Creative Criticism

(Mean What You Say, but Say it in a Way that Really Means Something)

By Gary Picariello, published Sep 13, 2007
Published Content: 692  Total Views: 1,086,306  Favorited By: 97 CPs
Rating: 4.8 of 5
I've always felt that the term "constructive criticism" ranks right up there with "almost pregnant" or referring to a blind date as "a great conversationalist." When it comes to criticism you're either being criticized or your not. How "constructive" that criticism is, is purely objective. If you're on the receiving end you can either learn from it or ignore it.

All of which doesn't make criticism any easier. I've been on both sides of the table -- the one giving the critique and the one receiving the criticism - and believe me, putting fancy names on criticism doesn't make said critique any more palatable.

Some of the most successful managers today all seem to agree on one thing when it comes to dealing with that employee or colleague: there are specific ways to criticize. Methods that can help you deliver your message more effectively, and lessen the negative impact. Because if you think about it, when you criticize someone's actions, your intention (hopefully) is for him or her to improve at something, not feel so demoralized that they give up completely and crawl under their desk or head for the nearest window.

So, just how do you point out the bad while keeping he overall atmosphere positive? It's not as difficult as it may seem "creative criticism" draws heavily on plain 'ol common sense and some fundamental building blocks about dealing with people.

1.Point out that everyone makes mistakes - even you. According to an article in Mercola.com, saying things like, "I've made the same mistake myself," keeps you from sounding superior, and lets the individual sitting across from you know you understand how the mistake happened.

Takeaways
  • Criticism CAN be constructive.
  • Criticism should never be given in a sarcastic fashion.
  • There is such a thing as good and bad criticism.
Did You Know?
it's also a good idea to wrap up your critique with a positive statement of some kind as well.
Comments
Showing Comments 1 - 8 of 8
 
 
I really liked the article,it had a lot of good suggestion. I particularly liked the fact not to sweat the small stuff. When you give criticism it also helps to give 2 positives, the critique, and one more positive. I enjoy your writing style. (So did you catch the two positives, negative, positive...Ha!)

Posted on 12/16/2007 at 2:12:15 PM

 
Great advice in giving and receiving criticism. Thanks for sharing.

Posted on 11/08/2007 at 11:11:00 AM

 
Great advice and very well put.

Posted on 10/23/2007 at 3:10:00 PM

 
Great advice, Gary! I deal with this issue all of the time as I teach English. Whether it's correction of the spoken work or edit of the written it must be done tactfully so the recipient does not get insulted or feel less intelligent in some way.

Posted on 09/15/2007 at 8:09:00 PM

 
Good suggestions, and well written (as always). I like the idea that you closed on a positive note (ha!) You're exactly right though, there has to be some things an individual does well. And if you let them know you have noticed THOSE, it may help swallow the bitter pill of criticism. I had one AF boss I remember. All I can ever think about is the day he told me to wear more make-up and to wear a skirt. YECH. I've always hated both. :) Thanks again Gary, great article! Kim

Posted on 09/13/2007 at 6:09:00 PM

 
With something negative, there should always be a positive with the positive being first. Great article and I love the "almost pregnant" line. Great article

Posted on 09/13/2007 at 3:09:00 PM

 
In almost any situation there is some good that can be mentioned with the critique part being a suggestion for how things could have worked better.

Posted on 09/13/2007 at 1:09:00 PM

 
I do agree these are helpful techniques, but a significant proportion of people don't receive critisism too well - no matter what flavor it comes in. :-)

Posted on 09/13/2007 at 1:09:00 PM

Type in Your Comments Below - (1000 characters left)
Your name:

Submit your own content on this or any topic. Get started »
Showing Comments 1 - 8 of 8
 
Most Commented On