The Immigration Debate

I am going to start off by saying my position on this issue, although I will try to address the problems of both sides of the argument. I am and have been always very pro-immigration, as many of you know I am a strict free market capitalist, and I believe it would be contradictory to
 endorse the free market when I exclude a large source of competition due to government not allowing that particular commodity into the market, in this case, that commodity is labor.

We all the know the rhetoric republican talk show hosts say from dawn til dusk, they say we are rewarding illegal activity and endorsing a crime. We hear the democrats saying they are all taking jobs that typical americans don't want anyways, and with those two arguments being thrown at each other over the radio and on TV nothing gets solved and we are left with a system at teh end of the day that just plain doesn't work.

We cannot hide from this issue any longer, blocking reform of the immigration issue is only allowing more and more unknown, unaccountable, and untaxed people across our borders. And they are going to keep coming across because there is a large incentive to do, the people in DC call it job magnet, they say we need to get rid of the job magnet issues to stop them from coming over. Well how exactly do you do that? One solution is that we could become a third world country so there is no incentive to come over illegally.. But thats not going to happen, and there is no way to get rid of this Job Magnet.

Immigration has always been healthy to america since the first ships landed on our shores. During the industrial revolution it helped shape us into what we are today. America has always had immigration and it has forced americans to be hard workers out of competition. We HAD to compete with the germans, the irish, the hispanics, the asians, we were forced to do our jobs efficiently in order to keep them. It has helped our country be one of the most advanced countries in the world.

 
Comments 1 - 2 of 2  
Comments
Type in Your Comments Below

Winz, define "infrastructure." One of the great things you should know about free markets is that they fluctuate and accomodate. It is not static. Therefore, I see no problem with an increase in immigrant labor. The market will adjust like it always does when left alone.

Posted on 12/12/2008 at 9:12:37 AM

Sounds easy, but the free market, open border solution does not take into account that it not just the competition in jobs, that is a part of it, but probably not even the biggest issue with illegal immigration. There is still that our infrastructure just cannot support the free flow of workers that the free market is demanding, that cultures are colliding, and its just all getting way out of hand. Economics is important, but there is alot more to a happy life then just that.

Posted on 11/13/2007 at 12:11:00 PM

Comments 1 - 2 of 2