A Hook Makes a Song but There is No Song Without the Hook?

In This Day and Age of Instant Gratification, a Good Hook Can Substitute Effectively for a Song

Listen to a few of your favorite songs on the radio closely. Better yet let's do a pop quiz, how many of you actually know the lyrics to your songs. A quick inventory of any of your top ten songs and your remembrance
 of their lyrics may suggest something telling, particularly if you're into pop music; you listen to the hook and memorize it quickly, which is in part your acculturation to the song, but you may not ever remember the lyrics at all whatsoever.

In some ways this is in part the way it has always been; for as long as I can remember I have known songs by their hook even before I knew the songs name. But in other ways producers and artists have capitalized off of this replacing meaningful lyrics with words that are "good enough" to get the listener through quickly to hear the hook again; hooks are repeated up to 16 times these days, bridges are forever and both can overshadow a song. What's worse is that some songs only have one or two verses.

Take a listen to your average Gwen Stefani song; in Hollaback Girl the first hook is repeated twice and then the second hook is repeated four times. The last verse doubles as a hook "It's Bananas ...", so in truth the song is overwhelmingly outdone by the hook. The lyrics themselves are brief and to the point. One of the singles off of her newest album "Now that You've Got It" isn't much different; the hook is modified and interspersed with the lyrics to the point where the two are indistinguishable from each other! Not to mention the structure of the first single off of that album "The Sweet Escape".

But I've often realized that my hottest songs that I can't do without are often formulated in this way, most of Fergie's songs are the same way, one of my favorite songs "Show Stopper" isn't but the lyrics are rather forgettable and the song may as well be. There is too tight of an integration between the girls voices and that of the accompanying track. When I finally listened to the rest of their debut album, I realized that the entire disc was the same way.

Related information
  • There are still good songwriters out there, yet it doesn't always pay to be one
  • My favorite cuts get my attention in two seconds or less
  • I'll come to appreciate serious songwriting eventually
 
Comments 1 - 2 of 2  
Comments
Type in Your Comments Below

Thanks. They say that everything has been done before, and in some ways that's true. But it's better to try to bring something unique, your own personality and soul, into the music than to copy something else. That way even if it isn't new at least they can't say that you didn't bring anything new to it.

Posted on 12/27/2007 at 11:12:51 AM

This was a really fun read! I personally believe that folks are running out of original ideas. Let's face it, every "new" song that you hear is comprised of licks and progressions that have already been beat to death. My son is a musical savant (no really) and he currently is the lead guitarist in a heavy metal band. He also loves classical music and is exploring ways to bring some originality to his band's music by combining several different styles. He admits that it is really hard to not appear like you are imitating someone else's work. Every new song I hear has a feel or vibe that reminds me of songs and/or bands from the past. Nice job on this one!

Posted on 12/27/2007 at 8:12:00 AM

Comments 1 - 2 of 2