Should Senior Drivers Be Treated Differently?

This is a sensitive subject for a lot of seniors. They give up so much of their freedoms over time, that the thought of giving up their right to drive can be a big hurdle. Let's face it, as we age, we change. We may not see as well as we used to, and we may not hear as well either. Many
 of us as we age have slower reaction times-mainly due to our inability to assess situations and react to them quickly enough. In order to have adequate responsiveness, we must have full range of motion in our muscles, and we must be able to interpret what we see and hear and make split second decisions, to prevent driving mishaps or accidents.

I am not what I consider old yet (57), but I know that I cannot see well enough at night to drive, so I stay off the road. As we age, we generally don't process light as well as we used to, causing limited vision at night. My biggest problem with night driving is that I am blinded by the oncoming headlights that causes glare that overtakes my vision of the road. For the safety of others, and myself I voluntarily stay off the road at night.
Should seniors be tested to keep their license?

I don't believe arbitrarily testing seniors is the answer to safe driving, because some people at 60 are unsafe, while others at 80 can still safely drive. It would be discriminatory to make every elderly person retest to prove he/she still has adequate driving skills; however, if a senior demonstrates unsafe practices, such as changing lanes abruptly, or causing some near misses with other vehicles or property, I believe they should be evaluated. Again, I will use my dad for reference; after getting a call from the police department that my dad had knocked over two mailboxes on the side of the road, I asked my dad to surrender his license to the Department of Motor Vehicles. He was fortunate the people who owned the mailboxes didn't press charges against him.

What are the signs of decreased driving ability?

 
Comments 1 - 6 of 6  
Comments
Type in Your Comments Below

I don't think it's a matter of whether or not everyone should be tested but those who are proving to have trouble as time goes on. Anyone who is older and having trouble should take a step back and evaluate what they should do.

Posted on 02/12/2008 at 9:02:15 AM

I don't think it's a matter of whether or not everyone should be tested but those who are proving to have trouble as time goes on. Anyone who is older and having trouble should take a step back and evaluate what they should do.

Posted on 02/12/2008 at 9:02:14 AM

My father has given up his license when he noticed how he got too near the curbs. Mom still drives and keeps to just in town now. They are both in their 80's. Lots of people do not use the turn signal so not sure that is such a good sign for older folks. I have always had difficulty with depth perception and perhaps in time I will give it up if it gets too difficult to adjust to. Good article about how we must tend to each other and hope it does not come down to mandatory testing.

Posted on 01/13/2008 at 3:01:24 PM

You're right -- sensitive subject. I don't know the answer. Good article.

Posted on 10/18/2007 at 2:10:00 PM

While some seniors give up their driving privileges voluntarily because they know they are unsafe, many more refuse to give up this bit of independence and put others at risk. It's a touchy subject, suggesting a parent shouldn't drive anymore! My dad is 74 and his driving skills are still good, but when the time comes I would have to insist he give up driving. It's the best thing a child could do to protect an elderly parent, and although it is bound to cause hard feelings, it could save a life.

Posted on 10/16/2007 at 7:10:00 AM

there has just been two deaths on different occasions here in montreal caused by senior drivers in their 80's I think it is a matter of public safety and they should be tested more often than younger drivers.

Posted on 10/15/2007 at 9:10:00 PM

Comments 1 - 6 of 6