My Brown Eyed Baby and the Milkman Syndrome

A Rebuttal to the AC Article, "Why Two Blue Eyed People Can't Produce a Brown Eyed Child," by Michelle Williams

By Tammy G, published Oct 18, 2007
Published Content: 119  Total Views: 485,477  Favorited By: 28 CPs
Rating: 4.2 of 5
Prior to writing this article I came across an Associated Content article entitled, "Why Two Blue Eyed People Can't Produce a Brown Eyed Child," by Michelle Williams. Her article was one of the most inaccurate pieces of fallacy I have seen published in any medium in a very long time. She was blindly following obsolete curriculum accrued way back in her high school biology class and is still taking it as the word of God despite well-publicized breakthroughs in DNA coding. The Davenport eye color model, which dates back to 1907, partially attributes to her ignorance as well as all of the skeptical mothers-in-law out there.

Her inability to accept criticism by fellow readers all but forced me to write about my own findings and experience with this subject.

Picture this if you will. One night my otherwise amazing Mother-in-law treated all of us to dinner at a very nice restaurant. A couple of times over the past five years she's mentioned how my youngest daughter doesn't really look like my husband. She thought that particular dining experience was another fine time to make a wisecrack about it.

We never thought much of her observations and were always amused when she brought it up. In fact I believe I was the one who originally noticed how my daughter's complexion was a little off.

My husband, oldest daughter and I are all pale-skinned red-heads with tons of freckles, yet my youngest daughter has the same red hair but no freckles and has a darker complexion. She even tans, something I'm a little jealous about. Utterly shocked that our genes could produce a bronzed beauty, I've called her my Mexican milkman baby to both my husband and his mom in a joking way.

My Brown Eyed Baby and the Milkman Syndrome
My Brown Eyed Baby and the Milkman Syndrome

See it for yourself. My Older daughter has blue eyes and my younger one has brown eyes.

Credit: Lynne G.

Copyright: Lynne G.

Did You Know?
Around the time of the Davenport model, a French geneticist believed eyes could change colors the same way the ocean can appear blue, green or gray depending on how sunlight was hitting the atmosphere. He said all eye color was an illusion.
Comments
Showing Comments 1 - 9 of 9
 
 
Please disregard that last comment. I went and did little research and answered my own question.

Posted on 12/21/2007 at 10:12:05 PM

 
Okay, this might sound stupid, but I'm a little confused. If you have a brown allele what keeps you from having brown eyes, if brown is dominant over blue? Both of the sources you cite seem to say that all the alleles must be blue for you to have blue eyes. Also, you said that blue-eyed people could pass on the strong form of the oca2 gene, when you just said having the strong form meant you would have brown eyes. Are these genes switched off or something?

Posted on 12/21/2007 at 9:12:11 PM

 
I love this article. I'm the brown eyed child of two blue eyed parents. You would not believe the fun my older siblings had with that. Though I think it may have helped my education as they had to teach the theory to me before they could harass me with it. However, with age my eyes have faded from almost black at birth to a grayish hazel at pushing the outside of the thirty-something envelope.

Posted on 12/19/2007 at 1:12:13 PM

 
Sweet! Glad I could help! :D (It sounds scandalous already haha)

Posted on 12/13/2007 at 2:12:10 AM

 
You just gave me an idea for a subplot in a novel I'm working on. Thank you!

Posted on 12/13/2007 at 1:12:38 AM

 
I accidently ran accross this article..Finding it very interesting. Your daughters are beautiful! My aunt and uncle both have light blue eyes, much like your color of blue and they had 6 kids. One of their kids has very dark brown eyes. Funny thing is, she looks the most like her Dad! Great Article!

Posted on 11/17/2007 at 5:11:00 AM

 
Thanks a lot RJT! They were beyond thrilled to be "stars" in one of my articles. :D I had fun writing it too!

Posted on 11/11/2007 at 11:11:00 PM

 
Your daughter is beyond adorable and I loved this article, very interesting.

Posted on 11/11/2007 at 5:11:00 PM

 
That's Cal State San Marcos, not Cal State San Mateo. I lived in San Mateo at one point. That's what I get for moving around so much!

Posted on 10/18/2007 at 10:10:00 AM

Type in Your Comments Below - (1000 characters left)
Your name:

Submit your own content on this or any topic. Get started »
Showing Comments 1 - 9 of 9
 
Most Commented On