The Case for Christ-Free Christmas

By Steve Shives, published Dec 22, 2007
Published Content: 66  Total Views: 6,349  Favorited By: 5 CPs
Rating: 4.3 of 5
Christmas is only a few days off, and I think it's as good a time as any to speak up for a segment of humanity that is too often ignored and forgotten by the media around the holidays. I speak up for this faction of society not only because I believe it to be vastly in the majority, but also because I happen to be a member. I'm talking about those of us who celebrate a secular Christmas.

My favorite time of year for as long as I can remember has been Christmas. As a child, I strung popcorn onto thread, hung ornaments from pine branches (we always bought a real tree back then), and stood alongside my mother as she baked cookies decorated with brightly colored red and green sugar. When I was young enough to still believe in him, I wrote letters to Santa Claus and left a plate cookies and a glass of milk out on the kitchen table for him. One year I even constructed a crude object d'art from yarn and glued-together popsicle sticks and left it out for Santa to take with him, labeling it in my letter simply "a toy." I figured he could deliver it to some underprivileged child behind the Iron Curtain who wouldn't know the difference. When I woke up that Christmas morning, my homemade toy was gone, and Santa thanked me for it in a note left on the kitchen table.

At the time it was a thrilling surprise, though now when I think about it, I am suspicious of the similarity of Santa's handwriting to that of my mother.

My mother's father was a minister. My father's upbringing wasn't nearly so religious, but he wasn't brought up an atheist, either. Mercifully, they both decided before I was born not to push religion on me. Except for a few months when I was in first grade, when Dad temporarily let his elderly grandmother guilt-trip him into it, we never attended church. Our Christmases were centered around Santa, snowmen, food, and family. And presents, naturally, which my younger brother and I soon realized were best of all.

South Park Santa.

Credit: Comedy Central

Copyright: Comedy Central

Comments
Showing Comments 1 - 12 of 12
 
 
Hannah is really getting on my last nerve. I've seen her on several articles spouting her religious views without listening to anyone else's opinions about WHY they're not religious. Great job Steve - I'm with you on the Christ-free Christmas :-)

Posted on 12/28/2007 at 4:12:45 AM

 
Really great article!

Posted on 12/25/2007 at 8:12:21 AM

 
Thank you, Hannah. The same to you and yours. Happy Christmas!

Posted on 12/25/2007 at 6:12:46 AM

 
Steve, Because I'm such a bigtime animal lover I don't believe in betaing a dead horse. One part of Christmas I know we can both agree upon is that it's about love of one another. I truly hope you and your family have a Happy Holiday!

Posted on 12/24/2007 at 7:12:57 PM

 
Excellent article, Steve! I, too, celebrate Secular Christmas. I love the lights and the trees but the baby in the manger and the rest of the myth and superstition that comes with the "religious holiday" is not for me. I am an Atheist, and I find it sadly ironic that the Religious Right rants about there being a war on Christmas. They criticize everyone for saying Happy Holidays, when all the Happy Holiday-sayers are doing is being inclusive. Those Christmas Warriors are a hypocritical bunch: they have no tolerance for other religions and insist that this is a "Christian nation" when it's not. It's a Secular nation. Merry Secular Christmas, Steve!

Posted on 12/24/2007 at 1:12:44 PM

 
I thank you for your comments, Hannah. I really don't see how my family celebrating Christmas as we always have, and as millions of other unreligious people always have, is disrespectful to anybody. As for the definition of Christmas, I think that varies depending on who you are. To some folks, like yourself and W.E. down there, it is narrowly defined as pertaining to the birth of Christ. For me, my family, and many other people I know, it has nothing to do with that, and, in our personal experiences, never has.

Posted on 12/24/2007 at 7:12:48 AM

 
Christmas for many has little to nothing to do with Jesus Christ, but for millions of others, He is the "reason for the season". It's become somewhat of a commercial holiday, I think we all know that, but for Christians, it will always be so much more. We don't really know when Christ was born, so Christians actually converted a pre-existing winter festival into what we now know as Christmas... it's been around for thousands of years. I believe in Jesus. It's a heart thing, a faith thing, a very real thing.

Posted on 12/24/2007 at 6:12:36 AM

 
I do thank you for trying to explain it. Do you know that the definition of secular is non-religous, without spiritual nature. The definition of Christmas is the celebration of the birth of Christ. So I guess untill you change the dictionary, a secular Christmas isn't possible. But honestly, you are being disresptful by degrading a Holy day to something it is not. No matter how hard you try, for whatever reasons you may have, you can't take someones Religious Holy Day and change it into whatever you feel like. At least not without being totally disrespectful to another's religion.

Posted on 12/23/2007 at 11:12:23 PM

 
And I call it "Christmas" because that's what it's called, not "Santamas." Conscience doesn't enter into it. I'm not a Christian, I don't think Jesus is my saviour, I reject the entire theology, so I have no reason to feel guilty about my Christ-less Christmas.

Posted on 12/23/2007 at 10:12:45 PM

 
It's really not as complicated as you're making it out to be. I'm not really celebrating anything, other than the fact that it's Christmas. I realize it's totally arbitrary, as though we just spun the calendar and picked a date for our number one holiday at random, but that's not it. I'm not TAKING the Christ out of Christmas -- for me, the Christ was never there in the first place.

Posted on 12/23/2007 at 10:12:59 PM

 
P.S. Isn't that like celebrating the 4th of July, just because you like hot dogs, instead of the meaning behind why we have the 4th of July, which is our Independence? I'm honestly trying to make sense out of this, but I find it imposible. If you want a Santa Day, why not at least be honest about it and call it "Santamas". or Santa Claus Day? Why use the term Christmas, which has Christ's name in it, if your not celebrating the birth of Christ? Truthfully, it is virtually impossible, and I think they also call it an oxymoron, to have a "Secular Christmas"! If it's a sacred day to you because of family, and friends, and Santa, then honestly in good conscience, you shouldn't call it Christmas!

Posted on 12/23/2007 at 8:12:25 PM

 
Okay so you celebrate "Mas", because you take the Christ out of Christmas. I'm confused, Santa came much later, but Christmas is still Christ's Birthday. So, aren't you actually celebrating Santa's bithday. What day was he born? Sorry, it just makes no sense. It's like I never understood Jews who celebrate Christmas either!

Posted on 12/23/2007 at 8:12:21 PM

Type in Your Comments Below
Your name:

Submit your own content on this or any topic. Get started »
Showing Comments 1 - 12 of 12
 
Most Commented On