Find » Education » More Schools Ban Peanut Butter

More Schools Ban Peanut Butter

By Anna Lane, published Sep 21, 2007
Published Content: 14  Total Views: 5,129  Favorited By: 0 CPs
Embed:  
Rating: 4.1 of 5
Schools across the country are being faced with a decision to ban what some call a deadly substance. But we arent talking about lead paint or asbestos; instead the substance of fear is peanut butter. Campaigns all across the country are calling for schools to ban peanut butter from schools or create safety zones and put safety measures in place.

Its a heated debate between parents and school. Parents are being backed by the Food Allergy Network, who both claim that the Americans With Disabilities Act supports their cause. They say that an allergic child should be considered to have a disability, and thus measures should be put in place to accomodate allergic children. Many pro-ban parents dont understand why schools will willingly install wheelchair ramps or provide testing and education for disabled children, but seem to balk or resist at the idea that allergic children are disabled as well.

How serious is Peanut Butter allergy?
Peanut allergy is actually both more common and more deadly than you might think. Anaphylaxis is the reaction to an allergic substance being introduced into the body. Dr. Peter Vadas explains in an article by the CDC, exactly what happens during a reaction: "The airways clamp down and they fill up with mucous. It becomes very difficult to breathe and they will also experience a fall in blood pressure to the point where perhaps there's not enough oxygen being delivered to the tissues. "They may have problems with heart rhythm and the blood vessels in the heart might constrict and lead to inadequate oxygen delivery to the heart and heart attack."

A reaction to peanuts can kill - very quickly.The Center for Disease Control reports 88 deaths from allergies in the last 20 years (although the majority were peanut related). However the Food Allergy Network contends that allergic reactions are underreported. They claim at least 1% of all Americans are allergic to peanuts, and they estimate almost 130 people die per year from these allergies.

Takeaways
  • Debate over banning peanut butter in schools.
Did You Know?
Some children are so allergic to peanut butter that just the oil or smell can kill a child
Comments
Comments 1 - 15 of 32
Next >>
 
My comment is to Lynne. Please, Please, Please educate yourself before questioning the severity of allergic reactions. As a mother who has had the unfortunate experience of watching and helpinbg my daughter through two life threating reactions, I know first hand how serious reactions can be. I do understand how ignorance exists within the people who do not live in 24/7 fear of their child's airway closing due to accidental ingeation of the wrong food is possible, however, education is key. Reactions happen everyday and they can be life threatening. I can't speak as to why the peanut allergic children ride the bus- prehaps their parents have somehow ensured their safety. Its not your place though, to question the severity of an allergy or risk for potential reaction.

Posted on 10/09/2008 at 9:10:26 PM

 
I have found that all of the "peanut allergic" kids (who prompted the ban at my children's elementary school) ride the school bus to and from school. I suspect that if their allergies were truely serious, the parents would keep their kids off the same busses shared by high schoolers and middle schoolers (who may have peanut products before/during the bus ride). Sorry ~ with that said, I just cannot believe that the allergies are serious enough to ban peanuts in school.

Posted on 09/17/2008 at 10:09:46 AM

 
Sure it's a problem - but total bans are unrealistic and it's upsetting to others. It's like having to be in a wheel chair - and then insiting that everyone else ride in a wheel chair when a proper alternative is to make life easier for the person. Peanut butter bans in schools is improper - what we need is Federal guidance to protect schools and provide guidance that meets in the middle. Sure you could say - big deal it's peanut butter - but what if someone comes in a says I'm allergic to meat - stop serving it; or ham, or eggs etc etc etc. Where does it end?

Posted on 09/14/2008 at 12:09:51 PM

 
I do understand how serious this problem is. It is not a minority any more it is becoming a majority. So, for the who don't understand imagine you walk into your child room and they are choking. Their lips turn blue and you hear this whisling sound. You realize it is your child and they can't breath. You call 911 this time they live. You find out it is all from this sweet little nut. It hard to believe but true. Of course you want to protect them. Protecting them from dieing. Anaphylaxic reaction are real and parents worst night mare. Static are there to support their fears. I think as community we need to step back acknowledge their fears. Try to do our best to support them by providing nut free tables, educating our kids about allergies. Teaching our kids at home about keeping their friends safe. If they are eating something that is not safe move away. This has been a huge topic at my school so I have been doing a lot of research. Yes I have a child with a milk allerg

Posted on 09/07/2008 at 1:09:47 AM

 
No, but I have taught my kids about allergies. I have taught them to wash their hands before and after they eat and their areas. If we decided to ban peanuts are we going to ban milk products too. Then are we going to ban teachers and parents from wearing perfume to school because it could trigger a childs asthma attack. Yes there needs to be a safe environment for all allergy kids. First you need to inform all staff members. Hopefully the schools will talk to the class mates about be a great pal by not sharing fun, washing their hands, and area's. I think informing is very important. We need to be very careful about mandating what other kids eat. First thing you can do for you son or daughter's is empower them over their bodies. Make sure they understand never to take food from anyone else. Provide the foods for your kids that you know are safe. Provide extra snacks for the teachers so when there is parties they have choices. Most reaction happen when they eat something

Posted on 09/07/2008 at 1:09:19 AM

 
People with peanut allergies are generally more sensitive than regular allergies and peanut allergies are more life threatening! My son is has peanut allergies and I dread having him go to school. Luckily my school already has a nut free classroom and is very careful. But still everyday I will worry when the time comes. Sure, it is your right to feed your children whatever you want but good GOD where is your heart- is it worth it to feed your kid peanut butter if it kills another child? This is not an exageration- as the article states sometimes a simple touch from someone who had peanut butter earlier can be enough to kill another person. Do you want to live with that? Do you want your kid to live for the rest of his/her life knowing that they killed their classmate because they ate peanut butter? Also- for those that don't know Chik Fil A (if you have them by you) uses peanut oil. I never knew that but wondered why my son kept having reactions. Great article!

Posted on 01/24/2008 at 11:01:04 AM

 
A portion of my message got cut off, but never mind. For those who don't have a child that has problems with food allergies and therefore do not feel the slightest responsibility to kids who could die because you think your kid should have their peanut butter sandwich, all I can say is, I hope you're never in a situation where you have to rely on the goodwill of other people to keep your kid from dying in a manner that is wholly preventable.

Posted on 01/24/2008 at 11:01:44 AM

 
Anna Lane - Thanks for writing a great, balanced article on this topic. You seem to avoid taking sides, which is a good way to present the information. Unfortunately, based on some comments, I can see that many people aren't capable of understanding the possible consequences of allowing peanut butter into a school where someone with an allergy attends. It's not as simple as leaving the responsibility up to the child. Should my five year old be left to determine, either through questions or inquiries, for herself if something is safe to eat? My daughter is allergic to five different common foods. We are lucky that, as of yet, her reactions are not life threatening. I understand that those five products cannot ALL be banned from her school. That's why we separately provide her snacks, lunches, and "party day" food. She understands that she may not be able to eat someone's birthday treat, but its her teachers who make sure she doesn't. I understand that my daughter's m

Posted on 01/24/2008 at 11:01:53 AM

 
I have a cousin who is allergic to dairy products, and her brother is allergic to nut products. Whatever one of them can eat the other can't. They are both so sensitive to their allergies that they have to keep shots on them in case they do have a reaction.

Posted on 01/24/2008 at 5:01:29 AM

 
When my granddaughter wasn't able to take carrots and peanut butter to school due to her classmates allergy, she was angry. She was 10 at the time. I explained to her that she could always come home and have carrots and peanut butter but that the boy could never have her favorite snack. He could never have PB&J, or PB cookies. Never have Kris Kringles, or peanut butter on toast. She just had to help him out by not having it for a few hours everyday. She was horrified when she understood that the poor boy would never know this simple pleasure. And that if the allergy was severe enough, he could get very sick or even die. It was a great opportunity to teach empathy.

Posted on 01/24/2008 at 3:01:59 AM

 
"Discrimination" is a term used specifically for protected classes. When people state their child is being discriminated against for eating peanut butter it does not make sense. Peanut butter eaters are not a protected class. People with a severe food allergy are a protected class this is a legal medical disability. It confounds me the narrow selfishness of people who insist peanut butter is their god given right. Living is a god given right...why should someone's right to PB&J be allowed to injure another...Parents, Mothers, we should be dilligent in protecting everyone's children...

Posted on 12/03/2007 at 5:12:00 PM

 
I am angry that my daughter, who only eats pb&j is discriminated against and that a minority of the peanut/peanut butter allergy group is treated as if this is a disability. For God's sake, what about all the kids who have allergies to milk products or mold or dust. Let's ban everything and put all our kids in plastic globes. Perhaps the entire peanut industry should be banned from the planet. This is an overeaction to a minority. Most kids eat pb&j with no problem. The kids with the problem is sad, but should be segregated, not the majority. I totally understand the potential problem but punishing everyone else is totally unecessary. Peanuts and peanut related foods are a good source of protein. Please let's be realistic!

Posted on 11/12/2007 at 8:11:00 AM

 
I agree that peanut allergies are a deadly problem. My daughter's friend has one and it completely regulates what she does and where she goes. She has a very severe allergy but she is also very well educated about it. These children are going to grow up into adults and we cannot ban all allergic substances from the face of the earth. What about people with allergies to eggs, latex, etc.? They have to be careful and learn to live with it. My husband is allergic to any raw fruit-it makes his throat swell up and he cannot breathe. Yet we can't ban others from eating it or including it in foods. We have to take responsibility for ourselves, although it is important to educate everyone about allergic reactions, especially ones involving common foods.

Posted on 11/06/2007 at 10:11:00 AM

 
I'm very concerned about what is being said about peanut butter. The reason is that, I live in a small town named Sonora, TX and in our school when kids are sent to ISS or DAEP the children do not get the lunch as everyone else. They don't even get a balanced meal for that matter. All they are fed is 1 peanut butter sandwish at lunch with 1 milk. If they want another they must pay an aditional $2.00. Thats even on free lunches. I wish I knew where to report this. Is it even legal? Any info. please contact me at diana_l.t@hotmail.com

Posted on 11/04/2007 at 9:11:00 PM

 
Hi,my 8 year old daughter has nearly died from her peanut allergy.She will react severely to even the tiniest amount of PB or other peanut products,whether eating,touching or smelling it.Her school has happily requested that peanut products not be brought to school,not just for her sake but for the other 6 kids at her school who are anaphylaxic to peanuts.Most of the children are very understanding and few bring peanut products any more,if they do they sit in a seperate area and wash thoroughly after eating. A ban is not ever going to totally end the risks of accidental reactions,but it certainly helps reduce the chances.Think for just a moment about your child being scared to go to school incase they die from someone wiping PB on them,or touching a book or other object that has been contaminated with PB.Until you live with it you don't have a clue.Everytime I watch her go through the school gate,I wonder if I will see her safely home that afternoon or if the next time I see her will b

Posted on 11/04/2007 at 9:11:00 AM

Type in Your Comments Below - (1000 characters left)
Your name:

Submit your own content on this or any topic. Get started »
Comments 1 - 15 of 32
Next >>
Advertisment