents can handle and others cannot. I have yet to see one who does it wrong, but I'm sure there are some out there who will not dedicate the time and effort it takes.

Posted on 09/11/2007 at 4:09:00 PM

Type in Your Comments Below - (1000 characters left)
Your name:

Submit your own content on this or any topic. Get started »
Showing Comments 1 - 5 of 5
 
Most Commented On