10 Reasons Why You Should Not Purchase a Manufactured Home

Problems with Manufactured Homes

By Cheryl Carpenter, published Aug 29, 2006
Published Content: 1,001  Total Views: 569,119  Favorited By: 9 CPs
Rating: 2.1 of 5


The manufactured housing industry is booming. There is a reason for this occurrence. The main reason is because the up front cost to the customer is far less than that of a stick built home. Traditionally one may have less than perfect credit, and may be able to get into a home with as little as zero to five hundred dollars down.

I am not implying that there isn’t a place in our society for manufactured housing, but I feel the consumer has a right to make an informed decision. I have an 8-year history in the construction of manufactured housing so; I am going to give you a heads up on what is actually going on where these homes are concerned.

Manufactured homes are constructed in a factory. This is where they get their name. This is a large long narrow facility with open ends and sides. The first step in the construction of a home is the building of the chaise. Then the flooring is put into place followed by the vinyl flooring, and plumbing. The frame is moved down the line to the next station by the use of a pulley and chain. In this station, the walls are erected followed by the electrical work. The roof is installed in the following station as are  the windows. The home is then pulled out of the end of the building by tractor and returned to the other side of the building to the next station in line. While in this station, more windows are inserted. The cabinets and toilets are in place; as are fireplaces and doors. Time to move to the next station. Here the shingles and siding are attached to the home. Now the house is ready for the final stages.

In the final stages the home will have the carpet installed, curtains hung, trim attached, pudding of holes completed, electrical checks run and plumbing tested. Now the home is inspected and ready to be sealed up for shipment.

Takeaways
  • Electricians are not certified. They are just trained on the job.
  • Those that are not plumbers install plumbing.
  • On average a manufacturing facility will totally compete as many as 7 homes in one 8-hour workday
Did You Know?
: All manufactured homes are constructed with the same process. All homes use the same materials
Comments
Showing Comments 1 - 15 of 24
Next >>
 
I have two mobile homes, and the only thing they have in common is that their mobile.

Posted on 12/16/2007 at 3:12:04 AM

 
What gets me is thast fact that the people in the mobile home industry who post comments in forums about defective mobile home is, that they always want to compare it to a "stick built" home. Funny to me, when I complained to my manufacturer, Cavco Industries about the defects in my home, they want to compare it to a car. So why do they compare to a house, it doesn't have wheels. A car does, but at least you can take it to a place and get it fixed. Its a little hard to drag a mobile home down the highway. Mobile homes are constructed the same way. NONCOMPLIANT to federal regulations. Cheryl, I do know what you are saying. Don't let the mobile home industry people try to persuade you to think differently.

Posted on 07/10/2007 at 1:07:00 PM

 
At least one point in this article is factually incorrect. There are a number of manufactured home dealers here in Lafayette, Louisiana, and they do not use the assembly line process you are describing. The homes are basically constructed like any other home, but they are designed to be moved from the start. In other words, to say, "All manufactured homes are constructed with the same process. All homes use the same materials", is a falsehood. Blanket statements such as the above usually are.

Posted on 05/10/2007 at 5:05:00 PM

 
I would bet that most of the people commenting on the "unfairness" of this article are most likely associated with the mobile home industry. Grissim appears to know a few of the head honchos, want you to buy his book and then believe that mobile homes are ok. How these people can live with themselves, who knows. Trust the mobile home industry and you learn from your mistakes the hard way. Don't let these "industry" people dupe you into believing a mobile home is well built. My rear. Come look at my home. Come look at my Cavco...

Posted on 05/09/2007 at 10:05:00 AM

 
I've been waiting for 14 months now for my Silvercrest ME-19 (4 units wide, 3700 sq ft) to be finished. The dealer promised my home in 45 days. The home was placed on my site on December 20, 2005, and on December 29 the problems began with the foundation, piers, electrical, air conditioning, marriage lines, and now the latest is the roof is falling off, the struts in the truss are twisting, Solar Board is missing, the shingles were installed wrong, and the dealer and Silvercrest won't do anything to fix this. I'm now crossing my fingers thata HUD inspector and the Contractors State License Board to step in. I have approximately $50,000 worth of damages. I won't let these clowns repair anything any more. I want to hire my own contractors to finish the job and have the dealer/Silvercrest pay for it. Take a look at my personal website: www.designsbyelizabeth.com/roof.htm. Take a look at the pictures. A&A Mobile Home Service was the Setup Company and Sav-On Homes in Beaumont, CA

Posted on 02/12/2007 at 3:02:00 PM

 
My experience with R-Anell in Denver, NC has also been a nightmare. The house was originally appraised at $185,000 but later at$125,000 ( I paid almost $150,000)when the appariser discovered that the plans that R-Anell provided were not the plans of the house that was built.They also did not have a 3rd party inspection when they tore out a load bearing wall. The mechanical sub-contractor they hired did not install my heating-hvac by code. There is so much more, too.It's a mess!!

Posted on 12/31/2006 at 7:12:00 AM

 
Hello. This appears to be in many areas of the U.S. As I live in Texas and currently living through the worst nightmare I could imagine with a mobile home. To keep this short, you can read my stories at www.myfoxaustin.com. Look in the communities section for mobilehomeowner. See what all i've tried and what they have done. My family is living in a home that is falling apart. And it's only been two years that we've been fighting this mess. The same amount of time since we bought it. I would not recommend these homes to anyone.

Posted on 11/28/2006 at 7:11:00 AM

 
Cheryl Carpenter's devastating critique of manufactured homes contains some incorrect statements but clearly she's witnessed construction horror stories. She has a point. I would put it this way: Shoddy construction with cheap materials is all too common in low end homes, especially in the Southeast where Sun Belt weather is more forgiving and buyers are less sophisticated. I say this as the author of two consumer books, The Grissim Buyer's Guide to Manufactured Homes & Land and The Grissim Ratings Guide to Manufactured Homes. For the latter, I researched and interviewed all 83 MH builders in the U.S. and rated their quality. Yes, probably 85% of these homes are inferior to site-built homes. That leaves 15% that are as good or better, representing terrific quality and meaningful cost savings. I know. I live in one. The key: find a reputable dealer who stands behind the product.

Posted on 11/21/2006 at 1:11:00 PM

 
I have lived in a Patriot manufactured home for the last 3 years & after buying my home went to work for the retailer whom I bought my home from. I am more than happy with my home & have had none of the problems that you outlined in your article. As with any home it requires periodic maintenance & things will break with time & use. This is the first manufactured home I have ever lived in & would have no problems buying one again. As with any home, site built or manufactured, you should research the builder & ask informed questions regarding construction. Just out of curiosity, why did you spend 8 years in an industry that you obviously feel produces an inferior product?

Posted on 11/14/2006 at 12:11:00 PM

 
Exactly what factory was it that produces 7 homes a day?

Posted on 11/12/2006 at 9:11:00 PM

 
Although there are some errors of fact and exaggeration incorporated into your commentary, the only real critique I'd offer is that the failings you ascribe to mobile homes are equally applicable to site-built housing. Framing, plumbing, electrical, roofing and finish work are "supervised" by journeymen but actually done by whoever is handy. Inspection is usually cursory and uncritical. As a reporter who has covered the construction business for two decades, I can list endless horror stories about shoddy or downright dangerous materials and workmanship that have been incorporated into site-built homes, at all price levels. In fact, the growth field in class action litigation is in construction defect, solely due to the dubious quality of homes being built. Knowing what I do, would I buy a manufactured home? I did and would do so again. The quality has exceeded my expectations and the product support and warranty protection is vastly better than I could expect in site built construc

Posted on 10/11/2006 at 3:10:00 PM

 
No third party inspectors.

Posted on 09/28/2006 at 8:09:00 PM

 
Something that you don't mention at all is the entire process inside the plant is monitored by a third party inspection agency and is also monitored by HUD. I think your article was not at all fair to the thousands of people that work in these plants.

Posted on 09/26/2006 at 12:09:00 PM

 
You are soooo right - we had our "dream house" built by R-Anell two years - it's been a nightmare ever since. You are right on all 10 points, topped by the fact that this company is highly unethical.

Posted on 09/18/2006 at 8:09:00 AM

 
My words went too long but my advice to any prospective purchasers is to have a licensed home inspector inspect your unit before the warranty is anywhere near expiration. The few hundred dollars up front could save you thousands down the road. It will allow a peace of mind that older owners will never know!

Posted on 09/12/2006 at 11:09:00 AM

Type in Your Comments Below - (1000 characters left)
Your name:

Submit your own content on this or any topic. Get started »
Showing Comments 1 - 15 of 24
Next >>
Most Commented On