Find » Arts & Entertainment » Movies » The Golden Compass Review - It's Si...

The Golden Compass Review - It's Siver

In Which Direction Does This Movie Go?

By LaRae Meadows, published Dec 07, 2007
Published Content: 130  Total Views: 22,435  Favorited By: 9 CPs
Embed:  
Rating: 2.0 of 5
Set in an alternate universe where souls live outside the body as demons, The Golden Compass is no children's movie. Graphic violence, beautiful special effects and dark, rich plot lines are far too dark for a child.

Lyra Belacqua (Dakota Blue Richards) is sent off by her uncle to a boarding school. While she is there she runs amuck, lying and creating general mischief with her friend Roger (Ben Walker), until he is kidnapped. Her uncle, Lord Asriel (Daniel Craig) raises eyebrows when he bucks the Magisterium, the religious authority in their world, and sets off to study a forbidden substance, Dust. So enraged by the fact that he would commit serious acts of heresy, the Magisterium sends Marisa Coulter (Nicole Kidman) to collect Lyra and keep an eye on her while they hunt her uncle. What the Magisterium doesn't know is Lyra has the last Alethiometer, a truth telling device. Lyra meets an ice bear named Iorek Byrnison (Ian McKellen) and an aeronaut Lee Scoresby (Sam Elliott).

A myriad of "A" list celebrities speckle the cast. Rich and powerful voices like Ian McKellen give characters like a giant ice bear breath and humanity. Nicole Kidman gives her character brooding intensity. Sam Elliot brings his typical rough and tumble attitude to his character. Daniel Craig, whose role is fairly minimal, is tough but intelligent. Even new comer Ben Walker is downright adorable.

The only actor whose performance doesn't add to the believability and sparkle is Dakota Blue Richards. I realize her character is supposed to be extremely, well, extreme but the acting doesn't have to so obvious. She is a child, a cute one granted, but when you cast the main character, they have to be strong, even if it is a child's role. Richards does not make me want to slice my eyes open with a butter knife but her acting couldn't be considered a hot knife through butter either.

The Golden Compass Review - It's Siver
The Golden Compass Review - It's Siver

The Golden Compass

Credit: The Golden Compass

Copyright: The Golden Compass

Takeaways
  • Graphic violence, beautiful special effects and dark, rich plot lines are far too dark for a child.
  • Watch for him to disappoint you.
  • Reminiscent of old fashioned adventure movie storytelling, The Golden Compass is
Comments
Comments 1 - 10 of 10
 
 
I read the books and saw the movie. I thought both were great. (Sounds like you guys got some sort of flame war going, so I'll say 'Good Bye.)

Posted on 12/19/2007 at 10:12:12 PM

 
Your real problem is that you loved the movie; I did not. So instead of attacking the substance of my arguments or complaints, you pick at trivial things like "daemon" and choice of words. I think it would show a great deal of wisdom to never come here and say I didn't see a movie or attempt impugne my credibility. I won't review movies I haven't seen and I have the readership to back up my review quality.

Posted on 12/13/2007 at 11:12:21 PM

 
Steven, Why would I even think to look it up? Do you look up the word elephant or do you think when you hear elephant e-l-e-p-h-a-n-t? I think not. I thought they were saying demon and there is on reason why I would've thought otherwise. Please, please, explain how I would've know differently? It isn't a character name, it is a classification, which I didn't know existed. So, I don't feel badly. And you are all full of rude comments in that comment. My comment about your hard on had nothing to do with the fact you have a penis, it is an expression. Sorry you took it the wrong way. I don't mind you filling me in, in fact, if I get something wrong, I like it when people tell me, respectfully. I think it is beyond silly to think that a reviewers credibility rests on getting something as trivial as daemon and demon right and that everyone should know it's daemon, not demon. Surely everyone has read the book? As I stated before, I don't tell everything in the movie and the "pro

Posted on 12/13/2007 at 11:12:57 PM

 
And the only comment I originally made that can be considered rude is doubting that you actually saw the film. Your reference to male genitalia was especially uncalled for.

Posted on 12/10/2007 at 3:12:49 PM

 
It is the responsibility of every reviewer to check facts, especially the spelling of character names. Anything less takes away from the credibility of the review and the reviwer; resources are available online or from the publicity office of the studio. And for the record, Lord Asriel is the master of Jordan College, which is decidely not a boarding school in the strict British sense of the term. Lyra lives there primarily because of a prophecy made about her and the Golden Compass and for other reasons that should not be revealed here.

Posted on 12/10/2007 at 3:12:22 PM

 
Whoops, Steven, I didn't mean to delete your last comment about me being nice. Feel free to repost.--- I don't think you have much room to speak about my nice words when you leave rude comments. I didn't read the book and I didn't know there was another way to spell daemon. There is no reason for me to look it up because i didn't know there was another way to spell it. I just didn't know. I don't feel badly and don't have anything to feel badly about. It would have been kind of you to say something like "Did you know it's actually Daemon." not try to insult or shame me. In hundreds of reviews I've written, I have always done my best to give accurate information to my readers with out giving anything away. (Read my bug review). That's why I have so many readers and such large syndication. So, again, I apologize for any inconvenience to you or your spelling sensibilities but I didn't do anything harmful to the movie, the actors or the opinion I set forth. I look forward t

Posted on 12/10/2007 at 2:12:19 PM

 
wheres the pitchres of pam

Posted on 12/10/2007 at 9:12:13 AM

 
To my readers: I apologize for the misspelling of daemon as demon. Thank you for continuing to read my reviews.

Posted on 12/08/2007 at 1:12:40 PM

 
Steven, Thank you for helping me out with spelling. That is a challenge for me. That being said the demon/daemon thing is more a spellign error than an error of fact. When I screened the movie they didn't spell daemon for me. Additionally, a boarding school is a school where someone lives and I choose not to give all the details to my readers so they can experience things for the first time when they see the movie. Again this is not an error of fact, just a different way of explaining. I read your review and you had exactly the opposite feeling as I did. I think your problem rests with the fact I didn't have the same hard on for this movie you did.

Posted on 12/08/2007 at 1:12:19 PM

 
LaRae: Did we see the same movie? I screened this one twice and many of the facts you have in your review are incorrect. The correct spelling of the animal spirits is "daemon", not demon. Lyra is at Jordan College, not a boarding school. Did you actually see the film?

Posted on 12/08/2007 at 7:12:00 AM

Type in Your Comments Below - (1000 characters left)
Your name:

Submit your own content on this or any topic. Get started »
Comments 1 - 10 of 10
 
Advertisment