Christopher Paolini - An Infamous Name in Fantasy Literature

Adjust font-size: + 
More:Christopher PaoliniEpic FantasyChild Prodigy
It has been said before, and nearly anyone familiar with Paolini and his writing will be aware of the fierce accusations surrounding him. One of these accusations is that he stole the 'words of power' system from Ursula
 K LeGuin, which LeGuin used in her Earthsea books. If you look at the intricacies of the magic systems between Earthsea and the Inheritance Trilogy, you will find, probably much to your dislike, that, indeed, Paolini stole (or, at least, 'was inspired by') the magic system the LeGuin used in Earthsea. They both focus around an Ancient Language, and the idea that everything has a name, and that, if you know something's True Name, the name of that thing in the Ancient Language, you will have power over it. While not directly related to LeGuin or Paolini, it is interesting to note the Jonathan Stroud, in his Bartimaeus Trilogy, makes reference to the 'True Names' of magicians, though in a different context.

Researching the magic systems being used by these two authors, I found that the 'words of power' and 'true names' type of systems are present in the native religions of indigenous peoples across the world.

While not an accusation, something that I noticed during my studies of old Celtic mythos, is Paolini's use of the name King Galbatorix. Galbatorix, in Inheritance, is the evil emperor which Eragon, the protagonist, is fighting against. Galbatorix seems to be Paolini's bastardization of the name Galbiorix, a name in Celtic mythology, which means 'king of the world' or something to that effect. Knowing that Paolini acknowledges in interviews that he likes 'good Norse dwarves' and basing the made-up languages he uses in Inheritance in old Germanic tongues, I can nearly guarantee you that Paolini, at least, once, came across the name Galbiorix and tweaked it to the purpose of Inheritance.

What also irks readers (myself included) is Paolini's writing style: excessive adverbs, the distinct lack of intelligence present in Eragon's character (almost everything he says is a question. Other than that, he doesn't seem like much of a protagonist, and more like a plot device to progress struggling story's arch of events.), the strange, sometimes seemingly silly twists that take place, and that Paolini rarely, if ever, simply says 'said'. 'Said' is always replaced by a non-transparent verb like, 'spoke' or 'bellowed', and various other things. Some speculate that Paolini must write with a thesaurus next to him.

 
Type in Your Comments Below

Rowling didn't copy.. Centaurs live in forests.... Her ideas are completely original, and it has earned her the best and fastest selling series of all time.
Christopher Paolini disgusts me. He doesn't have an original idea in his head. It was marketing that has earned him a following, not skill. They claim he was only fifteen when he wrote it, but in fact he was nineteen when it was published, so he doesn't have the excuse of naivety.
Paolini steals from about every story and is proud of it. So what if he is only 15; I wonder how much cussing Tolkien would yell at Paolini if he was alive? Add a Comment Posted on 05/31/2008 at 8:05:49 PM The plot line from Star Wars, names from Lord of the Rings, True Name idea from The Wizard of Earthsea. He can't write anything original and his plagiarism is so bad that he could probably lose a lawsuit. Add a Comment Posted on 12/03/2007 at 4:12:00 PM Who the hell does Paolini think he is, stealing ideas and being all proud about it Add a Comment Posted on 07/10/2008 at 9:07:25 PM I hated this book so much. I bought it because it looked interesting. Unfortunately, it's a total piece of shit. I'm angry that anyone likes this book it's so pathetic. I hadn't even READ the LOTR books, but I am a fan of the movies and everything was the same. He's got dwarves. He's got elves. He's got creatures so similar to Orcs it's crazy. Paolini probably thought that if he put in d
I hated this book so much. I bought it because it looked interesting. Unfortunately, it's a total piece of shit. I'm angry that anyone likes this book it's so pathetic. I hadn't even READ the LOTR books, but I am a fan of the movies and everything was the same. He's got dwarves. He's got elves. He's got creatures so similar to Orcs it's crazy. Paolini probably thought that if he put in dragons his story would be unique, but it's not. Dude's got to get a life and stop being published for being a crazed fanboy. Nobody appreciates plagiarism.
Whoever this Chris Pao no one little whelp is, he is a cunt. Forsooth.
I think Paolini is a brilliant author and I love his books.
wow. for someone at th age of 18 to compare himself to Tolkien can in no way shape or form be accurate. Tolkien was in World War I, Tolkien was well learned in language and northern European mythologies, Tolkien also wrote his work over his entire lifetime, Paolini has written his over a few years, Tolkien was a professor at Oxford, Paolini is still a kid, Tolkien faced obstacles from his who thought his works were terrible and without plot or drama and utterly pointless. When Tolkien could have been spending time working and developing ideas in his field of Anglo-Saxon, he was spending time writing his stories of Arda, which to his peers seemed pointless. Tolkien had many life experiences which fuel his verse and prose, and give it life and beauty. For someone so young to compare themselves to someone whose work was developed and changed and differed over nearly sixty years doesn't make sense to me.
Who the hell does Paolini think he is, stealing ideas and being all proud about it
Who the hell does Paolini think he is, stealing ideas and being all proud about it
I utterly despise Paolini's work.
Comments 1 - 10 (of 33) Next >>
Share
Tweet
Share on Facebook
Post a comment
33
54
I like this
Most Commented