To Breastfeed, or Not to Breastfeed? That is the Question

Stay Out of My "Boob" Space!

By Anne DeBerham, published Oct 24, 2007
Published Content: 10  Total Views: 1,069  Favorited By: 1 CPs
Rating: 2.6 of 5
So, I belong to an on line "mom's" forum. There are many groups for mothers of all ages, nationalities, religions, experiences as well as hobbies and so on.

The best, and cattiest, are the Breast Feeding Moms (known from here out as BFN's) and the Formula Feeding Moms (known from here out as FFM's). Never have I seen so many supposed "adults" go at each other with such vigor! It amazes me every time I read a new bulletin.

We, as women, all know the benefits of breast feeding our infants. It's the way children have been fed from the beginning of time, right up until the first commercially available formulas hit the market in 1912. If a woman couldn't breast feed, she would hire a wet nurse. If a wet nurse wasn't available, regular table food, pulverized and mixed with cow or goat milk, was supplemented.

Modern day formulas are far more superior to those introduced in the early 1900's (Dextri-Maltose). As much nutrition as possible is packed into them so our children can get the vitamins they need when breast feeding is not an option. In this day and age, with two incomes being needed to support a home, there are a lot of mothers who just don't have enough time in the day to feed their children breast milk as often as needed. Some women will pump the breast milk so it's available while they're working. Some women try to get as much breast milk into their children as possible and use formula as a supplement. Some women try their best to breast feed their babies and, for whatever reason, they're unsuccessful and rely fully on formula to make sure their children eat and are healthy.

As a woman, I know my first and foremost goal is to make sure my child is getting the proper nutrition and is not hungry. However I can make that possible is the route I will take. But say that to a BFN and you're liable to get an earful about how you lack proper parenting skills and have no business bringing children into this world.

Comments
Showing Comments 1 - 6 of 6
 
 
Frogdoc, already got an article in the making, just had to site my sources and waiting approval. ;)

Posted on 10/30/2007 at 8:10:00 AM

 
I've seen some of these arguments on my mom's boards as well, and it's even caused some women to leave the group. Wanna stir up something REALLY contentious? Start talking about whether or not to vaccinate your kids.

Posted on 10/29/2007 at 1:10:00 PM

 
Ok, just for clarification, there is a huge difference between a breastfeeding advocate and a BFN (sorry Jenny, I cannot for the life of me think of another moniker so that's the last time I'll use that term!). One informs and tries to lead, but realizes that breast feeding is not something EVERY woman can (or should) do, whereas the other will only make a woman who can't (or chooses NOT to) breast feed feel like they're not worthy of their children. My point was that it is very easy to judge others when comparing to yourself, but not everyone is YOU. Thank you both for your opinions!

Posted on 10/29/2007 at 9:10:00 AM

 
You are being as judgemental as unfair by referring to Breastfeeding mothers as "BFNs" and "Breast Feeding Nazis" while calling formula-feeding mothers simply "FFMs" or "Formula-Feeding Mothers." Not all breastfeeding mothers so rude, and there are plenty of judgemental, rude formula-feeding mothers. I think this article just perpetuates the disrespect and lack of understanding each side has for the other.

Posted on 10/27/2007 at 7:10:00 PM

 
(oops cut off) Comparing what they endured, the slaughter of hundreds of thousands of innocent men, women, and children and further the abuse and starvation that was afflicted upon them to a mother who harshly pushes breastfeeding (what she believes to be nurturing and nutritious) is a slap in the face. I think a better term might be "militant" breastfeeders. Just food for though (nyuk, nyuk, nyuk). Again, my sincerest apologies that you have been harrassed by others.

Posted on 10/25/2007 at 5:10:00 AM

 
I am very sorry you received so much grief from others. I consider myself a breastfeeding advocate (not at all a like the women you described though), but I pride myself that I have never degraded anyone for whatever choice they make. Above all, you should be proud of the four months you DID breastfeed. You gave a great gift during that time. I understand your sorrow and pain of feeling like a failure. I do hope the best for you bfing your next cherb and kudos to you for choosing to bf again despite your previous problems. (Also, shameless plug for me,) For those who are reading and want more info on what can bring an early end to bfing, I did write a piece on that topic recently. :) Not at all saying that any of those was your issue though. I also have to say how much I HATE the BFN term. I realize you didn't event the term and it is quite popular on message boards- so not blaming you for that either. :) I think it is very degrading to those of the Jewish faith. Comparing

Posted on 10/25/2007 at 5:10:00 AM

Type in Your Comments Below - (1000 characters left)
Your name:

Submit your own content on this or any topic. Get started »
Showing Comments 1 - 6 of 6
 
Most Commented On