Find » Opinion/Editorial » The Last Cylon: Who is the Fifth of...

The Last Cylon: Who is the Fifth of the Final Five in "Battlestar Galactica"

By Joe Beaudoin, published Oct 29, 2007
Published Content: 7  Total Views: 120,168  Favorited By: 0 CPs
Embed:  
Rating: 3.8 of 5
After the revelation of four of the "Final Five" in Battlestar Galactica's third season finale, two major questions were asked: "Who is the Fifth?" and "Are they actually Cylons!?"

After re-imagined series developer Ronald D. Moore assured fans in interviews that Chief Galen Tyrol (Aaron Douglas), Colonel Saul Tigh (Michael Hogan), Samuel Anders (Michael Trucco) and Tory Foster (Rekha Sharma) were members of the Final Five, the next logical set of question sprang to being.

Just who is the last Cylon? Have we already seen them?

To lay down the ground work for the article, there are several pieces of information that need to be made available to you. These key pieces of information are based on comments from both Ron Moore and several key actors on the series. However, it would be remiss of me to not mention that these comments could also be slightly deceiving -- particularly in light of the elaborate deception concocted by Moore, his partner-in-crime David Eick, and actress Katee Sackhoff to trump up Kara Thrace's death in "Maelstrom" as her final appearance in the series.

Having offered that disclaimer, I'll now state what has been revealed so far. In addition to being "fundamentally different" than the "Significant Seven" introduced previously, they have been Cylons from the beginning. Therefore, they are not clones, replacements, or any other doppelgänger cliché that has been seen before in science fiction.

In addition, Moore claims in the Frak Party podcast for "Crossroads, Part II" that he already knows who the last Cylon is, and that he's left clues for who it may be. An additional comment from Bradley Thompson also reveals that the they have known who the "Final Cylon" is since the end of season one, therefore the character cannot truly be anyone who hasn't been around since season one. (For the record, Thompson also noted that the rest of the Five were decided upon in the third season, a claim further supported by Moore.)

Comments
Comments 1 - 15 of 93
Next >>
 
Why didnt Beaudoin consider Dr. Cottle?

Posted on 10/07/2008 at 2:10:37 PM

 
Clues then, my proposal for the final cylon. Clues: --Cylon #3 says in S04E10 "four, there are four in your fleet." Flee according to Websters could mean either exclusively military personal and ships or inclusive of the civilian ships and well, civilians. I'm taking fleet to mean military personal and craft only because this greatly increases the number of candidates to include only those aboard the cylon baseship and within the civilian ships at the time. --Moore has said the final cylon must have had significant impacts on the plot. This limits the number of candidates down drastically. --Moore as also stated the final cyclon is NOT pictured in the famous (or infamous : ) last supper parody picture. This completely negates all suspicious from Lee Adama, Starbuck, Admiral Adama, Dr. Balter and President Roslin. --Moore has also stated the final cyclone has been around since season 1, this eliminates our lawyer friend. Also, he's too good of a human to be a cylon, well so we

Posted on 09/24/2008 at 10:09:20 PM

 
I would think that the final cylon was Starbuck's Viper.

Posted on 08/27/2008 at 9:08:53 PM

 
i think the fifth cylon is spot. you know mr.bills dog...he is the only one who has happend befor and will happen again. 12 colonies---12 cylons--- 12 survivors from a end to earth mutated bionics ---12x12x12etc.it happened befor,it will happen again. fuceye at snoutcall dot com

Posted on 08/26/2008 at 10:08:44 PM

 
i think it is mr gaeta as all the other cylons fit in to a loose representation of the gods of olympus, samuel anders could be ares, cavil could be hades and leoben could be hermes and caprica aphroditie and athena athena chief tyrol as vulcan. Mr gaeta has a good voice and a bacchus look while he isnt merry and wine drinking he still may mold into the roll.

Posted on 08/25/2008 at 9:08:43 AM

 
The 5th has to be someone that, when revealed, you stand up and go "What the FRAK!!!" That means it has to be a big character. My money's on Roslin or Admiral Adama. While it would funny as hell to see Adama and Roslin deal with the fact that he's a cylon, I'm leaning towards Roslin. It's got to be someone D'Anna interacted with and screwed over some how to cause her to say what she did she saw the 5th. Roslin also shares dreams with two other cylons. In addition, when the fleet entered the nebula and the 4 discovered who they were, Roslin nearly passed out. Hasn't anyone else wonderred why she was the ONLY one to react that way and WHY did she react that way? Let us not forget what D'Anna said on the baseship, "There are 4 in your fleet...I want the 4." That means the 5th wasn't with the fleet. Hello...she was looking straight at Roslin so Roslin wasn't with the fleet.

Posted on 08/11/2008 at 12:08:44 AM

 
Anyone think Dr Cottle is a candidate?

Posted on 07/30/2008 at 1:07:32 PM

 
redback in regard to Deanna apologizing to the cylon she finds out in the temple, I believe she is referring to Sol because how he was tortured on New Caprica. That is what I always figured.

Posted on 07/22/2008 at 9:07:54 AM

 
I have a funny feeling it's Admiral Adama. I think at Episode 1, he was secretly replaced by a superior model Cyclon at Ragnar Anchorage. I suspect that the one who came out from the munitions depot with Leoben Conoy was a replacement and that the real Adama may have already died from a fight while trapped inside the chamber. But then again, if it isn't the father, then it must be the son. Isn't Adam the father of all humanity? And isn't it the premise of BSG that humans descended from another planet? It's very obvious that BSG has been reconstructing on centuries-old human myths. I think Starbuck's "important" role is to be the mother of reborn humanity. Doesn't she have feelings for Lee? And btw, why are we taking the Cyclons' word that there are only twelve models? These are Cyclons we're talking about. If they can falsely pose as humans and deceive everyone else, who's to say that they're not capable of spreading lies (or a half-truths) as well?

Posted on 07/12/2008 at 9:07:03 PM

 
At first I thought the fifth cylon was Kilo because he saved the cylons from the common cold and cried about humanity and considered Zarek because he has his gripe with the humans , but there was a character that was captured by the cyclons that escaped. He was on a covert mission and somehow return to the Galactica. He would then be the one that Deana would be apologizing to because he had been tortured. Dan "Bulldog" Novacek.. Any thoughts?

Posted on 07/09/2008 at 4:07:48 PM

 
Ok, I have a nice suspect, Lee's brother Zak. We have known about him since season one AND it would completely frak with the minds of the admiral, Lee and starbuck. Say he didn't die at the academy but actually left and is currently with the renegades we met in Razor. HUGE SPOILER COMING UP SO LOOK AWAY IF YOU HAVN'T SEEN EPISODE 10 OF SEASON 4. They could also be the ones who destroyed Earth. The only problem with the Zak argument is that D'anna looked into the face of the fifth and said, 'oh it's you, forgive me'. Which more or less implies she has seen the person before. But the idea of Galactica being the fifth I just don't see. Can't really imagine a flash back of D'anna's vision in the temple with a figure standing before her pulling back their hood to reveal a human-sized galactica. The biggest problem is that four of them were on Galactica. And she only knows who is onboard from the last time she was on there. So subsequent deaths (such as Calle) would be out of the qu

Posted on 06/29/2008 at 8:06:31 PM

 
The final cylon is Bill Adama's wife, making Lee half cylon half human. Also, I believe Kara's father is Tigh, making her half and half as well. I do not believe Kara has ever met her dad.

Posted on 06/27/2008 at 9:06:41 PM

 
I think mech6772 is right. I think the last cylon is Galactica herself. Think about the emphasis placed in earlier episodes on how the raiders were alive. The music comes from the ship. The awakening described by the hybrid represents Galactica's awakening in the sense of gaining consciousness. The apology by D'Anna is for attacking Galactica. Etc. There would certainly be precedent in other sci fi, particularly anime. As an aside, the "best" candidate -- Lee -- makes no sense. D'Anna says only four cylons are "with the fleet." And the claim that "Adama is a cylon" is clearly baseless, because Leonnin does not have any knowledge about the final five. (Consider the context of his remark: we hardly knew any cylons then -- it was a plausible ploy then.)

Posted on 06/27/2008 at 2:06:52 PM

 
It is starting to be clear now that we have seen the arrival on Earth. The Razor hybrid predicted it all. - He predicted the awakening of the four - "Soon there will be four, glorious in awakening, struggling with the knowledge of their true selves. The pain of revelation bringing new clarity." - He predicted Leoban finding Kara during the Demetrius mission and the joining of the humans and cylons - "And in the midst of confusion, he will find her. Enemies brought together by impossible longing. Enemies now joined as one. The way forward at once unthinkable, yet inevitable." - I think he also gave a clue to the identity of the fifth cylon that didn't make sense until now - "And the fifth, still in shadow, will claw toward the light, hungering for redemption that will only come in the howl of terrible suffering." I think we can see this will be the one who remains from the devastation that preceded the fleet's arrival on Earth. The questions is, how do we know them?

Posted on 06/27/2008 at 12:06:38 PM

 
Just a point to note, Helo is not necessarily out of the loop as a cylon. Where was it ever established that two cylons can't successfully breed if the 6 is pregnant with Tigh's child. Just a note.

Posted on 06/25/2008 at 12:06:40 AM

Type in Your Comments Below - (1000 characters left)
Your name:

Submit your own content on this or any topic. Get started »
Comments 1 - 15 of 93
Next >>
Advertisment